“In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.” Gen. 2:17. A number of inquiries have been received regarding the nature of the death that was threatened our first parents as a punishment for partaking of the forbidden fruit.
So far as we are informed, commentators and lexicographers are agreed that the words translated “thou shalt surely die,” may with equal correctness, be rendered, “dying thou shalt die.” This form of expression is given in the margin of the Bible as the literal Hebrew rendering. As we understand the matter, the sentence pronounced against Adam was equivalent to telling him that in the day that he should partake of the forbidden fruit he would become mortal, enter upon a dying condition, in which he would continue until death in its completeness—an utter cessation of life—should be reached. With regard to the duration of the condition of death that Adam should thus enter upon, there was no intimation that it was to be otherwise than perpetual. No evidence exists, that we are aware of, that the sentence of death was based upon, or contained any promise of release for those who should suffer its execution.
The question turns upon the time when the plan of salvation was formed. John 3:16 states that “God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish but have everlasting life.” It follows that previous to the time that God thus gave his Son, the prospect before the human race was that of utterly perishing; of suffering a death from which there would be no resurrection; and escape from that fate was impossible, with the then existing conditions. We cannot conceive that the plan of salvation was formed until there was need of such a plan; otherwise the fall of man was necessitated, for it is not to be presumed that God does anything in vain. We do not deny God’s foreknowledge of man’s fall and of his need of a Saviour; but foreknowledge does not imply foreordination. We do not deny that God foreknew that in the event of man’s fall, his Son was the only being who could supply the needed sacrifice, and means of redemption. But it must be remembered that foreknowledge does not interfere in the slightest degree with the exercise of free moral agency. If God is infinite in his power of foreknowledge, he foreknows our motives, and that what we do or refrain from doing, is the result of the free exercise of our faculties. But this is a diversion.
One of the conditions of the plan of salvation was that Christ should obtain possession of the keys of the grave (Rev. 1:18) whereby he would be able to release all prisoners therefrom. The Emphatic Diaglott gives a rendering of 2 Tim. 1:10 that makes this matter very clear: “Christ Jesus, who has indeed rendered death powerless.” Then, before it was planned that Christ should so obtain possession ofp. 586 the keys of Satan’s prison-house, death had power to retain its victims irrecoverably, for Satan releases none of them. Isa. 14:12-17.
As there are some texts of Scripture that may be thought to militate against the claim that the plan of salvation was not formed until after the fall of man, we will consider them.
Rev. 13:8: “And all that dwell upon the earth shall worship him, whose names are not written in the book of life of the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world.” It is thought that this text proves that the plan of salvation was formed from the foundation of the world. We think, however, that upon a critical examination it will be found that such is not the case. The Emphatic Diaglott renders the text thus: “And all who dwell on the earth shall worship him whose name has not been written from the foundation of the world in the scroll of the life of that Lamb who was killed.” Wakefield gives substantially the same rendering, also the Danish and Swedish versions, and others that we might mention. Meyer, who is called the “prince of exegetes,” says that the phrase translated “from the foundation of the world” belongs to the writing of the names, and not to the slaying of the Lamb. He quotes Hammond, Bengel, Heinrichs, Ewald, Züllig, De Wette, and Hengstenberg, as supporting this view. Scott, Barnes, Dean Alford, and the Cottage Bible all admit that such a construction is allowable. With such a construction the idea is this: There is a book of life, in which have been written the names of subjects of the everlasting kingdom of the Lamb that was slain. The use of this book for the purpose named, dates from the foundation of the world. This book belongs to Christ, and he has said, “He that overcometh, the same shall be clothed in white raiment; and I will not blot out his name out of the book of life.” Rev. 3:5. As different individuals have entered the kingdom of grace, from time to time, during the history of the race, their names have been recorded in the book of life, and all who prove faithful in the work of overcoming, will have their names retained, and eventually be redeemed.
But if more conclusive evidence is wanted to show that the expression, “from the foundation of the world,” refers to the writing of the names, and not to the slaying of the Lamb, we will find it in Rev. 17:8: “And they that dwell on the earth shall wonder, whose names were not written in the book of life from the foundation of the world.” In this text, which is a parallel to chap. 13:8, the writing of the names in the book of life is distinctly stated as that which dates with the foundation of the world. We present this text as a divine commentary on chap. 13:8, and as giving an interpretation at once consistent and conclusive.
1 Peter 1:19, 20: “But with the precious blood of Christ, as of a lamb without blemish and without spot: who verily was foreordained before the foundation of the world.” There is no statement in this text or its connections, to show for what Christ was foreordained. It is not said that he was foreordained to be the “lamb without blemish.” Let it be interpreted that he was foreordained to be the possessor of a kingdom, and no difficulty is experienced. Had not man sinned, but continued in obedience, Christ would have come into possession of his kingdom as it was foreordained that he should; but the fall occurring, there must needs be another way provided; for God’s plan cannot be frustrated. That new way was the plan of salvation, and this necessitated that Christ should obtain possession of his kingdom by way of the cross.
But there is another explanation to be given of the text last quoted. The word rendered “foreordained” in our common version, is rendered “foreknown” in the Diaglott, also in the revised version. Several prominent commentators agree to this, and Meyer quotes Kühl as saying that the meaning of the expression is, “foreknown as the one who alone would be qualified to be the Messiah and Redeemer.” But as has been previously stated (and as was conclusively shown in No. 12, present volume of the REVIEW), God’s foreknowledge of what is to occur, does not imply that he determined beforehand that it should occur.
2 Tim. 1:9: “Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began.” The question at issue, as affected by this text, turns on the signification of the phrase, “before the world began.” Wakefield translates it “before the ages;” the revised version, “before times eternal;” Young’s Analytical Concordance, “before the times of the ages.” Robinson’s Greek and English Lexicon defines the terms as meaning in this instance, “before the ages, worlds, from eternity.” Rotherham renders it “before remote—age, times.”
There are two interpretations that may be given of this text, both of which are consistent with the views heretofore presented, and neither of which admits the formation of the plan of salvation previous to the fall of Adam: First, by the expression given in our common version, “before the world began,” the apostle intended simply to make an indefinite reference to the remote point of time when the Saviour was promised, as recorded in Gen. 3:15. This idea is very clearly expressed by the rendering given by Rotherham, “before remote—age, times,” and concurred in by Wakefield and Young, above quoted. This view is rendered plausible by the tenth verse—“But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ.” With this interpretation, the apostle is made to convey the idea that the purpose and grace of God, that was manifested in the promise of a Saviour, which promise was made in very remote ages, is now manifested by the actual appearance of that Saviour.
The second interpretation that may be given is this: Before the world began, the purpose and grace of God concerning the beings that should people it, was that they should be the subjects of his Son’s kingdom. They were placed on probation, and God’s purpose was, that in the event of their successfully passing that probation, this earth, with its perfected race, should be the everlasting kingdom of Christ Jesus. But the race fell, and forfeited all right and title to its prospective inheritance, and with the then existing conditions, there was no possibility for it to have a second trial. But Christ, “having loved his own which were in the world” (John 13:1), proposed to lay down his life for the lost sheep (chap. 10:15), and now we see that same purpose and grace of God manifested by the actual appearance of God’s only Son as the Saviour of the fallen race. Thus in any event, whether we consider the race before or since its fall, it was and is connected, in the purpose and grace of God, with his Son Christ Jesus.
There are several texts, the signification of which is rendered very clear with the foregoing interpretation in view: “Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who hath blessed us with all spiritual blessings in heavenly places in Christ: according as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before him in love: having predestinated us unto the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to himself, according to the good pleasure of his will.” Eph. 1:3-5. By locating the choice and predestination here referred to, as having been made before the fall, and with the opportunity in view for man to successfully pass his probation, the beauty and force of the language is apparent.
“In hope of eternal life, which God, that cannot lie, promised before the world began.” Titus 1:2. The eternal life that we have set before us, is the same life, upon the same earth, and with the same King, that was set before the race, previous to its fall.
“For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the first-born among many brethren. Moreover, whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.” Rom. 8:29, 30. God’s foreknowledge of man, with respect to his being saved, consisted in knowing that he would need a plan of salvation. His predestination consisted in predestinating that those who should accept of the conditions of that plan of salvation, should be conformed to the image of his Son, and experience the new birth in its completeness. The “predestination” spoken of in Paul’s second statement is reached by the same method as in the first statement. He says that those “whom he did predestinate” were also called, and such is the case; for the call extends to all the human race. Rev. 22:17; 2 Pet. 3:9. Those who accept the call, and comply with the conditions of the plan of salvation, and thus become predestinated, receive justification, and finally, glorification. The signification of these texts may be made clearer by reversing the order of considering the points named. Those who are finally glorified, are made so because they were justified. They received justification because they became predestinated to that condition in consequence of accepting of the call. Take also the first series in the same manner. Those who will experience the new birth in its completeness, do so because they had become conformed to the image of Jesus Christ. They became thus conformed because of the predestination to which they were entitled, in consequence of complying with the conditions of the plan of salvation that was provided by God’s foreknowledge of man’s necessities. This is the only view of foreordination that does not charge God with folly in imposing conditions in the plan of salvation, and that does not destroy man’s free moral agency. G. W. Morse.