MUNSEY ON THE LAW

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 8, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 19.

Read the full edition

MUNSEY ON THE LAW.

[ALMOST every person here in the South is, I suppose, familiar with the name of Wm. E. Munsey, the great Southern Methodist orator, now deceased. In his sermons on the law (of which there are three), he so forcibly presents the views which we entertain on this subject, that I cannot refrain from making the following extracts from them. W. R. Patterson.]
The moral law is an expression of God's will, and God's will is God's nature. It is not arbitrary, for it arises out of relations; yet relations, when properly traced, rest finally and primarily in the nature of God. . . . This process of reasoning being true, what principles must necessarily constitute the structure of a code of laws for the government of moral beings, if there are such beings?—The principles of his moral nature, as a matter of course.
The law accepted in God's nature must be the law given to govern the nature of his subjects. It must be one like his moral character—not contrary to it. . . . The perfections of God's moral nature are holiness, justice, goodness, and truth. Its essence is love. The law for the government of moral beings, or moral law, being necessarily a copy of his moral nature, must then be holy, requiring perfect purity of character. It must be inflexibly and immutably just, recognizing the divine right of the Lawgiver to make laws, the obligation and duty of its subjects to obey, defining its sanctions and apportioning them according to merit. It must be the truth—an exact representation of the whole nature of God, and certain and veracious in its retributions. It must be good, embodying the divine benevolence and excellency, to make it admired and elevating, and to promote the happiness of the subject in the ratio with his obedience. Its essence and actuating principle must be love to the utmost compass of its requirements, and the utmost boundary of its application. To epitomize it, the law must be holy, just, good, and truthful. It is the grand law of love, the exact transcript of God. . . .
Let us see what its character is as revealed in the Bible. Paul says in Rom. 7:12: “The law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good.” The psalmist says, “Thy law is the truth.” The law according to these scriptures is holy, just, good, and truthful. Now, what is revealed as the essence? Paul says, “Love is the fulfilling of the law.” Christ says: “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind . . . and . . . thy neighbor as thyself. On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.” Again we arrive at the same result. Reason as we may, from the character of God; from the nature of man's relations; from the express revelations of the Holy Scriptures, and we discover it is the same law of love—holy, just, good, and truthful. . . . The moral law is immutable. It is unchangeable in its principles and requirements from its very nature. It is a perfect and accurate transcript of the perfections of God's nature. It could not therefore change, unless God's nature changed. . . . God cannot repeal it or give another, without contradicting his own nature, consequently destroying himself. God “cannot lie,” and his law is but the truth of every relation out of which it springs in living expression. The relation an intelligent creature sustains to God and his fellows, is not fictitious, but real; hence a truth. The law prescribing duty arising out of such relations, if it be a natural, spontaneous result, is but the character of the relation duplicated; therefore it is truth; and truth from its very nature cannot change without losing its entire character as truth, therefore its existence.
[In speaking of the giving of this law, he uses the following language:—]
God the Lawgiver was upon his throne. A trumpet as terrible as the trumpet of the judgment, which will wake the dead, announced his presence. A trumpet summoned humanity to receive the law; the same trumpet will summon humanity to be judged by the law. Still sounded the awful trumpet, and its thunder-blasts shook the mountains. Moses trembled, the people fled from the mount. Inexorable law was king this day. If man has not a mediative Moses to ascend the mount, man is undone. But louder, and still louder, sounded the trumpet, and its thunder tones forming words, shaped themselves into a curse: “Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them.” And the dreadful curse significant of law's aspect to a sinner, like a red-hot bolt from heaven's artillery, went roaring down the centuries.
[Using Rom. 3:31 for his text, Mr. Munsey commences “discourse No. 2” with these words:—]
God's law cannot pardon. No law can; call it law of the gospel, law of Christ, law of faith, or what you will, if it is law it cannot pardon. Organization is necessary to the existence, identity, stability, and harmony of God's moral government. Law is the essential basis of all organization. In fact, there is no government without organization. And there is no organization without law. The conclusion is, Law is a necessity. If law is essential to organization, and organization is essential to government, then the violation of law produces disorganization, and is destructive of government. This destruction and disorganization constitutes a penalty of law, and follows the violation of law with the certainty of cause and effect. The law which preserves and protects the obedient subject, destroys him when disobedient. [Italics mine.] And man can see from the nature of the penalty of law, that as law is a necessity to organization, so penalty is necessary to God's law—both are necessities. This being true, pardon, which implies to set aside the penalty, is impossible in a system of law.
If law can pardon, it can destroy itself. If it does pardon, it does destroy itself; it renders itself null; it is to lower its demands; it is to violate every relation upon which it is founded; it is to make God encourage sin. Inexorable and unbending, it demands satisfaction commensurate with the criminality of the guilt. Its holiness, goodness, justice, truth, and essence make it unpardoning. Each quality does it; united they do it. Paul recognizes so much when he says: “If there had been a law given which could have given life, verily righteousness should have been by the law.” Law cannot pardon. Mr. Fletcher, the author of the celebrated “Checks to Antinomians,” says that “gospel law,” as distinguished from “Adamic law” can [pardon], and that we are under a law adapted to our present state and circumstances, which he terms a “milder law.” He speaks of an “evangelical, mediatorial, remedying law of our Redeemer” as distinguished from what he terms the “anti-evangelical, Christless, remediless law of the Creator,” by which he means the great moral law given to Adam. The phrases “gospel law” and “Adamic law” are a perplexing misapplication of terms. There is no such thing as gospel law, unless is meant by it the mode of gospel action, as Paul frequently uses the phrase; and you may as well say, “Abrahamic law,” “Davidic law,” “Calvinic law,” and “Wesleyan law,” because such persons as Abraham, David, Calvin, and Wesley were subject to it, as to say “Adamic law” because Adam was subject to it. The distinction itself is absurd!
If any part of the gospel be law as distinguished from the great moral law of God, it must be something more or less than that law; it must add something to it, or take something from it, or there is no distinction; and the very idea of its perfection forbids either. If it does superinduce something upon the law, it only makes the law more condemnatory; hence, if possible, less disposed to pardon. If it takes something from it, and becomes indeed a “milder law,” it involves the absurdity of God compromising with sin, of compromising with man, because man had willfully transgressed his law, which being created holy, he could have kept—and that man was placed under a law which required imperfect obedience and an imperfect holiness. That God would even bend his law to the contracted capabilities of the creature for obedience, in place of strengthening those capabilities to the full measure of the law's requirements, is an animadversion upon his holiness—much less that he would stoop to a compromise so utterly contradictory to his nature.
As to the “evangelical, mediatorial, remedying law of our Redeemer,” there is no authority for its existence in the Bible. A law essentially possessing such elements, the very elements qualified to rob it of its sanctions, to neutralize and destroy its penalty forever, is surely bent upon self-destruction. . . . This great moral law is universal. Its origin, nature, principles, and requirements indicate its universality. It is the law governing angels and archangels. It is the law governing every intelligent creature on all worlds, and I believe there are a million of worlds crowded with intelligent beings. It is the law under which Adam was placed. The commandment visible upon the surface, was not the whole of that law—Adam's nature and relation to God forbid it. Yet the commandment given him to test his obedience, as the representative of his race, involved at once the great principles underlying the construction of moral law,—the right of God to govern, and the duty of man to obey. It brought man at once under the law of love—under its protection if he obeyed, under its curse if he disobeyed. It was nothing distinct from the great moral law, but a peculiar manifestation of it, perceived by infinite wisdom to be adapted to such a state of trial as Adam occupied, both as a person and as the representative of his children. The result is seen in the tragical history of the race, with its thrilling records of sin, misery, and woe. Man fell under the curse of God's law, and remaining of himself under the curse is evidence of the continued authority of the law [italics mine]. . . .
It is the law under which we are placed—call it Adamic, angelic, or what we will—and if the law under which intelligent beings are placed must necessarily be a transcript of the divine perfections, it can no more change than God's perfections can change. If it cannot change, it is perfect, hence could not under any circumstances be abrogated or substituted. If it is perfect, it must require perfect obedience;—God's nature would not let him accept anything less;—hence it is perpetually binding. . . . If he (man) is under another (law), God's character and man's relations require that it must be precisely like the first; and if like the first, it must require perfect obedience and have the same penalty. This is precisely like what tradition says the legislature of Virginia once did. In order to retain a member of its body who had fought a duel, it repealed the law against dueling, admitted the transgressing member to his seat, then, for the good of the old commonwealth, immediately re-enacted the law. Take your seat, sir. Assume the privileges of a peer in this legislative body; the law you violated we abrogated; the law you are under you have not broken.
[This is but a fair sample of the reasoning of those who attempt to prove the abolition of God's law of ten commandments at the cross. We submit it to the antinomian reader for his consideration; also the next quotation, as follows:—]
That Christ met the claims of the moral law, and thereby released us from them [this is exactly what antinomians assert], placing us under the gospel law, is happily answered by Dr. Fisk, in this short sentence: “Sins atoned for,” then, “need no pardon, and sins pardoned need no atonement. That is, pardon and atonement do not meet, in reference to the claims of the same law.” 1. Adam broke the moral law. 2. The atonement was made with reference to the violated claims of that law. 3. If the law cannot pardon, we have pardon only through virtue of that atonement. 4. The sins pardoned must be offenses of the great moral law of God, with reference to which the atonement was instituted. 5. And if there be offenses against that law, that law must be in force. Pardon and atonement must meet with reference to the claims of the same law.
That we are under the law given to Adam is clear from the federal representative character of Christ. We were placed upon probation in Adam, and fell. For our restoration we were placed upon probation a second time in Christ our representative, who is called the second Adam. If in our representative we broke the great moral law of God, which is true in a certain sense, Jesus Christ, our second representative, in order to redeem, must come under the same law, obey it, and suffer its curse. He must obey the law violated at first, in order to redeem us from under the penalty of that law. For certainly we were under the penalty of no law save the law violated. Indeed, if the law had been abrogated, there would have been no necessity for a Saviour.