AN OLD ERROR DYING OUT

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 8, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 19.

Read the full edition

AN OLD ERROR DYING OUT.

It is pleasing to note how rapidly in various portions of Christendom, the unscriptural doctrine of the immortality of the soul, involving, as it does, the God-dishonoring theory of everlasting torture in an ever-burning hell, is giving place to the more reasonable teaching of the Bible that immortality is conditional, and man has no hope of an eternal existence outside of Christ.
A recent Chicago paper published a telegram from London stating that a number of teachers had been expelled from Mr. Spurgeon's Sunday-school because they refused to believe in the doctrine of eternal torture.
The same paper took occasion to note the rapid advancement which the denial of this doctrine of endless conscious misery is making in Chicago, not only among laymen, but clergymen as well. It speaks of the formation of a society, in September last, called the “Conditional Immortality Association,” and mentions six pastors of churches, several Baptist deacons, besides prominent scholars and business men, who belong to it.
Thus men are gradually awakening to the fact that the world has been laboring under a gigantic delusion; that for fifteen centuries the church has been teaching error; that man does not by nature possess an immortal soul; that the idea of natural immortality is simply an ignis fatuus; that a person can secure eternal life only by connecting himself with Christ the Lifegiver, and being made through him fit for an endless existence; that eternal life is a gift, the unspeakable gift, of God, to those who by seeking it on the conditions he has prescribed, prove themselves worthy of it; while upon those who persistently reject the conditions and refuse the gift, God will bestow the wages of sin, which is death; that is, make the best disposition that can be made of them, by granting them their choice, and remanding them back into the condition they were in before they had any conscious being.
One of the members of this association was asked if this was not a new doctrine. The answer was, “No; it is as old as the Bible itself. It is as old as Christ. Not one word or hint of natural immortality can be found in the writings of the earlier Fathers. They uniformly speak of immortality and eternal life as the gift of God to the redeemed, while the wicked are doomed to everlasting destruction. It was not till after Platonism had been engrafted upon the religion of Christ in the second century, that we find any other doctrine. This is not the faith that was delivered to the saints, and it is high time that Christians returned to the simple faith of the gospel as taught by the Master himself.”
Being questioned as to the object of their association, the member gave the reporter this answer: “It is to bring the church back to first principles. We have not started a new sect, and do not intend to. We retain our places in our old churches, and expect to remain in them. We have merely formed a society for the purpose of propagating this one idea—fitness and faith the conditions of immortality; for all others death, and not eternal conscious suffering. I do not think our churches will expel us for teaching this, or that teachers will be discharged from American Sunday-schools for refusing to teach the children that there is an eternity of torture staring them in the face.”