Court Dialogue on Leniency in a Murder Plea

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 8, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 19.

Read the full edition

Court Dialogue on Leniency in a Murder Plea

THE Christian at Work prints the following dialogue as having taken place recently in the Court of General Sessions in New York City. The occasion was the examination of a prisoner who had committed a cold-blooded and unprovoked murder, and had, by the advice of his counsel, pleaded guilty to murder in the second degree. Judge Martino said:—
“The District Attorney has examined the case very fully, and, has recommended that the plea of murder in the second degree be accepted by the court.”
“I thank the District Attorney’s office for its leniency,” said Mr. Purdy.
“It is not necessary, Mr. Purdy,” said Judge Martino. “A large portion of this community seems to be against hanging for murder. Jurors in these courts frequently refuse to convict of murder in the first degree, even where the evidence warrants such a verdict.”
To which the Christian at Work adds this comment: “In other words, ‘A large portion of this community seems to be against hanging for murder,’ therefore it is not necessary to thank the court for leniency, as the court will presumably grant leniency under the circumstances!’ This is strange doctrine for Judge Martino to declare from the bench: it is little less than a notification to murderers that whatever happens to them, at least one court will not hang them, because ‘a large part of this community seems to be against hanging for murder.’”