HOW LONG DID CHRIST LIE IN THE GRAVE?
We noticed last week one of the assumptions on which the seventy-two-hour theory rests; namely, that the expression “three days and three nights,” must mean just seventy-two hours. It appears from the use of equivalent expressions in the Scriptures, that it was the custom of Bible writers to use the phrase “three days and three nights” to signify a period less than seventy-two hours; and the fact that they so used it, utterly destroys it as proof that Christ must lie in the tomb just seventy-two hours.
The other leg of that theory is a more glaring assumption still; namely, that the expression, “heart of the earth,” means the grave. If it does not mean that, then the structure built upon their main proof text (Matt. 12:40) suffers an utter collapse. But, we ask, where is the proof that “heart of the earth” means “grave”? We have, time and again, called for proof on this point, but have never yet succeeded in securing any response. We have carefully searched through a dozen arguments on that side of the question, and not the first attempt do we find to prove that “heart of the earth” means the “grave.” The quiet assurance with which all these writers take this point for granted, the nonchalance, sang-froid, indifference, and obliviousness, with which they pass it by, is astonishing. What can be said to awaken in their minds the idea that here is a point that must be proved, before their theory will stand?
We deny that the heart of the earth has any more to do with the grave than it has with the moon, and we would like to see at least an attempt at proof that it means the grave.
The word “heart” primarily means the organ by which the circulation of the blood is kept up in the body. Of course it is not here used in that sense; nor is it used in its secondary sense of the “seat of the affections;” nor yet in its third meaning, as “the part nearest the center,” as the “heart of a tree,” the “heart of a country,” etc.; for Christ was not buried in the center of the earth. Evidently the sense in which it is used is a figurative one; but what is there about the grave, to make such a figure appropriate, as applied to it?—Nothing whatever. But if the heart of the earth does not mean the grave, then, even if three days and three nights mean absolutely seventy-two hours, it is not proved that Christ was to lie in the tomb that length of time. These are the two main pillars of the theory; and both of these are assumptions.
That this view has been adopted by the few who entertain it, with a good motive, we have no question. It has seemed to them a masterly stroke of policy to destroy the Sunday error at one blow. Thus a friend wrote us recently from Colorado: “But if their [the Sunday-keepers’] principal and fundamental premise—‘Jesus rose on Sunday’—appears uncertain, or is false, all arguments, premises, and conclusions of Sunday advocates are ruined at once. It supersedes the necessity, on our part, of following them through all their arguments of assumption, etc., and compels them to acknowledge that the weapon they hold in their hand is only an illusion.”
This would be true only on one condition, and that is, that the Sunday-keeper would acknowledge that the position of the Sabbath-keeper was correct, that Christ did not rise on Sunday. But this is just what he will not do, and what the Sabbath-keeper cannot prove. Then what advantage is gained?
Let us imagine an attempt to meet a Sunday-keeper on this ground. The Sunday-keeper says, “I keep Sunday because the Lord arose from the dead on that day.” The Sabbath-keeper replies that he is wrong to keep it for that reason, because Christ did not arise from the dead on that day. He must have arisen the evening before the first day; for he was put into the tomb near the close of some day, and was to remain in the heart of the earth three days and three nights, just seventy-two hours, hence his resurrection must have taken place at about the close of the Sabbath, and not on Sunday at all. And his crucifixion was on the preceding Wednesday. The Sunday-keeper asks him to prove that the phrase “three days and three nights” means just seventy-two hours, confining the resurrection to the close of the day; and that the “heart of the earth” means the “grave.”
The issue of the controversy is now shifted from the Sabbath question proper to that of the time of Christ’s resurrection. And giving it such a turn implies that the resurrection of Christ has a decisive bearing on the question as to which day is the Sabbath, which is wholly untrue; the Sabbath-keeper takes upon himself propositions which it is impossible for him to prove, and the vantage ground every way is given to the Sunday-keeper. Such is the position a person puts himself in, who undertakes to work the Sunday question on this line of argument. The Sunday-keeper retires from the field triumphant, confirmed in his conviction that the resurrection of Christ determines the day of the Sabbath, and that that day is Sunday. It must, therefore, inevitably prove a damage, rather than a help, to the Sabbath cause; which is the second indictment we hold against this view.
We believe it is acknowledged to be a sound principle in all discussions, to go as far as possible with an opponent, reducing the issue to as small a compass and as few particulars as practicable; for in this way can questions be the soonest and most satisfactorily settled. But the method here referred to enlarges, rather than contracts, the field of discussion, and that, too, on an issue for which there is no foundation whatever. When the Sunday-keeper claims the first-day institution on the fact of Christ’s resurrection upon that day, grant him his supposed fact, even if only for the sake of the argument; and then show him that though this was the case, it has not the remotest bearing on the question of which day is the Sabbath, and affords no ground whatever for the observance of the first day of the week. And let the reader be assured that this can be done a thousand-fold more easily than you can convince the Sunday-keeper that Christ did not rise on the first day of the week. The object would be as fully gained by the first proposition as it would be by the second, even if the second could be established; and the first can be easily proved, while the second cannot be. Under these circumstances, why take the impossible side?
Before we proceed to examine the Scriptures on the subject, a word may be in place concerning that peculiar phrase, “the heart of the earth.” We have already noticed some things to which it cannot refer. Let us now consider what it may mean. It seems very clear that the word “earth” is here used in the same sense in which it is used in Isa. 1:2: “Give ear, O earth;” and in Jer. 22:29: “O earth, earth, earth, hear the word of the Lord.” Here the word is used to denote the wicked inhabitants of the earth. Satan is the god of this world, the head of its prevailing multitudes, who constitute the children of the wicked one. Into the hands of these the Son of man was to be for a time delivered. Christ often makes a special point of this: “The Son of man shall be betrayed into the hands of men.” Matt. 17:22. “The Son of man is betrayed into the hands of sinners.” Matt. 20:18. And this is what we understand he meant by declaring that he should be “in the heart of the earth;” that is, under the full control and power of wicked men and devils, so that they could accomplish the evil desires of their hearts concerning him. And when he was thus delivered over to them, he declared plainly, “This is your hour, and the power of darkness.” Luke 22:53.
In nine instances where it is declared that he will rise on the third day, the betrayal, trial, and crucifixion are specified as included in the events to occur during the three days; and from the first of these, and not from the burial, the period is to be reckoned. Thus, Matt. 16:21: “From that time forth began Jesus to show unto his disciples, how that he must go unto Jerusalem, and suffer many things of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and be raised again the third day.” Matt. 17:22, 23: “The Son of man shall be betrayed into the hands of men, and they shall kill him, and the third day he shall be raised again.” Matt. 20:18, 19: “The Son of man shall be betrayed unto the chief priests and unto the scribes, and they shall condemn him to death, and shall deliver him to the Gentiles to mock and to scourge, and to crucify him; and the third day hep. 489 shall rise again.” Mark 9:31: “The Son of man is delivered into the hands of men, and they shall kill him; and after that he is killed, he shall rise the third day.” Mark 10:33, 34: “The Son of man shall be delivered unto the chief priests, and unto the scribes; and they shall condemn him to death, and shall deliver him to the Gentiles; and they shall mock him, and scourge him, and spit upon him, and shall kill him; and the third day he shall rise again.” Luke 18:32, 33: “For he shall be delivered unto the Gentiles, and shall be mocked, and spitefully entreated, and spitted on; and they shall scourge him and put him to death; and the third day he shall rise again.” Luke 24:7: “The Son of man must be delivered into the hands of sinful men, and be crucified, and the third day rise again.” Verses 20, 21: “And how the chief priests and our rulers delivered him to be condemned to death, and have crucified him. But we trusted that it had been he which should have redeemed Israel; and besides all this, to-day is the third day since these things were done.” Verse 46: “Thus it behooved Christ to suffer, and to rise from the dead the third day.”
In all these scriptures it will be noticed that his being given over “into the hands of men,” “the hands of the Gentiles,” and “the hands of sinners,” is made equally prominent with the other events; and the trial and condemnation and crucifixion are inseparably connected with the resurrection, as coming within the three days. During all this time he was “in the heart of the earth”—that is, in the power of sinful men. This idea corresponds much better with the case of Jonah. He was in the stomach of the fish, under the control of a living monster, not merely dead earth; so Christ was under the domination of living men and devils. He was no more in the heart of the earth when in the grave, than he was when hanging upon the cross; no more in the heart of the earth when in the tomb, than he was when the mob had secured actual control over him, after his betrayal by Judas.
Reckoning from this point, how much time have we? Near the close of the day on Thursday, he prepared to eat the passover with his disciples. The evening following (Thursday night as we would now call it; Friday, or sixth day, night as it was then), Judas and his mob came out with torches, and swords, and staves, and he was betrayed into their hands. All that night and the next day till the third hour, was occupied with the trial; from the third to the ninth hour with the crucifixion. From about the ninth hour to the beginning of the seventh day, the burial was attended to. All that night, the day following, and the succeeding night were passed by him in the tomb. Early on the morning of the first day of the week, he arose. This gives us three full nights, two full days, and a portion of the third day, making it strictly true that on the third day he arose. The following diagram will illustrate these points:—
REFERENCES.—1. The betrayal, near the beginning of the sixth day of the week. 2. The trial, to the third hour of the following day. 3. The crucifixion, from the third to the ninth hour of the sixth day. 4. The burial, between the ninth hour and the close of the day. 5. The rest in the tomb during the night and day of the seventh day, and the night of the first day. 6. The resurrection, early the first day of the week. Mark 16:9.
Remember that when Christ said to the chief priests and captains of the temple, who had come out to take him, “This is your hour and the power of darkness” (Luke 22:52, 53), he set apart a peculiar period in his experience during which he was in the hands of men. “This was the time when he was ‘in the heart of the earth.’” It began with his betrayal, at the beginning of the sixth day, and ended with the resurrection, on the morning of the first day of the week. Thus it will be seen that all was in strict accordance with the Jewish manner of reckoning time, as in Gen. 42:17, 18; 2 Chron. 10:5, 12; Esther 4:16; 5:1; and with the manner in which both Christ and Paul reckoned the third day (Luke 13:31, 32; Acts 27:18, 19); and with Christ’s repeated declarations that on the third day after his betrayal into the hands of men, his suffering and death, he would rise again.
It now only remains to examine the direct testimony of the Scriptures on these points, which must be deferred to another number.