I have to-day finished a two days' discussion on the Sabbath question, with Eld. Smith (United Brethren).
Question: Resolved, that the Bible teaches that the Seventh-day Sabbath, called Saturday, was God's rest-day at creation, was sanctified and blessed by the Lord, and, by the authority of the fourth commandment, is binding under the new covenant.
By request of the brethren, I present for publication a brief synopsis of my argument, giving the scriptures used. During my first thirty minutes, remarks were founded on Matt. 17: 5, last clause; Deut. 18: 18, 19; John 12: 48-50; 14: 23, 24; Acts 3: 22, 23; 2 Thess. 1: 7-9; Ps. 40: 7-10; Isa. 42: 21; Matt. 5: 17-20; 15: 1-9; 19: 16, 17; Rom. 2: 13; Rev. 22: 13, 14; Ps. 89: 27-34; Col. 1: 12-19; Heb. 8: 1, 2; 9: 1-10, 19-24; Rev. 11: 19. The opponent did not try to refute these scriptures, except Matt. 5: 17-20; but his effort was simply to assert that Christ gave a new law.
Second Speech.—“First and second covenants.” Jer. 31: 31-34; Ex. 19: 1-8, describe the covenant made with Israel concerning what they heard in God's voice. See Deut. 4: 12, 13; Jer. 7: 21-23; Gal. 3: 19-25; Lev. 4: 27-31; Col. 2: 14-17. The new covenant puts God's law in the heart. 2 Cor. 3: 1-6; Isa. 51: 6-8; Ps. 37: 29, 31. They shall all know God. 1 John 2: 3, 4; Jer. 31: 35, 36; Acts 26: 6, 7; James 1: 1-5; 1 Pet. 2: 9; Gal. 3: 26-29; Ex. 31: 12-17.
The Elder became nervous at this point in the discussion, and filled his half-hour with misapplication of many scriptures, and many assertions such as the following: “Moses wrote the ten commandments.” “There was only one law.” “Christ did not abolish the law, but it ran out by statute limitation.” But to-day he called up Col. 2: 14-17, and said Christ abolished it, then, pointing to the ten commandment chart, said, “Nine of them are found in the New Testament: that is, the principles of them.”
Third Speech.—I spent the half hour in contrasting the two laws, showing who wrote each of them, refuting some of his assertions, and recapitulating some of my former arguments, to see if he would not notice them.
Fourth Speech.—I presented Mark 2: 27, 28; Gen. 2: 1-3; Matt. 24: 20; Acts 13: 14, 27, 42, 44; 16: 11-14; 17: 1, 2; 18: 1, 4, 11; Rev. 1: 10. The Elder then tried to make quite an impression on the people by asserting that they could not keep the seventh day without killing two lambs every Sabbath. But when I showed him that the fourth commandment did not require any such thing, but that those sacrifices were required only by typical law, he had no more to say concerning that. His next position was that Col. 2: 14-17 abolished the seventh-day Sabbath. But when pressed to show that the seventh day pointed forward to anything, he could not do it, and therefore it could not be classed with the typical Sabbaths; hence, Col. 2: 17 put a decisive quietus on that position. He next stated that he had read the Bible very carefully, and he never had found a passage that called the ten commandments a law. I called his attention to Ex. 24: 12; also to Rom. 7: 7-14, and James 2: 10, which completely demolished that assumption.
He then asserted that Christ never said a word about the seventh-day Sabbath in the new covenant. I showed him that Christ said that not one jot or tittle should pass from the law till heaven and earth pass away, and then called on him to prove that God did not perpetuate the fourth commandment to the end of the world; but he would not attempt it. To this was added proof that Christ said, “The Sabbath was made for man,” and that the term “man” here included the whole race of man, and therefore includes the whole race under the new covenant. I called attention to the fact that Jesus said in Matt. 12: 12, that it is lawful to do well on the Sabbath days; that “lawful” means according to law, which must include the commandment; and that the women kept the Sabbath, according to the commandment, this side of the cross. My opponent says the law was abolished at the cross; but their keeping the Sabbath according to the commandment this side the cross, proves, beyond any possible doubt, that the fourth commandment belongs to the new covenant.
Fifth Speech.—It was proved that the law is older than sin; that sin is the transgression of the law; and that the law is a righteous rule by which all men are required to live. Ps. 119: 138, 144, 172. I showed that the Lord said his covenant (Deut. 4: 13) should stand fast with his first-born, as described in Col. 1: 12-19; that Jesus taught every jot and tittle of it binding, till heaven and earth should pass; and that in Ps. 89: 34, God says, “My covenant will I not break.” I referred to the second commandment, showing that if God does not show mercy to those who keep his commandments, he will break his covenant; and proved that his covenant was the thing that went out of his lips. The ten commandment covenant went out of his lips; and if he changed the Sabbath, altering the thing that went out of his lips, he has not kept his promise. He says, “My covenant will I not break.” Therefore the seventh day must forever continue to be his holy Sabbath. I could not induce the Elder to notice that position.
I then brought proof, by a comparison of Acts 2: 37, 38, 41; 4: 4, that about 8,000 Jews were converted to Christ, receiving the law of God into their hearts, according to the promise of the new covenant; and by Acts 26: 6, 7, brought to view the fact that Paul called them, with all others who united with them, the twelve tribes; and that James addresses this class as the “twelve tribes scattered abroad,” just before the second coming of Christ (James 1: 1-5; 5: 6, 7); also that Peter calls them a holy nation. It was also proved, from Jer. 31: 35, 36, that Israel had not ceased from being a nation before God; while the Jewish nation did so cease, in A. D. 70, and, as a nation, had been lost among the nations of the earth; but the children of God are the Israel of God, and a holy nation. I connected this with Ex. 31: 12-17, showing that the Sabbath must be kept by them for a perpetual covenant, and as a sign that they might know that God, who made heaven and earth, sanctified them. Jesus perpetuated every jot and tittle of the ten commandment covenant, “till heaven and earth pass,” and sealed his teaching with his blood. My opponent could not be induced to offer a negative to this argument.
It was clearly proved that Israel, the twelve tribes, all the true people of God, with the law, the ten commandments, in their hearts (see 2 Cor. 3: 1-6), and the holy Sabbath as God's own appointed sign, must continue as long as the sun, moon, and stars continue.
Eld. Smith affirmed,—
Resolved, That the Bible teaches that the first day of the week, called Sunday, is the Sabbath under the new covenant, and as such, should be observed by all men in this discussion.
He was to discuss this question to-day, but yesterday he said that quite a number who had already attended two days, could not spend another day now, as having had begun. Hence his proof for first-day observance waits his indefinite postponement. We shall hear it, perhaps, in the autumn.
As the result of the discussion, quite a number have become deeply interested in the truth. We have received pressing invitations to hold meetings in two places, which we intend to do right away. This is a new field, and these meetings, with a few held here last spring, are the first in this place, by Seventh-day Adventists. There are now about seventeen Sabbath-keepers, who have been much confirmed by the discussion. These have been organized into a church, and an elder and a deacon ordained. Bro. Chas. A. Smith, who started the work here, is with me, helping forward the good cause. I. SANBORN.
July 12.