It was my privilege to attend the discussion held in the Christian church at Abington, Iowa, between Eld. J. H. Morrison and Eld. D. R. Lucas, editor of the Christian Oracle, published at Des Moines. The tent was pitched in this place last summer, by Bro. Washburn and Beard; and they had but just begun their labors when they were challenged to a discussion by the Disciple brethren, who are quite numerous at that place. The matter was deferred at that time, as they did not want to have the meetings interrupted; but as the interest increased, and some were taking their stand for the truth, the opposition became bold and somewhat defiant.
Eld. Lucas held a series of meetings there early in the winter, at which time he took occasion to preach against our work, and to challenge any of our people to a discussion of the points at issue, saying that he was ready to meet them at any time. Finally, after some correspondence, arrangements were made for a joint discussion between him and Eld. Morrison, to begin Tuesday evening, March 6. The propositions for discussion were as follows:—
1. Do the Scriptures teach that the ten commandments,p. 221 as recorded in the twentieth chapter of Exodus, are now binding, the fourth precept of which enjoins the observance of the seventh day as the Sabbath, or Lord's day, as taught and practiced by the Seventh-day Adventist Church?
2. Do the Scriptures teach that the first day of the week is the Lord's day and should be observed, as taught and practiced by the Christian Church?
Eld. Morrison agreed to affirm the first, and Eld. Lucas the second of the above propositions. It was further agreed that each question should be discussed for four sessions of two hours and twenty minutes each, and if either party desired more time on either question, it should be granted.
It is not my purpose in this article to give anything like a synopsis of the arguments employed on either side, as that would take too much space, and might not present anything especially new to the readers of the REVIEW.
The first question was discussed for five sessions. Eld. Lucas took the usual position of his denomination, denying that the Bible recognizes two laws, and calling the ten commandments a yoke of bondage, and making their observance the worst kind of slavery, claiming that they were abolished and taken out of the way as not adapted to this age of "gospel liberty;" that Christ magnified the law by taking it out of the way, etc.
His positions were all more than met by Bro. Morrison, it being simply a matter of veracity between Eld. Lucas, who says it was a system of "slavery" and "bondage," and Inspiration, which calls it a law of liberty, holy, just, and good. Eld. Lucas made no effort whatever to harmonize his theory with the various statements in the Bible respecting the two systems of law, thus leaving his hearers to believe that the Bible contradicts itself, as well as his own theory of interpretation.
On the second question the Elder tried desperately hard to prove a "custom" to meet on the first day of the week to "break bread," from Acts 20:7, but had to acknowledge before he got through, that the breaking of bread in the text was on the second day of the week. It soon became evident to all that the Elder was about run ashore for arguments to sustain his first-day-of-the-week Lord's day, when at the close of his first session, without consulting with Bro. Morrison, he announced to the congregation that he would hold only one more, when the debate would close. He doubtless felt the sand sliding from under his feet, and that if he should live up to his contract, and have to draw his inferences out over four sessions, they would be so transparent that all would see through them.
He tried to divert the minds of his hearers by bringing in irrelevant matter from Sr. White's writings; but the moderators ruled him out of order, thus shutting him off from the pleasure he had anticipated in reading what some one else has said of Mrs. White. If powerful physical demonstrations and "bodily exercise" were equivalent to good, sound logic, the Elder would be a hard man to meet; but when we consider that "bodily exercise profiteth little," it is more and more apparent that the truth has nothing to fear from its opposers when presented in meekness and humility.
Thus the debate ended by Eld. L. assuming the responsibility of closing the discussion, and leaving the field, two sessions short of the time he had agreed upon at the beginning, Eld. Morrison predicting that he will never again meet any Seventh-day Adventist minister in debate on the above propositions, with the same rules and regulations.
Although the roads were very muddy, the attendance was good, the house being crowded at each session. I think a favorable impression was made on the minds of those who were desirous of learning the way of truth more perfectly.
C. F. STEVENS.