AdventAI

CHURCH REFORM IN ITALY.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 11., March 13, 1888

The Chicago Interior prints the following paragraph relative to a movement lately set on foot among the Catholics of Italy for a “reform” in the Catholic Church:—

Marked and special attention begins to be generally drawn to a church reform in Italy which has been for some time in progress within the pale of the Roman Catholic Church. The object of its promoters, who claim to be true Italian Catholics, is a new organization of Catholic Christians independent of the Vatican and in opposition to its extreme and ultramontane views. While the new society is in its infancy, it has, as we learn from a recent and reliable letter in the London Times, a large number of zealous and determined adherents among all ranks, orders, and professions, for whom, as the result of the present condition of church affairs in Italy, Catholicism of the present ultra type has no charm. The head of the recalcitrant organization is said to be Count Enrico di Campello, a Catholic priest and recently a canon of St. Peter’s, whom the Church of Rome will probably soon discover to be as certainly a “son of perdition” as was Luther. The general purpose of the new society, so far as it can at present be gleaned, is akin to that of the old Catholic party, if it be not identical with it. Its belief is that if the Italian church can cast off the heavy encumbrance it now carries in the form of a usurping and anti-progressive popery, and secure some union with the Christian world outside, a long step will be taken toward an union of the divisions of Christianity, and that the word “catholic,” now so entirely misused, will bear a new and real meaning, and become a watch-word of peace. The new organization will be heard from hereafter. It has, we think, come to stay, and we shall watch its course carefully and with interest. The political and religious conditions of Italy are now favorable to the movement.

If the inaugurators of this movement were a little more familiar with church history, they would see that their scheme of reform is only the same old scheme so often tried by a certain class of “reformers” in the past. Again and again, during the early progress of the Reformation, was the attempt made to reform the Church by smoothing down some of the most repulsive and objectionable features of the papacy without touching the foundation principles, and more than one futile attempt was made to patch up the rent caused by Protestantism, by uniting the two factions on a basis half way between their respective stand-points. All these attempts ended, as they deserved to end, in ignominious failure. No half-way scheme of reform will accomplish anything. Romanism is wrong from the very foundation up, and no reform can be a true or successful reform which does not recognize this fact. If the promoters of the present reform movement ever come to recognize this fact, and to act accordingly, it will be a happy day for them and for their country.

L. A. S.