THE SECOND COMMANDMENT

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 3, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 27.

Read the full edition

THE SECOND COMMANDMENT.

We learn that some of our good brethren are still troubled over the matter of pictures and illustrations, supposing that all such things are forbidden by the second commandment; and they feel so strongly over the subject that they decline to engage in the circulation of our books which contain such illustrations.
Now we have great respect for any one's convictions of conscience. And while persons have such convictions, we would not advise, much less try to compel, them to go contrary thereto, unless in cases where, as with the Mormons and Hindoos, it might lead to the commission of open crime. Still we should remember that conscience is not itself a standard; for it is largely affected by surrounding conditions and circumstances and by our own practices. There is a good conscience and an evil conscience, a sensitive conscience and a scared conscience; an enlightened conscience and a darkened conscience. Before, therefore, we yield ourselves to its control, we should be sure that it is a good conscience, and well enlightened, according to the word of God. What we would do, consequently, in the cases of those who we think are led by their conscience in a wrong direction, would be to try to show them that their conscience is not well informed, and does not rightfully require of them what they suppose. Such we believe to be the condition of the brethren above referred to, and hence offer these thoughts on the matter.
The commandment reads: “Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them; for I the Lord thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me, and showing mercy unto thousands of them that love me, and keep my commandments.”
Now what is the object of this commandment? What is it designed to secure? What sin is it intended to prevent? What is its great leading idea? Is it composed of many ideas, and has it many objects in view? or only one? If it has but one, we do not rigidly divide the commandment, or rightly understand it, until we take enough of it to complete that idea.
With this thought in mind, let the reader ask himself this question: “Is it not the one sole thought, idea, and object of the commandment to prevent false worship? Is not the idea of worship inseparably connected with that commandment? Are there really two separate precepts in that commandment, one forbidding the work of the architect and artist, and the other forbidding false worship? Are these two incongruous ideas associated together in the commandment? It would hardly seem possible that any one could suppose that acts so distinct, and ideas so separate, are thus combined. But if they are not, then in reading the commandment, we have not the complete idea, till we come to the prohibition of worship; and if we stop short of this idea, then we misinterpret the commandment, and fall into error.”
And this is just what we do when we say that the commandment forbids the making of certain things without any reference to the idea of worshiping those things. There can, it seems to us, be no question that the commandment forbids the making of images and likenesses of things in heaven and earth for the purpose of bowing down to them and worshiping them. But the matter of producing illustrations for books, not to be worshiped, but to impart instruction, and make the subject treated upon more clear and impressive—to such work as this the commandment has no reference whatever.
This becomes more evident still when we consider what difficulties are involved in the view under consideration. If the simple making of anything which could be called an image or a picture is forbidden, without any reference to worshiping it, then the Lord caused the children of Israel to violate the commandment by making the images of two cherubim, one on either end of the mercy-seat, of beaten gold, and adorning the walls of the sanctuary with cherubim of cunning needle work.
Moreover, if the commandment is to be so construed, no object must be made resembling any other object that has been made in all the earth. One must not make a house like any other that was ever made; for that would be a likeness of it, according to this scrupulous interpretation; neither would any one be allowed to make a chair like any other, or a bowl, plate, knife, fork, spoon, kettle, machine, plough, hat, coat, or any other thing under heaven; for the last one made would be the image or likeness of the one made before. Such is the inevitable conclusion, if we rigidly adhere to the bare phraseology, without looking at the scope and intent of the commandment as a whole. But no one will say that this is what the commandment means, and that men are consequently in a condition where they cannot well avoid an unlimited violation of the commandment all the time. Hence the position of our friends above referred to is not correct, and their conscience, which would forbid their circulating a book because it has an illustration in it, is not a well balanced conscience.
Again we say that we must not stop short of the whole idea of the commandment, if we would get its true meaning. If we are to stop short of this completed idea, where shall we stop? We could just as consistently stop at the word “make”—“Thou shalt not make”; which would forbid our making anything whatever; or with the word “not”—“Thou shalt not”; which would forbid our doing anything whatever. We get the whole idea only when we read it, “Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image or any likeness of anything in heaven above or earth beneath, to bow down to it and worship it.”