A NEW ARGUMENT FOR SUNDAY-KEEPING.
By L. A. S.
In the question department of a late number of the Chicago Interior, a reader of that paper propounds a number of questions which touch quite forcibly upon the discrepancy apparent in the course of those who profess to regard the fourth commandment of the decalogue as binding, and yet do not observe the day which it specifies. The following is the substance of what the Interior attempted by way of reply:— The fourth commandment does not command the sanctification of the seventh day. . . . On the contrary, with divine foreknowledge of the Christian Sabbath, it says, (God rested on the seventh day; but he “blessed and hallowed” what?—The seventh day? The command does not say so. It says the “Sabbath day,” meaning thereby that the “Sabbath” should not be limited to the Jewish day, but should be transferred to the Christian day. If not, why does not the command say: “Wherefore the Lord blessed the seventh day and hallowed it”? The Lord did not say so because he intended not to say so. Notice how accurate the spirit of inspiration was. How this little substitution of “Sabbath” for “seventh” prepares the way for the honor due to Christ. Brother P—— can show no command for the sanctification of the “seventh” day. It is the “Sabbath”—the institution, the one day in seven devoted to rest. In the production of this remarkable piece of logic, the Interior has made a worthy addition to the large and interesting museum of Sunday-Sabbath argument; but the intelligent reader need not be told that the fabric of the first-day Sabbath is no stronger, for the addition of this new prop, than it was before. The more publicity which can be given to the fact that the most intelligent defenders of the institution can bring no better arguments than this to support it, the weaker will its claims become in the minds of candid and intelligent persons. It is for this reason chiefly that we notice it. As is usually the case with the assertions of those who are driven to defend a practice which has no scriptural warrant, they give rise upon a slight examination to questions more difficult than the ones they were put forth to answer. Notice a few of the difficulties and absurdities involved here. All admit that, back in the old dispensation, the Jews observed the Sabbath day. The Sabbath day was then sanctified and blessed the same as it is now. But the day which the Jews observed was the seventh day. And yet, says the Interior, the seventh day was not sanctified and blessed! Again, it is stated that God did not sanctify the seventh day, and yet that he did sanctify “one day in seven.” Is not one day in seven the seventh day? How could the Creator, starting as he did with the beginning of time, sanctify one day in every seven without selecting the seventh day? It is further stated that God sanctified the Sabbath institution. But the Sabbath was not instituted until it was given to man. Did God then give man a day which was not blessed and sanctified? Was there a Sabbath institution without a blessed and sanctified day? If not, then it must have been the day, not the institution, which was sanctified. Thus it is with all the arguments put forth to establish the sacredness of the first day of the week. Their success depends wholly upon their being taken for granted, for a candid examination of their claims, sooner or later proves fatal in every case. The facility with which strange and unheard-of arguments can be manufactured in support of the first-day Sabbath, illustrates one great distinction between truth and error. A proposition which is supported by facts needs only that those facts be brought to light, and its truth is demonstrated. It has one straight line of defense, which is always satisfactory, because it is impregnable. But where, on the other hand, a theory exists without any facts for its support, of course none can be produced, and one line of argument is just as satisfactory, so far as proving the truth of the proposition is concerned, as another. And as no line of argument ever actually demonstrates its truth, its champions are continually on the lookout for another. This is just the case with the Sunday-Sabbath theory. It has nothing in the nature of facts to support it, and consequently its various lines of defense cross one another in inextricable confusion, and radiate to all points of the theological compass. Would the champion of this institution pause a moment to consider the situation, before rushing forward in his blind zeal to uphold it against the claims of the seventh-day Sabbath, he would discern better the hopeless difficulty of the task before him. He would see that the task is a double one. First, he must establish and make plain the truth of his own particular proposition in behalf of the first-day Sabbath; and second, he must overthrow all theories of other Sunday champions with which it comes in conflict. Such being the case, it is not surprising that those who do realize the nature of the situation, should be reaching after something more powerful than their arguments to give the Sunday institution that prominence which they are determined it must have in the established practices of our nation.