AdventAI

The Investigative Judgment.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 21., May 22, 1888

It has been shown in S. D. Adventist literature, in books, pamphlets, tracts, and frequent newspaper articles, that before Christ appears in the clouds of heaven at his second advent, so much of the judgment appointed for the world (Acts 17:31) must have transpired as is necessary to determine the character of all men, and separate them into two great classes,—the righteous and the wicked.

Such a position is no far-fetched, fanciful conception, but one that is absolutely necessary under the circumstances; for when Christ appears, certain events take place instantaneously which are the result of a work of judgment; but for this work of judgment on which these events depend, no time is given at the moment of Christ’s appearing. Thus, certain ones among those who live to see Christ come, are in an instant changed from mortal to immortal, from corruptible to incorruptible, at that time. “Behold,” says the apostle, “I show you a mystery: We shall not all sleep [die before the coming of Christ], but we shall all [all of the church who do not die] be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trump; for the trumpet shall sound, and the dead [in Christ] shall be raised incorruptible, and we [the living] shall be changed. For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality.” 1 Cor. 15:51–53.

The same apostle states to the Thessalonians the same great truth, in these words: “For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God; and the dead in Christ shall rise first: then we which are alive and remain shall be [changed and] caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air; and so shall we ever be with the Lord.” 1 Thess. 4:16, 17.

Now, we cannot conceive of such changes as those passing upon men—a resurrection to life and incorruption on the part of a portion of the dead, and a change to immortality on the part of some of the living, and the ascent of all these to meet the Lord in the air—before they are judged! Such an idea would not be worthy of a moment’s credence; for it is the very object of the judgment to decide just such questions as these in relation to mankind.

But there is nowhere brought to view a work of judgment in reference to these classes after Christ appears, and before they are caught up to meet him; nor is there any time for such a work. Does the judgment sit in mid-heaven, and is there an examination of cases there held to determine what ones the Lord has come to save? to ascertain what ones ought to be raised from the dead, and who among the living are entitled to a change? Absolutely nothing of this kind. But the loud blast of the trump of God announces the appearance of the Lord, coming in power and glory in the clouds of heaven; and at the sound of that trump, in the twinkling of an eye, the righteous living are changed, and the righteous dead are raised, and the wicked are given over to destruction. Mark, we do not say that the wicked are as instantaneously destroyed, but they are given over to destruction; that is, they are openly abandoned to their fate. The taking of all the righteous to heaven, is at once an open announcement of the status of all who are left. Their fate is declared. They are doomed to destruction; which in due time comes upon them. We refer in these statements to the living wicked, and the loss of their natural life, in connection with the second coming of Christ. But if any wish to claim the statements as referring to the wicked dead also, they will be equally true even then; for the bringing up from the grave of all the righteous, declares just as plainly the status of all who are left in the grave; they are the wicked; and they are given over to destruction, which will come upon them when all the wicked are destroyed together, at the end of the thousand years, in the second death.

Therefore we most positively and confidently aver that the only position which will stand the test of either fact or reason, is, that so much of the judgment as is necessary to determine the character of all men, and decide to which class they belong, the accepted or rejected, must take place before Christ comes. And to this extent the sentence rendered can be carried out when the Saviour appears, in taking all the accepted ones unto himself, and leaving the others to be disposed of in a proper manner at a subsequent time.

But it may be asked, “Where is the need of any previous investigation? does not God know all men? does he not know his people? and can he not give them immortality at once through the exercise of his own omniscience?” We reverently admit that he could do this; but his word informs us that he has not chosen to do so. If God by an act of his own omniscience decides all cases and visits rewards or punishments upon each “in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye,” where is that process called “the judgment,” which is so clearly revealed in the Bible? We appear before the judgment-seat of Christ to “receive [sentence for] the things done in the body” (2 Cor. 5:10); and it is expressly declared that when men are judged, they are judged (that is, decision is made and sentence is rendered) according to a record of their deeds kept in books which may be called the books of judgment. Rev. 20:12. In the very opening scene of the judgment (Dan. 7:10) it is said, “And the books were opened;” and in the closing scene (Rev. 20:12) it also reads, “And the books were opened.” Therefore what is experienced by the righteous and wicked at the coming of Christ does not proceed from the workings of God’s omniscience at the moment exercised, but is the result of decisions previously arrived at in their cases.

It may be asked further, “Do not the Scriptures declare that Christ will judge the living and the dead at his appearing: ‘Who shall judge the quick and the dead at his appearing and the kingdom’ (2 Tim. 4:1)?”—Very true; but what kind of judgment does he then render?—He carries out a sentence previously decided upon, and gives immortality to his people. He declares when he appears, “And my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.” Rev. 22:12. A “reward” must follow investigation and decision previously made. It should be remembered that the words “judge” and “judgment” are used with reference both to the judicial and executive divisions of the judgment separately considered. It is first decided who are to be saved; then that sentence is carried out at the second coming of Christ, by the bestowment upon all such, of immortality. Then the cases of the wicked are examined with a view to determining the degree of their punishment; and this sentence is carried out in the second death. First, the investigation before Christ comes, is called “the judgment” (Dan. 7:10); secondly, the execution of the sentence, thus far, at the second advent, is called a work of judgment (2 Tim. 4:1); thirdly, the examination of the cases of the wicked during the thousand years, is called “judgment” (Rev. 20:4): “Judgment was given unto them: . . . and they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years” (see also 1 Cor. 6:2, which unquestionably applies during this time); and, fourthly, the execution upon the wicked at the end of the thousand years, of the judgment written (Ps. 149:9), is called “judgment.” 2 Pet. 3:7: “Day of judgment and perdition of ungodly men.” Thus the day of judgment covers all this time, and the work of judgment embraces all these divisions. And there is order and consistency in the arrangement: First, the cases of the righteous are examined [judgment begins at the house of God. 1 Pet. 4:17], and sentence is executed. Then the cases of the wicked are examined, and sentence is executed.

Having thus ascertained that a portion of the judgment must precede the coming of Christ, which, to distinguish it from other divisions of the work, may properly be called “the investigative judgment,” the inquiry next arises, What is the nature of this work, and how is it carried out? The answer is obvious. It must involve an examination of books of record, and making decisions according to the deeds written therein. On this point we refer to Rev. 20:12; but we find that the reference is by some entirely misapprehended. It is taken to mean that we apply Rev. 20:12 to the investigative judgment of Dan. 7:10; which is not the case. Never have we so applied it. The reference to that text in this connection was, and is, simply to show that books are used in the judgment, and what use is made of those books; and we take this text as determining the matter in all cases where books are mentioned or alluded to in the judgment work; for we apprehend that the method of showing forth the innocence or guilt of all parties is the same throughout the entire work. One rule is not adopted for one class and another for another. Now Dan. 7:10 speaks of books being opened, but does not state for what purpose they are used. This refers to the opening of the judgment, and Rev. 20:12 to the close; but we refer to this latter text in reference to the books, to show that the books in the judgment scene of Daniel 7, must be used for the same purpose; that is, to examine the deeds written therein, and render judgment accordingly.

The closing work in the sanctuary involves this very procedure. It is for the purpose of making the atonement, and cleansing the sanctuary, by putting away sin. But when sins are put away, how is it done?—They are blotted out; for so Peter testifies: “Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord; and he shall send Jesus Christ, which before was preached unto you; whom the heavens must receive [or retain] until the times of restitution of all things.” Acts 3:19–21.

Here, just before Christ comes, Peter declares that the sins of those who have repented will be blotted out. Blotted out from what?—From those books wherein human deeds are written before God. Thus we are brought back again, by unavoidable steps, to the “books” brought to view in Dan. 7:10. No place is found for this work except in the view of the sanctuary, which we have not a shadow of doubt is the correct one, held by S. D. Adventists; and here it comes in necessarily, harmoniously, beautifully.

But the objector stands ready with his protest at this point. He asks, “What was there in the earthly sanctuary corresponding to the ‘investigative judgment’ in the heavenly? Did the earthly high priest investigate the characters of the Israelites? But if there was no ‘investigation’ in the earthly sanctuary, there can be none in the heavenly; for the rule says that ‘the type must correspond to the antitype.’”

To the candid, thoughtful mind, this must sound much like a mere cavil. Who would naturally imagine that earthly scenes must equal heavenly, or that man can read the character of his fellows as accurately as it is recorded by the divine penman on the books above? Paul says the law had a shadowp. 329 but not the very image, of good things to come. Heb. 10:1. And we would like to have the objector tell us what better illustration could have been given here among men, of the real atonement and blotting out of sin, the “investigative judgment,” than was furnished in the earthly sanctuary on the day of atonement? It was the great day of solemnity for all Israel. They were to afflict their souls, and every one who did not do this was to be cut off from among the people. It was a day of judgment for them. The work could be only a shadow, and the offerings were necessarily imperfect; but sin was dealt with as fully and effectually as mortals had power to deal with it, and was in the only manner and to the fullest extent available to them, put away. In Christ’s work, the real atonement which he makes, pertains to individuals, not to a nation as a whole; it puts away sin, not merely in shadow, but in fact; and Peter declares that this is blotting it out; and this involves an examination of the records of men’s deeds, from which all judgment proceeds; and this decision of cases is a part of the judgment; and this part precedes the coming of Christ. There is no evading of this conclusion. However captiously disposed a person may be, it seems to us that there is no room here for either doubt or quibble.

But there is nothing which seems to stir the indignation of Mr. Morton, whose positions we have of late been examining, like this view. In his rejoinder to our first reply, he says:—

Thus, this doctrine of the “investigative judgment,” as taught by the “remnant church,” which, at best, rests upon an uncertain and improbable interpretation of Dan. 7:9, 10, gives the lie to Jesus, to John, to Paul, and to Peter. Is it any wonder that evangelical Christians should hold it in abomination? It is not only unscriptural, it is equally unphilosophical and unworthy of the well-known character of God. The thought that a God of infinite justice and fair dealing would, by a sort of “star-chamber” process, judge and sentence to utter destruction, millions of his own creatures, without a hearing, is the very quintessence of absurdity. It is little short of blasphemy. I know of no more truth-defying, God-dishonoring doctrine in the whole range of modern theology. This is my deliberate testimony.

He prefaces this fearful thunderbolt by transcribing Matt. 25:31–41; 12:36; Rev. 20:12; Rom. 14:10–12; 2 Cor. 5:10; and 1 Pet. 1:4, 5; which he would represent as all applying to the same time. We explained our position last week in reference to Matt. 25:31–41, and Rev. 20:12; and the other references are wholly indefinite as regards the matter of time. Mr. M. is still confused with the old “medieval” idea of the judgment, which ignores all order and regularity in the work, but has the whole human family come up in one indiscriminate, conglomerate mass, and one by one receive their examination and sentence. How much time would this occupy? Take, for example, the lowest computation of the present generation, 1,400,000,000, and give to the judgment of each person one minute, which would certainly be short enough time, would it not? and how long would it take to judge just this one generation? Reducing the number to hours, days, and years, omitting fractions, we have, 23,333,333 hours, 972,222 days, 2,663 years. That is, it would take over two and one half thousand years to go through the present generation, according to Mr. M.’s “orthodox” view, and gather out those who are to be made immortal at Christ’s coming, and which Paul declares is accomplished “in the twinkling of an eye,” at the sound of the trumpet. Twinkling of an eye, forsooth! If it takes Mr. M. as long as that to twinkle his eye, he is a slower man than we had supposed.

But the most singular part of his criticism is that he accuses God of pursuing a sort of “star-chamber” process unless he gives all the wicked “a hearing” at the judgment. A hearing, indeed! What kind of a hearing does he suppose the wicked are entitled to, or will be accorded to them? Will they be permitted to come up and deny the crimes recorded against them, or charge the heavenly records with partial or exaggerated statements, or urge palliating circumstances in extenuation of their evil deeds? What other evidence could come in to influence the findings of the court, when they have before them the complete life record of the culprit, with every thought, motive, purpose, and secret thing—the whole character photographed upon the page of destiny exactly as it is? Can a person have any further “hearing” than this? Can the court make up a just sentence from all this, and justly bring the doomed man up afterward to hear that sentence? The question answers itself.

The sins of the righteous are blotted out before Christ comes bringing with him the reward of immortality for them, or both Peter and Paul have testified incorrectly, and there is no lesson to be learned from type and antitype. And the wicked have their sentence prepared in the judgment of the thousand years, for so John states, in Rev. 20:4. But this does not preclude the idea of their personal presence before the tribunal at the proper time and place. All men will indeed personally appear before God in the judgment. At the end of the thousand years, for the first and last and only time, the whole human family are together before the throne: the righteous in the city, the wicked outside. Luke 13:28; Rev. 20:9. Their sentence is pronounced upon the wicked, and executed; and in that sentence they “give account” of their idle words, and “answer” for all their abominable deeds. Then the King pronounces the great blessing upon the righteous, and invites them to take possession of the renewed and purified earth, the kingdom prepared for them from the foundation of the world, which they are to possess forever and ever.

With a rational, consistent view of this subject, the testimony of the whole Bible comes together in the completest harmony.