KINGSBURY ON THE SABBATH

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 10, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 28.

Read the full edition

KINGSBURY ON THE SABBATH.

ITS RELIABILITY.

The Sunday question has given to the world a large number of publications within the last half century. Many of them are very pretentious, both as to their claims to being argumentative, and to being faithful chronicles of facts. Among these is “The Sabbath,” by Harmon Kingsbury, published by the “American Society for the promotion of Christian Morals.” We should be pleased if the avowed intention of the publishers were carried out in books of this class; viz., to increase respect for, and lessen the violation of, the holy Sabbath. By holy Sabbath, we mean, of course, the sanctified, blessed day of the Lord, the seventh day, which God sanctified because in it he rested from the work of creation. We could refer to no other by that title; for no other day has ever been divinely blessed and sanctified.
But in advocating the claims of “The Sabbath,” such authors as Harmon Kingsbury, Justin Edwards, etc., do not at all exalt the sanctified rest day of Jehovah, but, to the contrary, they put forth every effort to debase it, to stigmatize it, and to make it and its observance a reproach before the world. See Isa. 58: 13, 14. With a show of knowledge, “they have made others to hope that they would confirm the word” (Eze. 13: 6), when they have endeavored to prove that the Sabbath was changed from the seventh to the first day of the week.
As a specimen of this kind of literature, and to show just what reliance can be placed upon the writings of Kingsbury on this subject, I copy the following from his book, pp. 76, 77, edition, New York, Jonathan Leavitt, 1841:—
We understand the Emperor Leo, about 440, to say, “It is our will and pleasure, that the holy day, dedicated to the Most High God, should not be spent in sensual recreations, or otherwise profaned by suits of law.” Speaking of farmers, in relation to this subject, he says: “As to the pretenses, that by this rest, an opportunity may be lost [of securing crops], this is a poor reason, considering that the fruits of the earth do not depend so much on the diligence and pains of men, as on the efficacy of the sun and the blessing of God. We command, therefore, all, whether husbandmen or others, to forbear work on this day of the resurrection. For if other people (meaning the Jews) keep the shadow of this day in a solemn rest from all secular labor on the Sabbath (the seventh day), how much rather ought we to observe the substance, a day so ennobled by our gracious Lord who saved us from destruction.” Again, Leo thus expresses the sentiment of the whole Christian church: “We ordain, according to the true meaning of the Holy Ghost, and of the apostles thereby directed, that on the sacred day whereon our own integrity was restored, all do rest and cease from labor; that neither husbandmen nor any other on that day, put forth their hand to forbidden work.”
Very seldom do we find a statement claiming to relate the facts of history, so utterly destitute of truth, as the above. Notice a few points:—
1. While this is ascribed to a decree by the Emperor Leo, in 440, it is a fact that may be verified by reference to any cyclopedia or history, that Leo was proclaimed emperor in the year 457! The only decree that he ever published relating to Sunday, was given in the year 469, or twenty-nine years after the date ascribed to it by Kingsbury.
2. The only part of this quotation which belongs to the Emperor Leo I. is that in the first four lines. All the rest belongs to the tenth century.
3. That part which was written by Leo I. is misrepresented. Leo said, “The holy days,” including the other festivals of the church as well as Sunday. This is made sure, not only by the plural form, but he immediately spoke of the Sunday; in distinction from the other days specified in the edict.
4. Most of the words of the entire quotation belong to a decree of Leo VI., in the year 910.
5. If it be claimed that it was a mere mistake of the person, and that Pope Leo I. was the one intended, then the case is not bettered a whit. Justin Edwards does, indeed, ascribe a part of these words to Pope Leo, giving the same date 440, the very year in which he came to the papal chair. But Pope Leo never uttered any of these words. The somewhat celebrated letter of Pope Leo I., concerning ordinations on Sunday, was written in 445. But it contains none of the words given in the above extract.
It is no excuse for Kingsbury that others have made the same mistake, and ascribed these words to the wrong authority. Nicephorus claims to quote them as from Emperor Leo I., as early as the fourteenth century. Then followed Morer, who ascribed them to Emperor Leo I., and afterward duplicated them, and gave to them the proper authority, Leo VI., called the Philosopher. Justin Edwards ascribed them to Pope Leo I., and now follows Kingsbury, giving them to Emperor Leo—about thirty years before this emperor made any decree on the subject, and seventeen years before he was proclaimed emperor. How many other “Christian historians” have mutilated this testimony to serve the cause of the Sunday fraud, I am not now able to say; but it would be a curious study to trace this subject through all the Sunday literature of the day.
I have now before me the original of Emperor Leo’s decree, copied from the Justinian Code, and know that it contains none of the words ascribed to him, except the short quotation at the beginning of the entire quotation given from Kingsbury.
And as for Pope Leo I., he never made any decree or edict on the subject; all that he published on the Sunday, was a letter to Dioscorus, Bishop of Alexandria, in 445. This related solely to ordinations, and not to worship in general, as various “Christian” writers have made it read.
At another time I may note what Heylyn says of the cause of Emperor Leo’s decree, but I have given all that I intended; that is, to show that Kingsbury is utterly unreliable as authority on historical facts concerning the Sunday. As before said, this is only a specimen. Probably there is no other subject on which so much falsehood has been put forth for historical and Biblical truth, as that of Sunday.
J. H. WAGGONER.