AdventAI

THE COMING CHURCH UNION.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 13., March 27, 1888

Rev. Alexander V. G. Allen, D. D., professor in the Episcopal theological school of Cambridge, Mass., discussing in the Independent some of the possibilities and limitations of “Christian union,” sets forth the feasibility of such a step by the Protestant churches of this country, under the following conditions:—

The various sects of Presbyterianism or of the Reformed Church of Calvin might easily come together in one organization, as indeed they seem inclined to do, by subordinating their differences. How far this method of union by the subordination of differences might be carried, it is impossible to determine. It would at least require that each church should give up its distinctive limitation or negation. High churchmen must cease to insist upon their doctrine of apostolic succession; Presbyterians must admit that the Westminster Confession is not the last word in theology; Congregationalists, yield their theory of the independence of the local church; Baptists, no longer contend that obedience to Christ requires adult baptism by immersion; Quakers, withdraw their opposition to a hireling ministry and to visible sacraments; Methodists, allow that salvation is possible without undergoing a technical process of conversion; Universalists, confess that the Winchester articles disturbed the basis of a practical theology; and Unitarians, no longer reject the doctrine of the Trinity. As none of these concessions implies the sacrifice of necessary or fundamental truth, it is not impossible to conceive the attainment of Christian union by this negative process of elimination.

This strikes us as rather a novel plan for consummating Christian union. We had always supposed that, as true Christianity can make no compromise with error, true Christian union could only take place upon the basis of the acceptance of all Scripture truth, instead of the casting aside of that which is regarded as such, and that all Bible truth is to the Christian both “necessary” and “fundamental.” We believe, however, that there will be a union of the churches in this country, and a more extensive one than they at the present time contemplate; and already there seems to be a dawning presentiment of such a contingency as we believe will bring this union about; for the writer continues:—

And, further, faint as this possibility may now appear, yet it is within the range of the imagination to conceive some powerful motive whose working would hasten the process. A great sentiment may take possession of Protestant Christendom which would imperatively demand that all artificial restrictions be dropped in the presence of some grave danger.

We believe there is such a possibility, and not by any means such a faint one as the writer’s words would imply. But it will be a different one from any that is now anticipated. When the “loud cry” of the Third Angel’s Message begins to resound throughout the world, it will arrest the attention of Christendom in a far greater degree than its proclamation does at the present time. The popular churches will be aroused, and will then have little trouble in discerning therein a “grave danger,” professing, as they now do, to regard our views as a fatal form of religious heresy. Under such circumstances, it will not be difficult to form a “Christian union” without paying much attention to “distinctive limitations” of church or sect.

L. A. S.