The movement for the Sunday closing of the saloons is steadily gaining ground, and in the States of Ohio and Missouri is beginning to assume wide-spread proportions. The supreme court of the latter State has just rendered a decision to the effect that liquor-selling is illegal on that day in the city of St. Louis, and under the Downing liquor law, which applies to all parts of the State, there will be, it is said, no more open saloons or beer gardens in that city on Sunday; and an equally determined effort is being made to enforce the Owens law for Sunday-closing in the city of Cincinnati, as is shown by the fact that 147 warrants were issued last Monday for the arrest of persons who kept open their saloons on the previous day. It is probably safe to conclude that if Sunday-closing can be enforced in St. Louis and Cincinnati, it can be in any city in the Union.
We are heartily in favor of the closing of the saloons on Sunday, not only in the cities above mentioned, but in every other place now cursed by their presence. But we are not in favor of closing them simply on Sunday, and allowing them to run under the sanction of the law on other days of the week. We are in favor of closing them up altogether. We believe the fight against the saloon should be conducted on sound principles and backed by logical reasoning, and on such a basis we cannot see that there is room for any half-way measures in dealing with the question. No compromise with the saloon power will ever conduct the temperance movement to a successful issue.
And this is just what the Sunday-closing movement really is. It is an anomalous proceeding for which no consistent reason can be given. Why is it any worse to keep open a saloon on Sunday than on any other day of the week? The idea seems to prevail that there is a religious reason for closing the saloons on Sunday which would not apply to such an act on other days; but a moment's investigation shows that no such reason exists. For, aside from the fact that Sunday is not the Sabbath, the fourth commandment does not consider the nature of an act done on the Sabbath day only so far as to determine whether it is necessary or unnecessary. The fact that the saloon is a low and vile resort, a source of crime and a great evil, is not one with which the fourth commandment has anything to do. The mere fact that the running of one on the Sabbath day is an unnecessary labor, is sufficient to bring it under the full condemnation of the Sabbath law, and the same is true of any other kind of business, however honorable and legitimate in itself. The running of a saloon on the Sabbath violates other commandments besides the fourth, but does not violate that one any more than the running of a dry goods or grocery store on the same day. Thus the Sunday closing of the saloons cannot be consistently based on the authority of the fourth commandment by those who allow other places of business to run on that day as usual. While the temperance edifice is based upon a foundation of this illusive character, the structure will not, we think, be reared to a very great hight.
To deal consistently with this question requires that the saloon be either allowed to run freely on every day, or prohibited on all days. If this institution has not a right to run on all days of the week, it has no right to run on any; and if it has a right to run on any day, it has a right to run on all, so far as it stands related to any human authority.
The injustice of arbitrarily closing the saloons on the first day of the week, while other kinds of business are allowed to proceed unmolested, is a point which the saloonists themselves have not been slow to see, and which they will be sure to use as a weapon of defense as often as they think occasion demands. In fighting the Sunday-closing movement, the main effort of the liquor element has been to render the law obnoxious, and thus secure its repeal or convert it into a dead letter. To accomplish this there are two methods; one, to crowd the police courts with so many cases of violation of the law that it becomes impossible to attend to them; and, second, to rigidly enforce the law against all kinds of business, and thus arouse a public sentiment against it. The latter method is the most effective and the one most often tried, and it is in this way that the Sunday-closing movement, directed apparently toward the repression of a great evil, is made to interfere with legitimate and respectable business, to encroach upon the rights of a respectable portion of the community, and to assume the character of religious persecution. This is the way, most probably, in which the temperance question will be made accessory to the realization of the oppressive measures toward which we have long looked forward, and for which the representatives of “National Reform” are now most earnestly working.
It is not likely that the saloon-keepers of St. Louis and Cincinnati will tamely submit to the closing of their places of business on Sunday, while no restriction is placed upon the transaction of business in other departments of trade which is no less palpably a violation of the Sunday Sabbath. It remains to be seen how strictly the law will be enforced, and what action will be taken by the saloons against it, in the event that it is enforced.
The only consistent method of dealing with the saloon is to prohibit it altogether, as an unmixed and deadly evil, an enemy to the state, and a foe against which society is authorized to protect itself by the right of self-preservation. Proceeding on this plan, there will be no grounds given the saloonists on which to complain of injustice, and no mixing up of civil affairs with questions of religion. To proceed on the Sunday-closing principle, on the other hand, is to base the question on an imaginary foundation, to encroach upon the religious rights of other classes, to tacitly admit that the saloon has rights which it does not possess, and to effect a compromise with the liquor power which can but prove in the end sadly detrimental to the success of true temperance reform.
S. S. S.