The testimony of the Scriptures is sufficiently abundant to show that some of all the tribes returned from captivity to their native land, so that all Israel was represented in Judea as well as Judah, after the captivity, and those who were lost in foreign lands were cast off by the Lord forever from being his special people. This point is too plain to escape the notice of even secular historians. Thus Smith (History of the World, vol. 1, p. 178) says:—
The greater number of them [the ten tribes] probably lapsed into idolatry, and became confounded with the surrounding nations; but it is clear that many obeyed the invitation addressed by Cyrus to all his Hebrew subjects, and returned to Palestine, with the restored people of Judah.
On p. 187, he further says:—
The fact that their obedience to that edict was voluntary, was of itself a means of separation between the pious Jews who had preserved their faith in the promises of their restoration, from those who had lapsed into the idolatries of the provinces in which they were settled; and it seems probable that nearly all the remnant of the ten tribes who had not thus apostatized, joined with the people of Judah in their return to Palestine.
If all would bear in mind these facts, it would save a great deal of useless and unfounded speculation concerning the “ten lost tribes,” and their future restoration.