BY LOYD CALDWELL.
Cardinal Gibbons, chief Catholic prelate in the United States, thus, unconsciously perhaps, forecasts, in the North American Review of October, 1887, the probable future attitude of the papal church on the “Sunday Question”:—
The desecration of the Christian Sabbath is another social danger against which it behooves us to set our face and to take timely precautions before it assumes proportions too formidable to be easily eradicated. Whenever the enemies of God seek to destroy the religion of a people, they find no means so effectual for carrying out their impious designs as by the suppression of the Sabbath. Thus when Antiochus determined to abolish the sacred laws of the Hebrew people and to compel them to conform to the practice of idolatry, he defiled the temples of Jerusalem and Gerizim, he put an end to the Jewish sacrifices, and, above all, he forbade under pain of death the observance of the Sabbath and other religious solemnities, substituting in their stead his own birth day and the feast of Bacchus as days of sacrifice and licentious indulgence [refers to French Revolution as setting up a ten-day week, exiling priests, etc.]. And in our own times it is a well-known fact that the enemies of religion are the avowed enemies of the Christian Sabbath. A close observer cannot fail to note the dangerous inroads which have been made on the Lord’s day within the last quarter of a century in our own country; and if these invasions are not checked in time, the day may come when . . . the votaries of the theater and the drinking saloon will outnumber the church worshipers, etc. We might for a time worship God at irregular intervals, and would probably end by neglecting to commune with him altogether.
Daniel, John, and Paul foretold the career of persecuting Rome so clearly that all non-Catholic commentators are almost a unit in applying Dan. 7:25; Rev. 12:17; 13:4-10; 17:3-6; and 2 Thess. 2:3-9, etc., to the papal church. Passing by a striking variety of ways in which that church, and that alone, has literally fulfilled these predictions, let us address ourselves to a parallel of the work of the “enemies of God,” of whom the cardinal speaks, and the Sabbath career of the cardinal’s church:—
WHO CHANGED THE SABBATH?
THE CHURCH.
1. In A. D. 196 Victor, bishop (pope) of Rome, excommunicated all the churches of Asia for celebrating Easter on another day than Sunday. Doubtless this was the first papal edict—the first step in papal supremacy. See Bower’s “Hist. of Popes,” vol. 1, p. 18; Dowling’s “Hist. of Romanism,” p. 33; Torrey’s Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 1, p. 214; Maclaine’s Mosheim’s Ch. Hist., p. 49; Encyc. Britan. and McClintock and Strong’s Cycl., art. “Easter.”
2. In 305 the Council of Elvira denied communion to towns-people who were absent from church three Sundays. Confirmed by Council of Sardica, 345. See Schaff’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, par. 75; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3.
3. In 325 Constantine called the famous Council of Nice, chiefly to settle if Easter be fixed on a Sunday, or on a date of the month, regardless of the day of the week. See Euseb., Vita Const., chap. 18; Stanley’s “Eastern Church,” Lect. 5; or any good authority on Constantine or Easter or the Council of Nice.
4. In 364 the Council of Laodicea absolutely forbade Christians to observe the Jewish Sabbath, and enjoined resting on Sunday as far as they were able. See Torrey’s Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, p. 334; Lardner’s Works, vol. 4, p. 217; Shedd’s Guericke’s Ch. Hist., par. 78; Student’s Eccl. Hist., p. 293; Coleman’s Anc. Chris. Exemp., p. 331; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., p. 277; Smith’s Tables Ch. Hist., p. 19; McClintock and Strong’s Cycl., arts. “Lord’s Day,” “Laodicea”; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3.
5. In 440 Pope Leo the Great forbade all Sunday labor, lawsuits, and sensual recreations. See Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” pp. 555-6; Kingsbury’s “The Sabbath,” p. 210; Gesta Christi, p. 86.
6. In 538 the Council of Orleans ordered farm work to stop on Sunday, so as to allow attendance at church. See Chamber’s Encyc., art. “Sabbath”; Putnam’s Dict. Dates, art. “Sunday”; Guizot’s “Hist. of Civilization,” vol. 3, p. 264; Dict. Chronol., art. “Sunday.”
7. In 653 the twelfth Council of Toledo forbade the Jews to keep Sabbath, new moon, etc., or to labor on Sunday or on any of the great festivals of the Church, under penalty of one hundred lashes on the naked body; after that chains, banishment, confiscation of property. On the Jewish holy days they were all to assemble before the bishop. See Milman’s Hist. of the Jews, vol. 3, p. 117; Mores’s “Dialogue on the Lord’s Day,” p. 267.
8. In 1201 came Eustace, Abbot of Flaye, to England, with the Sunday Roll from Heaven, found on the altar of St. Simeon’s church, at Jerusalem, and confirmed by the pope! It forbade work from the ninth hour of Saturday till sunrise Monday; also on “the other festivals of my saints which you have not kept.” See Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3; Gillilan’s “Sabbath,” p. 309; Matt. Paris’ Hist. Major, p. 200; Mores’s “Lord’s Day,” p. 288.
9. In 1595 Rev. Nicholas Bound, D. D., an English Puritan, brought out the now famous “seventh part of time” theory of the Sabbath, thus basing Sunday (or any other day!) on the fourth commandment. This theory was eagerly taken up by the Presbyterians and later sects who are not satisfied to admit with the Catholic, Lutheran, and Episcopal churches, that “the church” could or did change the day. See Coleman’s Anc. Chris. Exemp., chap. 20; Neal’s “Hist. of the Puritans,” part 1, chap. 8; Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” note 305; Hessey, p. 205; Gillilan, p. 67; Heylyn’s “Hist. of the Sabbath,” part 2, chap. 8.
THE STATE.
1. In A. D. 321 Constantine, Emperor of Rome, issued a decree that all labor but country farm work should cease on the venerable day of the sun (not Son). He also forbade lawsuits and military exercises on that day. See Milman’s Hist. Chr., vol. 2, pp. 296, 298-7; Schaff, Neander, Stanley, or any good authority on Constantine, Sunday, etc.
2. In 386 Theodosius I., the Great, confirmed the above, and forbade the public games, allowed by Constantine, on Sunday. In 425 Theodosius II. forbade theaters with the foregoings, and extended them to include Easter, Epiphany, Pentecost, and Christmas. See Milman’s Hist. Chr., vol. 3, p. 205; Student’s Eccl. Hist., p. 293; Robertson’s Ch. Hist.; Guericke’s Ch. Hist., p. 297; Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, p. 330; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3.
3. In 469 Emperor Leo I. confirmed the decree of Pope Leo I., of 440. See Mosheim’s Eccl. Hist., Cent., 5, bk. 4; Moser’s Dialogues, pp. 259-60.
4. In 800 Charlemagne, Emperor of the West, forbade Sunday work and markets, and ordered all to come to church on that day. See Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” p. 556; “Sabbath Essays,” p. 241 (Boston, 1880); Kingsbury’s “The Sabbath,” p. 209.
5. In 910 Leo Philosophus, Emperor of the East, forbade the Sunday farm work, allowed by Constantine, whom he censured strongly for such allowance. See Chamber’s Cycl., art. “Sabbath”; Mores’s “Lord’s day,” p. 293; Hessey’s “Sunday,” Lect. 3; Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” p. 556.
6. Constantine forbade all non-Catholic worship, and confiscated all heretical places of worship. He forbade Christians to turn Jews, and ordered that any Jews who threw stones at or endangered a Christian’s life, should be burned alive! He bore the expense of the Nicene Council, exiled those who refused to obey it, and refused to hear charges against its bishops. He said that if he even detected a bishop in the act of adultery, he would throw his imperial robe over the unlawful deed, lest others might be depraved. See Milman’s “Hist. of the Jews,” vol. 3, p. 21; Lecky’s “Hist. of Rationalism” vol. 2, p. 23; Schaff’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, chap. 1; Bagster’s Eusebius’ “Life of Constantine,” and Theodoret’s Eccl. Hist., pp. 129 and 46.
7. In 380 the three Roman emperors, Theodosius, Gratian, and Valentinian commanded all their subjects (the civilized world) to receive the faith of St. Peter as held by Pope Damasus. They forbade all heresy and apostasy, and here began the state-church system of persecution. See Gibbon’s Rome, chap. 27; Ranke, “Hist. of the Popes,” vol. 1, chap. 1; Schaff’s Ch. Hist., vol. 3, p. 142; Sozomen’s Eccl. Hist., bk. 7; Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 209; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 30.
8. In 445 Valentinian III. commanded all bishops of the Western church, to hold and observe as law whatever it should please the bishop (pope) of Rome to decree. See Encyc. Britan., art. “Leo I.”; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 49; Wylie’s “Hist. of Protestantism,” vol. 1, p. 9; D’Aubigne’s “Hist. of the Reformation,” vol. 1, pp. 42-3; Hase’s Ch. Hist., p. 144; Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 269; Torrey’s Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 2, p. 207.
9. In 533 Justinian decreed that the pope or bishop of Rome be head of all the churches, east and west; which was accomplished in 538. This decree was formally admitted by Phocas in 606. See Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 26, p. 221; D’Aubigne’s “Hist. of the Reformation,” vol. 1, p. 49; Croly’s Apocalypse, p. 7.
Thus by the united and undeniable proof of these great authorities is shown the successivep. 357 steps by which the papal church substituted Sunday for God’s Sabbath, and gave new reasons and rules for the weekly rest.
That the state lent its authority merely in order to aid the church is undeniable. Says an able writer: “The decrees of the Nicene Council were enforced as laws of the empire by Constantine. That of Constantinople (381) requested and obtained the legal confirmation of Theodosius the Great; Theodosius II., after much hesitation, confirmed the principal decrees of that of Ephesus (431). Marcian’s edicts are extant confirming the decrees of Chalcedon (451). The next four councils, ecumenical, so called (553, 680, 787, 869), were either signed or also enforced by a decree of the emperors who respectively summoned them.”—Dr. Wm. Smith’s Dict. Chr. Antiq., pp. 322-6. See also Hase’s Ch. Hist., par. 122; Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 24; Coleman’s Anc. Chr. Exemp., 489; Stanley’s Eastern Ch., Lect. 2; Neander’s Ch. Hist., vol. 4, p. 95; Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, pp. 202-3. Said Constantine, “For whatever is transacted in the holy councils of the bishops is to be referred to the divine will” (inspired!)—Eusebius, Life of Constantine, App. to Bagster’s Edition, p. 53. “Thus the canons of the councils held in the East during the schism, at Antioch A. D. 341, Laodicea about 363, and Gangra between 362 and 370, were still maintained in the East, and at length were adopted in the West.”—Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 206.
Compare the Bible Sabbath (seventh day) with the papal Sunday, and the result would be about as follows:—
BIBLE SABBATH.
1. A memorial of creation. Exodus 20.
2. From evening to evening. Lev. 23:32.
3. A universal twenty-four-hour rest from business and selfish pleasure.
4. A sign to recall the Creator. Ex. 31:17; Eze. 20:20.
5. Not a feast; rather a fast. Ex. 16:23.
PAPAL SUNDAY.
1. A mere church festival.
2. Midnight to midnight:—a day sandwiched between two half-nights!
3. One hour at mass; the rest, at work or play. See Craft’s “Sabbath for Man,” pp. 126-178.
4. A sign to show the “true church,” and her authority!
5. Always a feast; never a fast. See the catechisms.
Yet, with such a record on this question, this “cardinal prince” has the effrontery to talk piously about American desecration of the “Christian Sabbath,” and of taking “timely precautions”! Ah! sir, we are reaping the reward of your church’s trifling with and overturning the precepts and institutions of God; and no amount of pious cant or ominous threats will avert the storm that is coming! Only one old tried resource is left you; it is persecution by State law! And in this you will be backed, yea, by Protestant churches (so called) whom you did your best to “eradicate.” Still further, your united blows will fall thickest and hardest on the “remnant” which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus. Rev. 12:17; 14:12. The greatest enemy of God is the papal church, that grossly perverted God’s truth and persecuted his people.
Battle Creek, Mich.