BY CHAS. F. WHITFORD.
Dear Cousin: Your kind and welcome letter of recent date is before me, and its contents are carefully noted. I am glad you so freely and frankly expressed your views regarding the Sabbath. It affords me great pleasure to notice briefly the positions which you take.
You believe the Sabbath has been changed from the seventh to the first day of the week by divine authority. Your first reference to prove this is John 20:19. I have examined this text carefully, and find nothing here teaching a change of the Sabbath. The disciples were not assembled together for religious worship, but “for fear of the Jews.” And they certainly could not have been engaged in celebrating his resurrection, for they did not believe at that time that he had risen. Mark 16:14.
Your next reference is John 20:26, where it speaks of Christ’s meeting with them again “after eight days.” I have thought of this expression a great deal, and I am frank to admit that I am so obtuse as not to be able to understand how that expression can in any way help the Sunday question. If I begin to count from Sunday, and count off eight days, it takes me over into the next week as far as Tuesday, and the record says it was after eight days; therefore I conclude that the next time the Saviour met with his disciples was as late as the next Tuesday; and as the expression “after eight days” is an indefinite one, we are left in ignorance as to just when he did meet with them again.
You next refer to Acts 20:7, and believe that here we have apostolic example for keeping the first day of the week. After a careful examination of this text in connection with others, I have learned the following facts: This text, instead of teaching any Sunday sacredness or apostolic example for its observance, shows that Paul regarded it as nothing more nor less than a common laboring day. Bear in mind that this meeting was a night meeting, and that it was held upon the first day of the week. The day begins at sunset, according to the Bible. Lev. 23:32. Then this meeting must have been held upon that part of the day which we call Saturday night. If held after sundown on Sunday, it would not have been upon the first day of the week, but upon the second day. Therefore we are forced to the conclusion that it was held on what we call Saturday night; and we learn furthermore from the record, that on the light portion of that first day of the week, Paul traveled nineteen and one half miles to Assos, where his companions had gone by boat, while he was holding a farewell meeting with his disciples. He never expected to see their faces again, and it was for this reason that he so much desired to have one more meeting with them. The apostle here held a meeting upon the first part of the day, and used the latter part as a common working-day. From a careful examination, therefore, of Acts 20:7, we reach the conclusion that Paul regarded the first day of the week as nothing more nor less than a common laboring day. In short, we have not only the example of the great apostle himself for laboring on this day, but we find his companions hard at work rowing their boat round the promontory to Assos, while Paul was engaged in holding a meeting. Hence we say without fear of successful contradiction, that Acts 20:7 does teach apostolic example for working on Sunday.
You next tell us that Rev. 1:10 calls Sunday the Lord’s day. I have carefully read this scripture also, and I do not find a word about Sunday or the first day of the week at all. John simply makes the statement that he was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day; but there is nothing in the text or its connection that tells us which day the Lord claims as his own. I turn to Ex. 20:8–11, and there I read in language too plain to be misunderstood, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord.” Then the seventh day is the Lord’s day, and when John declared that he was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day, it was equivalent to saying the seventh day. You say it seems right to you to keep in remembrance the day on which Christ rose from the dead. But do you not remember that the Lord’s supper and baptism have been left us as memorials to commemorate the death, burial, and resurrection of our blessed Lord? Do you remember the scripture which says, “There is a way which seemeth right unto a man; but the end thereof are the ways of death”? Prov. 14:12. We must be careful how we walk in a way that “seems right,” without having the most unmistakable evidence that it is right. We should manifest no less interest and anxiety in finding the right way to the heavenly inheritance, than we would were we on a journey through a strange land. How anxiously would we ask for the right way, and how carefully would we follow the directions?
As Christians, we are like the traveler journeying through a strange land. Our home is beyond this, far, far away. We shall find it necessary often to consult the chart, for directions as to the road we are traveling. We must make no mistakes if we would reach the port of endless day. If it were right to keep Sunday to commemorate the resurrection of Christ, that would in no way release us from keeping the Sabbath, unless the word of God has plainly said so. You think that Christ and his disciples kept Sunday. If you will show where either Christ or the apostles ever held a religious meeting in the day-time on the first day of the week, I will then give up the observance of the seventh day, and in future will remember “the Sunday” to keep it holy. In the absence of any example of either God, Christ, or the apostles for keeping the first day, do you think you would be willing hereafter to “remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy”?
If, as you think, the Sabbath was changed by Christ to meet the wants of the people living in the Christian age, why are the Scriptures silent respecting a change of so great importance? Why is there not some command or example for the observance of the first day? Why should David declare in Ps. 19:7, that “the law of the Lord is perfect”? Could a perfect law be changed and yet not become imperfect? Why should Paul declare that the law is “holy, and just, and good”? Rom. 7:12. And why do we hear Solomon saying that the commandments contain “the whole duty of man”? Eccl. 12:13, 14. If we can find nothing in the commandments about keeping Sunday, how are we to conclude that it is our duty to keep it?
And now, in conclusion, I wish to present for your consideration a few of the many reasons I have for keeping the seventh day:—
Do you think that God will condemn me for doing as he has done? Will he condemn me for doing what he has positively commanded me to do, and what Christ has reiterated, when he knows that I have not only his own example, but that of Christ, as well as the inspired men of all ages? Do you believe that in the judgment he will condemn the Jews for breaking this commandment, and condemn me for keeping it, when we are all to be judged by the same law? Rom. 2:11–16.
My reasons for not regarding Sunday, the first day of the week, as the Lord’s day, are these:—
- The Bible nowhere mentions it as such.
- It nowhere commands its observance.
- There are no blessings pronounced for keeping it.
- There is not a prohibition in the Bible against laboring on that day.
- The reasons specified in the fourth commandment for a weekly Sabbath, would not be true when applied to the first day. Hence it finds no support in the Bible, and therefore I cannot regard it as anything more nor less than a common laboring day.
I trust that God will bless you in all your investigations to know and do his will; and that we may at last meet and greet each other in the soon-coming kingdom, shall ever be my most earnest prayer.
Seventh-day Adventists sincerely believe that God has committed to them a most solemn message of truth, applicable to the present generation. Like all other reforms in the past, the work in which we are engaged is an aggressive one. The message must be proclaimed. A slumbering church as well as the world must hear. Along the lines comes the Captain’s command: “Cry aloud, spare not . . . show my people their transgression.” Isa. 58:1. Eighteen hundred years ago, God, by his servant, promised a final warning to mankind, to be followed by the great day of his wrath. Rev. 14:9–12. If the fulfillment of signs and prophecies proves that the time has come when this warning should be proclaimed, it is being proclaimed; for the providence of God never fails to fulfill all his promises as soon as they are due. And the fact that the warning is already spreading all over the earth, is the strongest evidence that the time has come for the fulfillment of the promise.
Dear cousin, I pray you to lay these things to heart, and not pass them by lightly. If you have not examined the evidences for the binding obligation of the fourth commandment, I entreat you to give the subject your prayerful attention. Do you say that if we believe in Christ we shall be saved whether we believe these things or not, granting that they are true? Do not deceive yourself so. Faith which God accepts, is that which accepts the special work which God causes to be done in our day. Look at the past and learn from that. God sent Noah with a warning to that generation. Then that was their present truth. No one before that had ever been required to hear or believe that truth. Hence they thought that it was of no consequence, and so rejected it. Noah was left alone to struggle on and bear the whole burden and reproach of that work. But they all perished, and the event proved that Noah’s message was of God. But now when the battle is fought and the victory is won, all are ready to praise Noah and have great faith in his work. We might give numerous illustrations of this kind.
A man may believe all the work of God in the past, but if he rejects the special work for his own time, he will be rejected by God. Faith in the present truth, a faith which will lead a man to obey it, to give his life for it, and to aid it with his means and his influence, is a live faith, a faith that will save a man and gain him a great reward in the kingdom of God. What is the use of faith?—It is to lead a man to work. James 2. Faith that does not lead a man to work, is dead. When does God call upon men to have faith?—When he has a work to be done among men. In what does he require them to have faith?—In that work which he has to be done in their day; for in this they can assist; not in some work in the past which others have already done, and which does not need their help or sympathy now. The present truth, the present work, and faith in the present work, which leads men to engage in and support the present work,—this is is Bible faith. A dead church and formal professors always have great faith in God’s workers of the past, but only contempt and persecution for his work in the present.
The coming of the Lord and a special preparation for it, is now the present truth. We earnestly desire you to take a part in it. Time flies! Probation is closing. Christ is coming. Eternal destinies are in the scales. The world reeks with rottenness and crime. A worldly church sleeps on in carnal security, dreaming of a world’s conversion. Scoffers are ready to ask, “Where is the promise of his coming?” The awful events of the judgment and the plagues of the last days are about to burst upon us, and the mass of the world are asleep. What shall be done? Laborers are few. A handful of men can never turn the vast tide backward; but bold, brave, prayerful efforts will rescue many a brand from the burning. The current is strong and swift, and the roaring, tempestuous winds of opposition are steadily rising; but a successful Commander steadies the helm, and his assuring voice is heard above the tempest of storm and tide, “I am with you always, even unto the end of the world.”
Moultrie, Fla.