WILL INDIA BECOME MOHAMMEDAN OR CHRISTIAN?
By T. S. Doolittle
A thoughtful writer in the Contemporary Review maintains that entirely different methods from those now pursued by our missionaries will have to be adopted in India, in order to reach and convert her people. Mohammedanism has already achieved remarkable success there. Every fifth person in that vast empire whose inhabitants number one fifth of the whole human race, is a follower of the Arabian prophet. Nor has this success been won, as commonly supposed, by the sword. Persecution may have had some effect in exceptional localities, as for example, in Sind and Mysore. But the great and substantial gain has been the offspring of ardent and ceaseless proselytism. The Mussulman both by the conviction of his faith and by every motive of politics—love of power and aggrandizement, as well as escape from taxation through the process of unloading on to others—is a zealot determined above all things upon the propagation of his religion; and accordingly the task of bringing souls under allegiance to the prophet waits not to be done by a few priests, or missionaries set apart for the purpose, but is eagerly seized and prosecuted by every child of the crescent and star. Moreover, the genius of Islam has been found admirably adapted to the Hindu mental and moral traits, and their creeds and modes of life. The essence of Hinduism, if not of its creeds, is fear—fear of the unknown result which may follow upon error either in conduct, or in faith, or in ceremonial. A single belief, the belief in his predestination, which is firmly accepted by every Hindu, fills his mind with vague terrors from which, while that conviction lasts, there cannot be by any possibility any full relief. He is responsible for the sins he knows nothing of, and who can say that any punishment of them would be unjust or excessive. If misfortune comes to him, that is his due; and a Hindu once unlucky, often broods like a Calvinist who thinks he is not of the elect. The modes of obtaining safety are infinite, but are all burdensome, and all, by the confession of those who use them, are more or less uncertain. Now, the doctrine of the divine sovereignty carried to its extreme as it is in the system of Islam, meets perfectly this characteristic phase of Hindu theology. The idea of one divine being, lonely, omnipresent and eternal, revealing through Mohammed his will, that those who believe in him shall have eternal bliss in heaven, which is earth over again with its delights intensified and its restrictions removed, and that those who disbelieve in him shall suffer torment forevermore, become to its recipient a source of freedom from painful and endless ceremonies, and an assurance equal to fate itself of safety and happiness in the world beyond. Hence it meets with welcome. Again, the followers of the prophet were not essentially alien in race. They were Asiatics, and accordingly were in a kind of unconscious sympathy and fellowship with the East Indians to whom they proclaimed their faith. Christianity has always labored under great disadvantages being preached by Europeans. “Something radical, something unalterable and indestructible, divides the Asiatic from the European.” For example, the Armenian, because he is an Asiatic, is tolerated as a Christian by the Mussulman, whereas any other Christian not an Asiatic would be slain at sight. The writer whose views we are condensing does not think that the Mohammedan privilege of polygamy in this world and the promise of houris in the next, have exerted very much influence in making converts, since all history shows that men looking for light desire a creed, and an ideal higher than their practice. For example, “the most dissolute of European societies foisted upon Christianity a restriction, celibacy, stronger than any Christ had taught; while the rigorous chastity of Christianity did not stop its spread in the abandoned society of the rotting Roman world. Once more: Islamism did not ask the Hindu to surrender absolutely his notions and practice of caste. It only asked him to exchange his caste for another and better one,—since the Islam caste is the largest, the most strictly bound, and the proudest of all,—a caste which claims not only a special relation to God, but the right of ruling absolutely all the remainder of mankind. Once in this caste the Hindu convert would be a brother of all within it, hailed as an equal, and treated as an equal even upon that point on which European theories of equality always break down—the rights of intermarriage. The rule of Islam forbidding indulgence in wine and all alcoholic beverages is another strong feature in its favor among the better class of Hindus, for the reason that they see in alcohol a deadly poison for their race. It is claimed that while the white races do not suffer except comparatively from drinking usages, yet the red and brown and black races find in such usages an inveterate and deadly foe, not simply to their souls, but to their very bodily exertions. Fire-water to most Asiatics is fire-water in deed, as well as in name. It awakens an uncontrollable craving for more, which ends in the complete stupor of intoxication. “I drinkee not for drinkee,” said the Madras man; “I drinkee for drunk!” To get beastly, dead drunk is his Elysium, and to do it as often as possible becomes the one absorbing aim of his wretched life. Hence the call by Islam to rigorous and total abstinence seems to the philanthropic and noble Hindu like a call from heaven, by heeding which his people are to be guarded against a serious tempter that would soon kill both body and soul. With all these things in its favor, and the significant fact that on the average 50,000 converts a year since the beginning have been added to Islamism, it is feared by many careful observers that at no distant day all India may be transferred, not to Christ, but to Mohammed. It is true that Christianity has grown in India, but not as it should have grown—not as Buddhism once grew, when it swept millions within its influence in a short period; not as Islam and other forms of error have grown. There are only 660,000 Christians belonging to all the Reformed churches in India, although it must not be forgotten that, if the aboriginal tribes be included, conversions are proportionally more numerous to-day to Christianity than to Mohammedanism. The reasons assigned for the slow spread of Christ’s gospel are three:— First, from the peculiar nature of the Hindu mind, he is capable of holding precisely opposite creeds as true, without changing his conduct in the least. A Hindu astronomer will predict eclipses ten years ahead without a blunder, and yet believe all the while, and sincerely believe, that the eclipse is caused by some supernatural dog swallowing the moon, and will beat a drum to make the dog give up its prize. And in the same way a Hindu will state with perfect honesty that Christianity is true, that Mohammedanism is true, and that his own special variety of Brahmanism is true, and that he believes them all implicitly. What, then, can you do with a man whom you have labored with your whole soul to convince, who is convinced, and who remains just as unconvinced for any practical purpose as he was before? Another obstacle is found in the fact that Christ is not, according to Hindu notions, enough of a sovereign and legislator. He is too humble, too self-denying, too resigned to his fate. The Hindu, it is said, is not attracted to that sort of a man or god. A second, and still more decisive hindrance lies in the Christian necessity of forcing the new convert to give up his caste. This means a surrender of his domestic law, the harem-like seclusion of his home, much of his authority over his wife and children, his right of compelling his daughter to marry early, which he holds a part of his honor, most of his daily habits, and even his method of eating his meals. Finally, Christianity, to succeed, must abandon its expensive habit of employing some 700 Europeans and Americans as high-priced missionaries, and ally itself instead to the native population by the employment of 3,000 native preachers for the same money. In eighty years no great native missionary has arisen, nor has there been developed a real native church. Asiatic converts must do the work of proselytism among Asiatics. There must be less fear of imperfect Christianity. Christianity is always imperfect in the beginning of its career among heathen races. Give the natives a chance.359 Nevertheless, and by and by their doctrine and life will grow more into the lofty ideal revealed by Jesus. These views are the well-matured convictions of one who has been many years among the Brahmans, and who is deeply acquainted with Indian traits, history, and prospects. They deserve careful consideration. — T. S. Doolittle, D.D., in Christian at Work.