DAY OF THE CRUCIFIXION AND RESURRECTION OF CHRIST.
HOW LONG DID CHRIST LIE IN THE GRAVE?
These are questions which naturally invite the interest and study of every believer. They are questions which have an intimate relation to other subjects, and upon which it is therefore important that correct views be entertained. We are sorry to see sentiments advanced upon these points, and seemingly promulgated with especial activity at the present time, which seem to us not only to be untrue in themselves, but to be calculated to work immense mischief to the Sabbath cause. It is the more to be regretted that these views come from Sabbath-keepers themselves; for every good cause has a sufficient number of obstacles to meet, and foes to encounter, outside of its own ranks, without suffering the greater calamity of being wounded in the house of its friends.
The views to which we refer are, 1. That Christ must lie in the grave seventy-two hours complete, because it is said that he was to be “in the heart of the earth three days and three nights;” and 2. That he was consequently buried at the close of the day on Wednesday, and rose at the close of the day on the Sabbath, or just before the first day of the week commenced.
Against this position we set up three indictments:—
It is founded on sheer assumption.
It is calculated to damage, rather than help, the Sabbath cause.
It is contrary to the Scriptures.
1. It is founded on assumption. The text to which appeal is first made is the one solitary declaration found in Matt. 12:40: “For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.” The statement in Jonah, to which allusion is here made, is simply this: “And Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights.” Jonah 1:17.
How does this prove that the Saviour was to lie in the grave for seventy-two hours? “Why,” it is answered, “the expression, ‘three days and three nights,’ means just seventy-two hours, no more, no less; one day and one night covering twenty-four hours, three of them would be three times twenty-four, that is, seventy-two; and, secondly, the expression, ‘the heart of the earth,’ where the Saviour was to be three days and three nights, means the grave. Therefore Christ was to lie in the grave seventy-two hours.”
THREE DAYS AND THREE NIGHTS.
In reference to the first part of this answer we inquire, Where is the proof that the expression, “three days and three nights,” means just seventy-two hours, and never any less? The response is, “That is what any one would understand by it at the present time.” Yes, but what we understand by it now, has nothing to do with the matter. The question is, What did they understand by it, by whom the New Testament was written? In what sense did they use it? What was the usage prevalent of that age? If we can ascertain this, we can tell what meaning we must give the expression in the New Testament, however much the manner of using it may have changed between that time and ours.
We easily find testimony to show that the expressions, “three days,” “after three days,” “three days, night or day,” were used as expressions not always signifying a period beginning with the first minute of the first day, and reaching to the last minute of the third, but taking in only a portion of the first or third, including, of course, the whole of the second. Thus we read in Gen. 42:17, that Joseph put his brethren in ward three days. Here the word “day” is used in its broad sense, covering the dark part as well as the light. It is the same as if it read that he put them in ward three days and three nights; for if we subdivide the day into its light and dark parts, it would take three of each of these parts to make the three days, and the expression “three days” must include all these parts. Yet on the third day, presumably in the morning of that day, Joseph made a proposition to them, which they accepted, and their sacks were then filled with corn, and they departed on their journey; which would naturally take the greater portion of the light part of that day.
Again in 1 Kings 12:5 we have a record of what Jeroboam said to the people, in these words: “Depart yet for three days, then come again to me.” This would indicate a definite period of just three days, if we should try to interpret it with the ultra rigidity of modern critics; but in 2 Chron. 10:5, the same expression is given as follows: “And he said unto them, Come again unto me after three days.” But in both records (1 Kings 12:12, and 2 Chron. 10:12) it is stated that, in accordance with this arrangement, the people returned on the third day: “So Jeroboam and all the people came to Rehoboam on the third day, as the king bade, saying, Come again to me on the third day.”
This testimony shows that the terms, “three days,” “after three days,” and “on the third day,” are used as synonymous expressions. But we have before us a little tract by Eld. N. Wardner, entitled “Prophecy of Christ concerning his Burial and Resurrection,” which considers it a very loose method of interpretation, to claim that “three days and three nights,” means a period that would terminate on the third day; and Mr. W. attempts to dispose of such passages as we now have before us, by simply remarking, “No nights are named.” Indeed! What possible difference can this make? Is not the word “day” here used in its broad sense, including both the light and dark parts? and would not “three days” include “three” each of such parts? The expression is therefore equivalent to “three days and three nights.”
In Esth. 4:16, and 5:1, we find an expression still more puzzling to those who deny that it was the custom of Jewish times and Jewish people, to use the expression “three days and three nights” to signify a period ending on the third day, and not embracing seventy-two full hours. The verses referred to state that Esther requested the Jews to fast with her three days. She said, “Fast ye for me, and neither eat nor drink three days, night or day.” She added, “I also and my maidens will fast likewise;” that is, three days, night and day. Would this passage be any stronger, if it read “three days and three nights,” instead of saying “three days,” and then distributing the period into its dark and light parts, “night or day,” restricting the word “day” in this instance to the light part of the three divisions? Mr. W. attempts to dodge this by saying, “But the number of nights are not named [!], and the statement does not require more than two; depending on the time of day they began to fast.” But we submit to the candid reader, if the numeral adjective “three,” does not cover both members of the distributive clause, as well as one; thus, “three days,” then dividing it up into its light and dark parts, “night or day;” how many light parts—days?—Three. How many dark parts—nights?—The same number, three. But Mr. W. would have us read it something after this fashion: “Three days, night or day, that is, three days and—well, let’s see, two nights, that’s enough for that.” It may seem to him consistent to wrest the word “three,” in the first part of the sentence, into “two” in one member of the last part; but it does not so appear to us. His conclusion in regard to the passage is, “It is not parallel to the statement, ‘three days and three nights.’” We beg leave to suggest that the word “not” should be taken out of this declaration, and the italics transferred to the word “is;” so as to make it read, “It is parallel to the statement ‘three days and three nights.’” But on the third day Queen Esther went into the presence of the king and obtained her request.
It will be noticed that Mr. W.’s exposition of this passage destroys his claim on Matt. 12:40; for he admits that three light portions of the day are here distinctly specified, and yet on the third one of these divisions, Esther proceeded to the king. So the expression “three days” does not include the whole of the time embraced in these days, but only the first and second, and a portion of the third. Now if the expression “three days,” applied explicitly to these light divisions, may mean only two and a portion of the third, by parity of reasoning, the expression “three nights,” applied to the dark divisions, may mean only two and a portion of the third; and the expression “three days and three nights” may be used without signifying absolutely seventy-two hours.
There are nine passages which declare that Christ was to rise “the third day,” as Matt. 16:21; 17:23;47320:19, etc.; one that he did rise “the third day” (Acts 10:40), and two that he should rise “after three days.” Matt. 27:63; Mark 8:31. This frequent reference to “the third day,” suggests the question,—
WERE THE DISCIPLES ABLE TO COUNT THREE?
for they have located for us this third day. The two disciples on their way to Emmaus said, “To-day is the third day since these things were done.” Luke 24:21. And this day is particularly specified as “the first day of the week.” Verses 1, 13. Here we have a plain and immovable waymark to guide us in our reckoning; the first day of the week was the third day,—a remark evidently brought in here with design to identify the fulfillment of the numerous predictions that he should rise on the third day.
But from what events did they commence their enumeration? How much was embraced in “these things”? Verse 20 answers. After stating what kind of a person Jesus of Nazareth was, a prophet mighty in word and deed, they begin the enumeration of the “things” to which they refer. They say, “And how the chief priests and our rulers delivered him to be condemned to death, and have crucified him. But we trusted that it had been he which should have redeemed Israel; and besides all this, to-day is the third day since these things were done.”
“These things” certainly include the trial of Christ as well as the crucifixion; and the first day of the week was the third day since this work commenced. Let us then count back and find the beginning. If the first day of the week was the third day, the day preceding, or Sabbath, was the second, and the day before that or Friday, was the first. But if, on account of the word “since,” any say that we must go back further still, we can go back only another day, which would carry us to Thursday; and this is as far as it is possible to go; and that, too, for the trial of Christ, and not merely for his crucifixion.
This circumstance and this positive declaration of the disciples, evidently staggers Mr. Wardner in his argument. He meets it by saying: “Is it proper to make an incidental remark of an uninspired man, outweigh and set aside a carefully written statement of an inspired penman?” This raises again our question, “Were the disciples able to count three?” We do not imagine it would require a great deal of “inspiration” to enable the disciples, under their circumstances, to keep the count, of three or four days at least, after the crucifixion; and we believe they stated it with exact correctness, and Christ did not accuse them of wrong reckoning. No inspired writer, as we shall see, has prepared any carefully written statement which contradicts this.
Not quite satisfied to leave it on that ground, Mr. W. turns around to find some “prominent item” from which they might have reckoned, and fixes upon the setting of the watch at the sepulcher, as the great desideratum. He says: “Hence the setting of that watch would naturally be a prominent item among ‘all these things’ that they were talking over; and this was the third day after it”!!
How much weight this is entitled to, may be estimated by reading again the words of the disciples to Christ, who say not one word about the setting of the watch, but dwell upon the trial and the crucifixion. A position which drives its adherents to such makeshifts as to try to discredit the statement of the disciples because they were not inspired (as if they could not keep track of time for three days), and then set up an artificial starting point from which to reckon, of which the disciples make no mention whatever, sufficiently betrays its inherent weakness.
We have two notable instances which show us how both Christ and the apostles reckoned “the third day.” When it was feared that Herod was plotting the destruction of Jesus, and he was desired to depart out of Herod’s jurisdiction, he made reply: “Go ye, and tell that fox, Behold, I cast out devils, and I do cures to-day and to-morrow, and the third day I shall be perfected.” Luke 13:32. Here the day then current when the conversation was held, though a portion of it had of course passed, was counted as one, the morrow as two, and the day after the morrow, as three.
Again in Acts 27:18, 19, Paul, in giving an account of his shipwreck, says: “And we being exceedingly tossed with a tempest, the next day they lightened the ship; and the third day we cast out with our own hands the tackling of the ship.” Here, also, the day on which the event first mentioned occurred, is reckoned as the first, the day following as the second, and the next the third.
Applying the same rule to the time of Christ’s death and resurrection, we have the day on which the events first spoken of occurred, the trial and crucifixion of Christ, as the first day of the series; the day which he passed in the tomb as the second day; and the day on which he arose and appeared to his disciples, the third day. And such a period the people of that time were accustomed to speak of as “three days,” “after three days,” the “third day,” “three days, night or day,” “three days and three nights.” Eld. W. may call the method by which Christ and his apostles reckoned time, “loose interpretation.” We do not so regard it. But whether it was or not, our duty is to follow the same rule when interpreting their words.
A portion of our first proposition (namely, that the view that Christ was crucified on Wednesday and arose on the Sabbath, rests on assumption) is now proved. The claim that the expression, “three days and three nights,” means just seventy-two hours, no more, no less, is an assumption. It cannot be proved. All the evidence goes to show that it means, or at least may mean, a less period than that. We have another still worse assumption to expose before we leave this point; but that must be deferred to another week. Then we will show that the position under review, is against the Sabbath cause, and finally, that it is contrary to the Scriptures.