A QUOTATION CONFIRMED

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 24, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 30.

Read the full edition

A QUOTATION CONFIRMED.

THE little leaflet issued from this Office, entitled “Candid Admissions from Sunday Observers and Writers concerning the First Day of the Week,” contains on page 2 the following paragraph:—
The Encyclopædia Britannica, after calling attention to the usual scriptural arguments, says: “Still, it must be owned that three passages are not sufficient to prove the apostolical institution of the Lord’s day, or even the actual observance of it.”—Art., Sabbath.
A correspondent wrote us some time ago, stating that he could find no such statement in the Britannica, the edition he consulted being the ninth, found in the Ohio State Library, at Columbus. Bro. W. A. Spicer has looked the matter up for us in the Museum Library in London, and reports that he finds in the eighth edition, Edinburgh, 1859, these words:—
Still, however, it must be owned that those passages, although the plainest that occur, are not sufficient to prove the apostolical institution of the Lord’s day, or even the actual observation of it.
There was, on the shelves of the library, the ninth edition of the Britannica, also, which gave Bro. S. the opportunity to compare the two. Of the difference between them, he writes:—
The writer on the Sabbath in the eighth edition writes well on the subject until he comes to the New Testament, and strongly denounces the idea that the Sabbath was not instituted until the exodus. You know what a different position is taken by the writer in the ninth edition. The subject is taken up in an entirely different manner.
The explanation, therefore, lies in the fact that the Britannica in its ninth edition takes a different position on the Sabbath question, from the one set forth in the eighth edition. It is to be regretted that when an opinion is expressed which is evidently honest, and pre-eminently sensible, like that above quoted from the eighth edition, it should not be allowed to stand. But it is perhaps not surprising. For as the light is being turned upon the Sunday institution, revealing the slimpiness of its foundation, its friends are becoming alarmed for the superstructure, and will suppress, as far as possible, all damaging admissions concerning it. But facts are facts, and can never be changed.