In a recent article, Thomas Huxley says: “It appears to me that the standard of (intellectual) veracity is higher among men of science than in any other class of the community. In this respect, they are already a long way ahead of the churches. I do not know of any body of scientific men who could be got to listen without the strongest expressions of disgustful repudiation, to the exposition of a pretended scientific discovery which had no better evidence to show for itself than the story of the devils entering into the swine.”
And yet this is the man who can do considerably more than listen patiently to stories a deal harder to believe than that of the swine. Has he not listened with both ears to the story that we have swine for ancestors—nay, worse still, that we must look for our parents in as ugly and fermenting a slime as ever swine wallowed in? Methinks I remember that in the city of New York, this apostle of bathybius not only listened very patiently to such stories, but told them himself; not only told them himself, but made affidavit that they were as well proved as the Copernican astronomy.
Mr. Huxley does “not know of any body of scientific men who,” etc.—we must spare space and time. He is unfortunate. Where has he been living? His environment cannot have been what I have supposed. I took it for granted that he mingled somewhat with brother scientists, and kept somewhat of an eye open on what was going on, at least in the United Kingdom. But it seems that I was mistaken. He has never heard of that body of British scientists, 617 strong, many of them of the highest eminence, who at the meeting of the British Association for the advancement of science, in 1865, issued a manifesto, signed by all of them, and deposited in the Bodleian Library at Oxford, that they knew of no science that conflicted with the Bible, of course not excepting the story of the swine. This manifesto was neither made nor kept in a corner. Where was Mr. Huxley that he did not happen to know of it? Perhaps he was so deep in biological studies and in the effort to trace back life to a spontaneous beginning in bathybius, that he was oblivious to what was passing.
Prof. Huxley, among his other professions, professes to look with small respect on men who are so unscientific as to believe the Bible. Does he mean to say that Sir Isaac Newton, and Blaise Pascal, and Michael Faraday, and many a man like them, were not respectably scientific? Does he mean to say that Guizot and Thiers and Gladstone and nearly all the great English jurists who accept the Bible with all its stories, have not decent knowledge and practice of the nature and laws of evidence? These latter men, it is true, are not classed with technical scientists, but for all that they have been very tolerable reasoners, and have been perhaps quite as well qualified by their broad endowments and culture to judge the book with judicial fairness as is a specialist in biology.
Prof. Huxley is amazed at the easy faith of the churches. The churches, too, have their amazements. One of them is that such men as Prof. Huxley should make such a business of throwing stones when they live in such glass houses themselves. Does he not know what the history of science has been from the beginning, and what sort of history it is making to-day? All along the ages things have passed muster as proved science that are now universally discredited and laughed at, and always deserved to be. Has not the present generation seen us beaten off from many a demonstrated bit of science—astronomical, geological, archæological? Are not the scientific circles of to-day divided into mutually hostile camps, each positive that only its own views deserve to be called science, and ready to splinter spears for the same? Are these people all “a long way ahead of the churches” for sure-paced and exacting logic; especially such of them as maintain such precious bits of science as the following—the universe is self-built, mental and moral forces are born of mere matter and die into the same, ethics at bottom is nothing but the translation into speech of certain necessary and useful fermentations of the human brain? How people who swallow such camels can strain at such gnats as the Christian doctrines, is something wonderful. The Huxleyites are among the greatest romancers we have. I would call them poets if they would prefer that title, were it not so hard for us to agree on what poetry is. The word is almost as much of a puzzle as civilization. On the whole, we will stick to romancers. We all know what that word means. It means air castles built in magnificent contempt of all the probabilities. It means “The Arabian Nights,” “The Mysteries of Udolpho,” and “King Solomon’s Mines.” It means what the London Times aptly calls Darwinism; viz., the last link in an unlimited chain of guesses. Is this a scientific use of the imagination?
If Mr. Huxley has any more “lay sermons” to preach, let him preach on.—E. E. Burr, D. D., in Episcopal Recorder.