AdventAI

NO POPE FOR HUNDREDS OF YEARS.

By R. S. Webber

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 9., February 28, 1888

BY ELD. R. S. WEBBER.

I recently went to hear what is no uncommon thing, a minister preach against the Sabbath. He said there was no pope for hundreds of years after Christ. B. Mathewson reported him in a New England paper, as follows:—

He also showed the utter futility of the pope's having changed the day from the seventh to the first, as there was no pope for hundreds of years after Christ.

Since then I heard another preacher make the same statement. Now, it seems to me that such men must know better. All history teaches that there began to be popes very early, even within the first three centuries. Originally, the popes of Rome were merely elders or bishops of the church at Rome. In the first half of the second century nearly all, if not quite all, of the independent churches were ruled by a bishop and a presbytery. Occasional councils, called Synods, composed for the most part of bishops, can also be traced up to this century. These were very common in the time of Tertullian, A. D. 200, and rapidly spread all over Christendom. The rules and canons enacted by these Synods were received as laws of the church which, even in those days, was called the Catholic Church. For full particulars upon this point, see Waddington's Church History, p. 177. Because of the luster and glory of the imperial city, the Church at Rome soon became distinguished above the other churches. Very soon the bishops of the Church at Rome began to arrogate unto themselves great power, till at length they gained the supremacy over all the churches. “The word ‘pope’ (Latin, papa) means father, and was always applied to the bishops of Rome.” Putnam says:—

This name was originally given to all bishops. It was first adopted by Hyginus, A. D. 138. And Pope Boniface III. procured Phocas, emperor of the East, to confine it to the prelate of Rome, A. D. 606.—The World's Progress, by Putnam.

Johnson says in his New Universal Cyclopedia, a Protestant work of the highest authority, Art. “Pope”:—

POPE [Gr. papas; Lat. papa], a term applied in the Greek Church to all priests, and originally used in the same manner also in the Western Church; but in the latter part of the fifth century it began to be applied exclusively to the bishop of Rome, and since the time of Gregory VII. (1073–85) it has become his official title. He is also called “Sovereign Pontiff,” “Vicar of Christ,” and “Holy Father.”

The following I copy from the Encyclopedia of Chronology, by Woodward and Cates, London:—

There were thirty-two popes in the first three centuries to Sylvester I., A. D. 314. Empowered to judge over other bishops by decree of Emperor Valentinian, A. D. 372. Confirmed by Council of Rome, 378 A. D. Primacy of, claimed by Innocent I. A. D. 417.

Bower says Sylvester I. was the thirty-second bishop of Rome. See Vol. 1, p. 45.

Dr. Schaff says that according to Eusebius there were thirty-seven popes before Sylvester I. See “Church History,” pp. 166, 167.

Dr. Beecher says:— This long list of popes [to Pius IX.] may be divided into six classes, according to the state of the civil government of the world. The first class includes those who were under the Roman Empire for three centuries before the conversion of Constantine to Christianity. Of these, thirty-two are given by Kenrick and Donnou, up to Sylvester.—Papal Conspiracy Exposed, by Rev. Edward Beecher, D. D., page 240.

Bower's “History of the Popes” is one of the most popular works of the kind. He gives a list of all the popes. We subjoin his list for the first 337 years of the Christian era, to Pope Julius I.

A. D.
St. Peter
Linus (about) 66
Cletus 78
Clement I. 91
Evaristus 100
Alexander I. 109
Sixtus I. 119
Telephorus 128
Hyginus 139
Pius I. 142
Anicetus (about) 157
Soter 168
Eleutherius 176
Victor I. 192
Zephyrinus 201
Calixtus I. 219
Urbanus I. 223
Pontianus 230
Anterus 235
Fabianus 236
Cornelius 251
Lucius I. 253
Stephen I. 253
Sixtus II. 257
Dionysius 258
Felix I. 269
Eutychianus 275
Caius 283
Marcellinus 296
Marcellus I. 308
Eusebius 310
Melchiades 311
Sylvester I. 314
Mark 336
Julius I. 337

Therefore there were popes in the first centuries after Christ; all agree upon this point. But suppose there were no popes for a few centuries, what does that prove? Nobody believes the Sabbath was changed for more than 300 years after Christ. The change was gradual; it was many years before it could be accomplished.

Prof. Brerewood, in his treatise, p. 77, says:—

The Sabbath of the seventh day . . . was religiously observed in the east church 300 years after our Saviour's passion. That church being the great part of Christendom, and having the accepted doctrine and example, would have restrained it if it had been deadly.

Dr. John Ley, in “Sunday Sabbath,” p. 163, says:—

From the apostles' time until the Council of Laodicea, which was about the year 384, the holy observation of the Jewish Sabbath continued, as may be proved out of many authors.

Prof. Stuart, of Andover, himself a Sunday-keeper and a recognized evangelical author and teacher, in his Appendix to “Gurney's History of the Sabbath,” p. 115, says: “The practice of it [keeping the Sabbath] was continued by Christians who were jealous for the honor of the Mosaic law, and finally became, as we have seen, predominant throughout Christendom.”

Mr. Morer says:—

The primitive Christians had a great veneration for the Sabbath, and spent the day in devotion and sermons.

He continues:—

And it is not to be doubted but they derived this practice from the apostles themselves.—Morer's Lord's Day, p. 189.

Lyman Coleman says:—

Down even to the fifth century the observance of the Jewish Sabbath was continued in the Christian church, but with a rigor and solemnity gradually diminishing until it was wholly discontinued.—Ancient Christianity Exemplified, chap. 26, sec. 2.

It was many hundred years before Sunday was kept as a Sabbath. Speaking of it, “Chambers's Encyclopedia” says:—

By none of the Fathers before the fourth century is it identified with the Sabbath, nor is the duty of observing it grounded by them, either on the fourth commandment, or on the precept of Jesus or his apostles.—Art. Sabbath.

Sir Wm. Domville says:—

Centuries of the Christian era passed away before the Sunday was observed as a Sabbath.

Neander says:—

The festival of Sunday . . . was always only a human ordinance; . . . far from the early apostolic church to transfer the law of the Sabbath to Sunday.—Rose's Neander, p. 180; Andrews's Hist. of Sab., p. 229.

Bishop Jeremy Taylor says:—

The primitive Christians did all manner of work upon the Lord's day, even in the times of persecution, when they were the strictest observers of all the divine commandments; but in this they knew there were none.—Ductor Dubitantium, part 1, book 2, chap. 2, sec. 59.

Dr. Heylyn again says:—

Take which you will, either the Fathers or the moderns, and we shall find no Lord's day instituted by any apostolic mandate; no Sabbath set on foot by them upon the first day of the week.—History of the Sabbath, p. 266.

The Townsend Herald says:—

It must be admitted, too, that no statute can be altered or repealed by any power inferior to that which enacted it. . . . You may search from Genesis to Revelation for a command or injunction to this effect [first-day observance], but you will search in vain.

Buck's Theological Dictionary, p. 403, after presenting all the first-day arguments, says:—

These arguments, however, are not satisfactory to some; and it must be confessed that there is no law in the New Testament concerning the first day.

The Augsburg Confession, drawn up by Melancthon, says:—

The observance of the Lord's day is founded not on any command of God, but on the authority of the church.—Cox's Sab. Manual, part 2, chap. 1, sec. 10; also History of Sabbath, p. 434.

Webster says:—

The heathen nations in the north of Europe dedicated this day to the sun, and hence their Christian descendants continue to call the day Sunday.

Sunday was a name given by the heathen to the first day of the week, because it was the day on which they worshiped the sun.

Constantine the Great was the first to give a command to abstain from labor on Sunday, A. D. 321. It was in honor of his sun god Apollo. Chambers's Encyclopedia says:—

Unquestionably the first law, either ecclesiastical or civil, by which the Sabbatical observance of that day is known to have been ordained, is the edict of Constantine, 321 A. D.

The edict reads as follows:—

Let all the judges and towns-people, and the occupation of all trades, rest upon the venerable day of the sun; but let those who are situated in the country, freely and at full liberty attend to the business of agriculture [etc.].

This is the first law or command ever found to abstain from labor on Sunday, given by a heathen, a worshiper of the sun; and this granted the farmers perfect liberty to plow, sow, harrow, build fence, and do agricultural business. We do positively know that there was no law in the Christian church at that time against labor on Sunday. Dr. Heylyn says:—

Tertullian tells us that they did devote the Sunday partly unto mirth and recreation, not to devotion altogether; when in a hundred years after Tertullian's time, there was no law nor constitution to restrain men from labor on this day, in the Christian churches.

It is true they devoted part of the day to devotion. The same is true of Friday and other days. Mosheim says:—

Perhaps also (Good Friday) the Friday on which our Saviour died was from the earliest times regarded with more respect than other days of the week.—Mosheim, by James Murdock, vol. 1, page 104, note 4.

Again he says:—

Many also observe the fourth day of the week, on which Christ was betrayed; and the sixth, which was the day of his crucifixion.—Ecclesiastical History, cent. 1, part 2, chap. 4, note 1.

The Mohammedans have observed Friday precisely as the early Christians did Friday and Sunday, partly to devotion and partly to mirth and recreation, from the days of Mohammed until the present time, more than 1,200 years. Mr. Sale says:—

However it be, the Mohammedan writers bestow very extraordinary encomiums on this day [Friday], calling it the prince of days, and the most excellent day on which the sun rises, pretending also that it will be the day whereon the last Judgment will be solemnized.—Preliminary to the Koran, by Geo. Sale, p. 114.

The Mohammedans never call Friday the Sabbath, but simply “assembly day”; and it is a fact worthy of our notice, that the early Christians never called Sunday the Sabbath, but, as above shown, they did all manner of work upon that day; there was no law against work in the country upon Sunday until the Roman Catholic Council of Orleans passed a decree against it, A. D. 538. Dr. Chambers adds:—

But it was not till the year 538 that abstinence from agricultural labor on Sunday was recommended rather than enjoined by an ecclesiastical authority, the third Council of Orleans. It [the Roman Church] has revered the fourth commandment, doing away with the Sabbath of God's word, and instituting Sunday as a holy day.—N. Summerbell's Hist. of the Christians, p. 418.

Respecting the first day of the week, the historian Dr. Peter Heylyn says:—

Thus do we see upon what ground the Lord's day stands: on custom first, and voluntary consecration of it to religious meetings; . . . after, from the canons and decrees of councils, the decretals of popes, and orders of particular prelates, when the sole managing of ecclesiastical affairs was committed to them. . . . The Lord's day had no such command [as the Sabbath had] that it should be sanctified.—Andrews's Hist. of the Sab., p. 353.

Dr. Heylyn says that Petrus Alfonsus was the first to call Sunday by the name of Christian Sabbath, and that he lived about the beginning of the twelfth century, and that “it was near 900 years from our Saviour's birth, if not quite so much, before restraint of husbandry on this day had been first thought of in the East.” (See Andrews's “History of the Sabbath,” p. 371.)

We have before seen that labor in the West wasp. 132 not prohibited in the country on Sunday, till the Roman Catholic Council at Orleans, A. D. 538. Thus it was gradually and slowly by the decrees of councils and the decretals of popes, that the Sabbath of the Lord was degraded to a common day, and “the wild solar holiday” of the pagans was exalted to be a Sabbath. In the Bible we are taught that the man of sin would exalt himself “above all that is called God, or that is worshiped,” and that he would think to change the law of God. See 2 Thess. 2:3, 4; Dan. 7:25. All agree that this is the pope of Rome, the antichrist. This prophecy has been fulfilled by the changing of the Sabbath. As Dr. A. Campbell says, in speaking of the Sabbath:—

If it be changed, it was that august personage changed it who changes times and laws; I think his name is Dr. Antichrist.—Chris. Dis., vol. 1, p. 44.

In the councils of the church in the second century, and all the way down through the third and fourth centuries, long before they gained the supremacy, the influence of the pope of Rome was great. In a Roman Catholic Council held at Laodicea, A. D. 364, the power of the pope was mighty, and a curse was pronounced upon those that kept the seventh-day Sabbath. So, then, the Catholic Church, with the popes at the head, did change the Sabbath.

SUNDAY.

“Our Sunday takes its name from the bright sun, By heathens called the god of light and day; At his approach the morning has begun, Rejoicing nature glories in his ray.”

SABBATH.

“The Sabbath takes its name from God's own rest, When he at first the earth's foundations laid; This day alone he sanctified and blessed; And thus for man the Sabbath day was made.”

Bangor, Maine.