SLIGHTLY INCONSISTENT

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 9, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 40.

Read the full edition

SLIGHTLY INCONSISTENT.

In the Christian Statesman of Sept. 18, is a short catechetical article which sets forth the writer's view of National Reform. In answer to the question as to how it is possible to make Christ the ruler of this country's national life, when the land is a chaos of beliefs, prejudices, and ignorance, it is there stated that the nation must be converted, “just as the truth concerning personal religion must be preached to man, in order to his conversion.”
Had the writer said that the subject of the National Reform movement contemplated personal labor with people in the nation until the last sinner should be converted, the efforts of its promoters could be considered only laudable; but when the writer goes on to say that “preaching the truths of personal religion alone will not save the nation, any more than preaching the truths of national religion will save individual souls,” he states the matter in a light that shows the inconsistency of the whole movement.
We do not say that the statement is not true; for we fully believe that it is. We further believe that the exact truth of the matter could not be more tersely stated than it is in that sentence. But let us weigh the matter carefully. Preaching national religion will not save individual souls. And yet the entire life, and all the energies of the being, of scores of talented men, and thousands upon thousands of dollars, are being expended—for what?—According to their own confession, for a work which has no power to convert an individual soul. More than this; they propose to move heaven and earth to secure the object of their desire—a converted nation. And yet after having done all this, no individual soul will have been converted through the Herculean task.
No one can say that this conclusion is not legitimately drawn. Then why waste time and means to bring about a religious reform in the nation, which will not be a religious benefit to individual souls? It may be said that when the nation becomes Christian by vote, then individuals in the nation will have the benefit of the nation's condition. But if the conversion of the nation does not convert its individual members, where does the benefit come in? Will they not still be unconverted, and need personal labor? Why, then, not do the personal labor in the start, and let the other part alone until the first and most important part of the work is accomplished?
But the accomplishment of such a work is evidently not what the National Reformers are after. The very fact that they disclaim any power in their work, to effect the salvation of individual souls, shows that theirs is another work than that of the salvation of their fellow-men in the good old-fashioned way. What they want is power to control the sentiment of the nation, so as to oblige all to outwardly conform to certain religious tenets, regardless of the condition of the heart.
We had always supposed that the nation was composed of its citizens, and that so far as these citizens were reformed, just so far the nation would be reformed. But it seems that these nineteenth century reformers do not view the matter in that light. They say that personal religion is one thing, and national religion another; that even though the majority of the nation's citizens are Christians, and might, if they chose, control the sentiment of the nation, there is an element lacking, in their estimation, which can be supplied only by the nation's conversion.
This seems strange to an unsophisticated person. How the nation is to be converted, without teaching personal religion, would indeed be a poser, were it not that these Reformers (?) have laid the matter open before all. They say that while “there is a decisive majority of Christians, even numerically considered, . . . they allow themselves to be divided up on issues which are irrelevant to the kingdom of Christ, and do not control the nation.” That is to say, Christians are now allowed to think for themselves, and to vote on moral questions as they consider for the best good of themselves and the country at large; and by so doing, scatter their votes to some extent. Therefore, our National Reformers want a conversion in the nation which will make all cast their votes solid for whatever dogma the leaders of religious thought may formulate.
And this is the effort of the National Reform movement, according to their own statements, when they are fully analyzed. But woe to any country that shall be brought under such domination. It would be but the repetition of the history of the Dark Ages, when men's minds were dwarfed because some combination did the thinking, and the subjects quietly sustained them in their manipulations. Is it possible that with the history of the papal supremacy before the people of this generation, they can be led into such a snare?—It is more than probable from the present outlook that this will be the case; but when it comes, look for persecution and moral darkness, from the midst of which the Lord has promised to redeem his faithful people.
J. O. C.