The first authoritative action of the Catholic Church in substituting the Sunday for the Sabbath of the Lord, was that of the Council of Laodicea, in the year 364. An effort has been made to evade the force of this fact, and to disconnect this work from the papacy, by offering the following objection; namely, the Council of Laodicea was held in the Eastern church, and not in Rome; therefore the change was not made by the papal church.
If anything were needed to prove that they who try to uphold the Sunday are reduced to great straits, their offering such an objection as this would surely serve the purpose. It clearly proves that they take only superficial views of the evidences on the subject, and have never considered the real relation of events and localities. On this subject, notice a few points:—
1. The council which declared the primacy of the bishop of Rome, was also held in Asia Minor.
2. The bishop of Rome was constituted the head of all the churches, and the effectual corrector of heretics, by the emperor of the East.
3. No general council was held west of Constantinople until the twelfth century. Does this fact have any effect on the supremacy of the popes of Rome in the centuries preceding?
4. The decrees of councils received no authority from the places where they were held, but from the consent and action of the emperors, popes, and churches.
5. No council was ever held that better served the purposes of the pope of Rome, than the second Council of Nice, Asia Minor, A. D. 787, called by Irene, empress of the East. Irene, crafty and unscrupulous, caused Tarasius, a layman, to be made bishop of Constantinople. Pope Hadrian I., “offended at the uncanonical election and ordination of a layman, had declared that he approved of his election only upon condition that he got the holy images restored.” So says Bower. But why did the pope look to such a source for the accomplishment of such an object? It was because he knew that Charlemagne, then ruling in the West, was opposed to the worship of images, and so were most all the bishops of the West; and he knew that Irene was in favor of the images. There appeared to be no hope of their restoration, under the circumstances, except by means of a council called by the empress and the patriarch of Constantinople. This council was attended by 375 bishops, all from the East, the West being represented by the pope’s legates only. There was great unanimity in their decision; but great also was the indignation manifested throughout the West. Charlemagne convened a council at Frankfort to counteract the decision of that of Nice, the decree of which was there condemned. The emperor made every effort to induce the pope to condemn the Council of Nice, and to reverse its decision, but in vain. The pope declared that “apostolic tradition” was in favor of the adoration of images; and through his influence the decision of the second Council of Nice became the established faith of the church. Had the pope united with Charlemagne and the bishops of the West, that canon of Nice would have become a dead letter. Does the fact that this council was held in Asia Minor, and was called by the empress of the East, destroy the claim that image-worship is a Romish, or papal, dogma?
6. The Council of Laodicea was not ecumenical, but, as says the Cyclopedia of McClintock & Strong, its canons “were received by the other churches.” The decisions of some of the most important councils, as that of Chalcedon, and the second of Nice, were subjects of much contention. Probably the canons of no council met with greater favor than those of Laodicea, and amongst them the 29th was almost universally accepted, because the decree of Constantine had already popularized the day of the sun, and because the observance of the seventh day was stigmatized as a badge of Judaism. But it was most favorably received in the West, the papal church making the Sabbath a fast day, which action was opposed at Constantinople. All history attests that Sunday received its strongest support from Rome, and that opposition to the Sabbath was much stronger at Rome than in the East. The observance of the Sabbath continued longer in the East than in the West. As in the case of the second of Nice, so in that of Laodicea, Rome was the life and strength of its canons.
7. The words of the best historians may be quoted to prove that it was not by any one act, nor in a brief period of time, that the Sabbath was entirely supplanted by the day of the sun. That Rome, with all her influence, found it extremely difficult to exalt Sunday to the place it attained, is proved by the many decrees of emperors and canons of councils which were found to be necessary to accomplish the object. Dr. Heylyn says the sixth council of Constantinople, A. D. 690, “did admonish those of Rome to forbear fasting upon that day upon pain of censures.” Rome had compelled fasting upon the Sabbath about three centuries before that, and she persisted, and prevailed. The Sunday church-festival, gradually turned into a Sunday Sabbath, is as truly a creature of the papacy, as is the custom of image-worship.
8. All that part of the Protestant Church at large which is represented in faith by the Baptists, has been forward to lay innovations to the papacy. It has persistently declared that infant baptism is an institution of the papal church. That infant baptism, even as the Sunday, owes its strength and perpetuity, its general acceptance, to Rome cannot be denied. And yet, who does not know that infant baptism originated in Africa, and not in Rome? So impossible is it for the advocates of Sunday to be consistent.
The sum of the matter is this: The primacy of Rome was declared in the East; the supremacy of Rome over all the churches was established in the East; all the general councils, before the 12th century, were held in the East; all the churches, east and west, were united into one hierarchy by Constantine; and the actual division into the eastern and western churches was not until the tenth century. Therefore, the councils held in the East were the councils of the Catholic Church as established by Constantine, over which the bishop of Rome was given the primacy by the first general council held in Asia Minor, A. D. 325.
But this objection is only an evasion; a subterfuge by which, if possible, to keep out of sight the fact that the Sabbath was changed for the Sunday by the church in the fourth century. Were the objection valid,—were it a fact that the church represented by Rome had nothing to do with establishing this canon of Laodicea,—it would not aid the cause of Sunday at all. It would still remain a fact that the Sunday institution, as a day of church observance, received its authority (1) from the 29th canon of the Council of Laodicea; and (2) from those who enforced and gave effect to this canon. It can be traced to no other source. But, unfortunately for the cause of the objectors, they cannot possibly separate this action from the Catholic Church, of which the bishop of Rome was at that time the primate, and from whom this canon received its best support.
They who are even partially acquainted with the history of the church in the early centuries, will not need this explanation. But it is very apparent that the advocates of Sunday are quite ignorant of the facts of history, or are fully determined to suppress those facts. Flimsy as is the objection here noticed, it has been urged with most amazing confidence. The confident manner of the objector might deceive, where the objection itself has no weight.
J. H. W.