AdventAI

PAPAL INFALLIBILITY, THEN AND NOW.

By Loyd Caldwell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 22., May 29, 1888

BY LOYD CALDWELL.

A 150 YEARS TEST OF VATICANISM: 1300-1450 A. D.

The noontide of the papacy was 1300 A. D. Boniface VIII. started its decline by issuing the bulls “Clericus Laicos” and “Unam Sanctam,” in the former condemning all rulers who claimed, and all clergy who paid, any tax in any form from the church to the state. (The church owned nearly a third of all Catholic property, and collected an immense revenue. The clergy could not be prosecuted in civil courts. See “Mortmain,” “Benefit of Clergy,” “Exemptions,” etc., in Foye.) “Unam Sanctam” affirms two swords, both in the hands of the church (pontiff); the spiritual wielded solely by the priest, the temporal by the kings and soldiers, but at the will and pleasure of the priest! “Moreover,” it concludes, “we declare, say, pronounce, and define that every human being should be in subjection to the Roman pontiff to be an article of necessary faith”!—necessary to salvation. (See Hallam, Dowling, Dupin, Neander, Mosheim, etc.) It is still, and must remain, everywhere in force.

King Philip the Fair, of France, resisted, and got them revoked as to France in 1311, by Clement V. who the same year condemned the Knights Templars to recant or die by torture, as many did. From 1305 to 1376 the popes resided, not at Rome, but at Avignon, France; which seventy years are known as the Babylonish captivity. From 1378 to 1448 or 1449, was the “Great Schism”—a double or triple line of popes for about seventy years more! Study the following diagram, and you can better appreciate the sublime impudence of the dogma of papal infallibility:—

THE GREAT PAPAL SCHISM 1378-1449.

POPES AT ROME. POPE AT PISA. POPES AT AVIGNON.
1378 URBAN VI. Supported by Italy, Germany, England, Sweden, and Denmark. CLEMENT VII. Supported by France, Spain, Scotland, and Sicily.
1389 BONIFACE IX.
1394 · · · BENEDICT XIII.
1404 INNOCENT VII.
1406 GREGORY XII.
1409 The council at Pisa assembled to heal the schism, deposed (on paper) both Gregory and Benedict as perjured heretics, and chose Alexander V. As both Gregory and Benedict refused to acknowledge the authority of the council, there was presented before Christendom the edifying spectacle of three popes at once! ALEX. V. Chosen by a union of the cardinals who had not approved either Gregory or Benedict. [ALEX. V. continued the decrees of Pisa; Martin V., those of Constance; Eugene IV., those of Basel. Evidently, with John XXIII. (who called that of Constance), Gregory XII., and Felix V., had a high number of the authority of councils.]
1410 JOHN XXIII.
1413 The great council of Constance (1414-18) deposed all three popes, John for monstrous crimes, Gregory and Benedict as perjured heretics. John and Gregory submitted, but Benedict, though deserted by his adherents, held to his office. No successor being chosen for two years, Christendom during this time was without any pope, unless the double-deposed and excommunicated Benedict XIII. be counted.
1417 MARTIN V. Martin sent the council home, but postponed demanded reforms to a future council.
1423 CLEMENT VIII. Abdicated in 1429.
1431 EUGENE IV. In this year the great council of Basel assembled, approved Pisa and Constance, and declared a council to be above a pope. Eugene deposed it (on paper), and then re-proved it from beginning until it should act. Then (1437) he ordered it to Ferrara and thence (1439) to Florence. Finally the council adjourned, after choosing Felix V., between whom and Eugene IV. a mutual war of excommunication followed.
1439 FELIX V. Abdicated 1449.
1440 · · ·
1447 NICHOLAS V.

Finally, the Basel fathers re-assembled in 1449, and induced Felix to reign as pope, to take chief place under Nicholas, thus ending the schism and 150 years of scandal. Nicholas, in return, approved in full the contradictory decrees of both Basel and Ferrara Florence! The councils of Pisa, Constance, and Basel were much larger and more representative than that of Florence, and all pope-approved; still Jesuits usually reject them, and count in Florence!

There is no theory of infallibility that can bridge over these 150 years. Consult the encyclopedias, church histories, lists of popes, councils, etc., and compare with the above. You will find it as authentic as anything in papal history. Bishop Hefele, “who has forgotten more about the history of councils than the infallible pope ever knew” (Dr. Schaff), numbers Constance and Basel as the 16th and 17th councils, and counts Ferrara-Florence as a continuation of Basel. The much-lauded “Catholic Belief” omits both Constance and Basel, and numbers the Florence side-show as No. 17. Both are high Catholic authorities. Why doesn’t the infallible pope decide? There is the same trouble in tracing the popes through the “Great Schism.” Compare lists, and see. Why doesn’t the infallible pope decide? Pope Paul V. in 1607 promised a decision of the predestination question, and the theological world is still waiting! Pope Pius IX. in 1854 decided “by divine authority,” that the “ever virgin mother of God,” Mary, was preserved from all stain of original sin. Should not the former topic precede, logically and chronologically? We move the previous question.