PROHIBITIONISTS AND THE SABBATH QUESTION.
[In the Watertown (N. Y.) Advocate of April 12, 1888, Bro. M. C. Wilcox discusses the relation of the Sabbath question and Sabbath-keepers to the prohibition movement and prohibitionists. Our readers will be interested in the thoughts presented, as we shall be called upon more and more to vindicate our position along this line of argument.] Mr. Editor: Believing that your sense of fairness, justice, and generosity will permit a minority to speak, I venture to send this communication. The writer represents a class of Prohibitionists numerically small, it is true, but nevertheless, real and stanch friends of the temperance and prohibition cause. But they do not feel that they can unite in the propagation and maintenance of principles held, if we understand correctly, by many, if not the majority of Prohibitionists. I cannot better make my meaning clear than to refer to two resolutions at the Congressional Convention held in Gouverneur March 27. But in the outset, let me say that we believe in prohibition of the liquor traffic seven days in the week and fifty-two weeks in the year; therefore with the sentiment of the resolutions relating to that, we are in hearty sympathy and concord. But with the first and twelfth we cannot consistently with the principles of justice and liberty, be in harmony. The first resolution reads as follows:— Resolved, That we acknowledge Almighty God as the rightful sovereign of all men, and that to his laws, who is the source of all just government, all human enactments should conform as an absolute condition of peace, prosperity, and happiness. It seems good, but, Mr. Editor, the soft words cover a sharp sword. We believe that “Almighty God is the rightful sovereign of all men” just as much and as reverently as any one can; but to say that to his law all human enactments should conform, is proposing what can never be carried out. For the law by which God governs his subjects is essentially different in nature and character from what any human enactments can be or should be. God is a moral governor; his law is moral law. It relates not merely to outward action, but to inward motive. It points out not only man’s duty to his neighbor, but his duty to his Creator. However scrupulously the outward service may be performed, if the heart is not in harmony with the service, if the motives are wrong, the service counts for naught. Obedience to God’s law (of course through Christ) develops moral character. But not so with the laws of human governments. They are not moral but civil. They relate to overt acts alone. They are designed to promote civility, to compel men to be civil. To illustrate: The constitution of God’s government is his moral law summarily comprehended in the ten commandments. The first declares, “Thou shalt have no other gods before me.” In other words, it forbids idolatry. But “covetousness,” says the inspired apostle, “is idolatry.” Col. 3:5. The tenth commandment341 reads, “Thou shalt not covet.” The sixth reads, “Thou shalt not kill;” but “whosoever hateth his brother is a murderer” (1 John 3:15); that is, hatred carried to its legitimate result, if allowed, would issue in murder. The seventh precept reads, “Thou shalt not commit adultery;” but “whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart.” Matt. 5:28. The third commandment forbids blasphemy; but not only is he, the professed sinner, who thoughtlessly and irreverently takes the name of God in vain, guilty of blasphemy, but he who arrogantly assumes God’s prerogatives, and whose service may be professedly the service of God, is the more guilty. See Rev. 13:6; 2 Thess. 2:4; 2 Tim. 3:2, 5; Rev. 2:9. Now, Mr. Editor, how can human enactments conform to God’s law. To do so they must take cognizance of man’s motives and purposes. But God alone can read the heart; he alone, therefore, can rightly judge. Or will we by thumb-screw, fire, and fagot, the auto da fé, the rack, and torture of various kinds, exact the truth that some of our Loyolas, Torquemadas, Lauds, or Claverhouses may find employment? It was the carrying out of just such a principle as is embodied in the resolution, that developed the persecution and persecutors of the Dark Ages. They made what they supposed to be God’s law the law of the government. Human nature is the same now as then. Again, the underlying principle of God’s law is love (Matt. 22:37-40); but how can human laws compel love in the hearts of any? Once more, human governments have no right to enact laws which relate to man’s duty to his God. The laws which define that duty are above all human legislation. And wisely and well did our forefathers, the founders of our Government, lay its foundation. The first four precepts of the decalogue point out man’s duty to his Maker. With them human governments have no right. But it is their duty to protect the life, chastity, property, and reputation of their citizens, so far as overt acts are concerned. Hence civil governments deal only with civil law, in order to make man civil; and when they go beyond this, and legislate upon those relations which lie between man and his Maker, they are repeating the sad, fatal folly against which all history warns us. That twelfth resolution is but a legitimate sequence of the first. It reads:— Resolved, That we believe in preserving the sanctity of the Sabbath by the enforcement of present laws, and the enactment of such other laws as may be deemed necessary. Your report correctly states that after the discussion, “the wording was left to stand, as every man should read that resolution as addressed to himself personally. Then if he believed the Sabbath to fall on Sunday or Saturday, it would still echo his sentiments.” But, Mr. Editor, who said this? It was the echo of voices who were either indifferent or else knew that the term “the Sabbath” in law could be interpreted in only one way; viz., as the majority hold. It was one of the reverend gentlemen who were on the committee on resolutions who declared so positively, The resolution is all right as it is. Did he have a doubt as to what was designed by the resolution?—We know not. And note this: That resolution could not be understood by any sane man as “addressed to himself.” The resolution is not designed to protect individuals, but an institution termed “the Sabbath.” If for individuals, why did it not read something like this:— Resolved, That we believe in giving every man the right to observe the Sabbath as conscience dictates, and that his rights shall not be interfered with in this respect. But it is the institution to which the resolution relates, and not the man. Now, to carry out that resolution, “the sanctity of the Sabbath” would be preserved. But is not “the Sabbath” a definite institution? If it is one day to one and another day to another, how can its “sanctity be preserved”? The man who believes in the Sunday Sabbath keeps it, or can keep it, as religiously as he desires; the law protects him in these rights. But his seventh-day neighbor believes that God commands him to keep the seventh day, and that it is also a bounden duty to his family to work the other six, Sunday included. God and the Constitution grant him these rights. But if he works Sunday, how is the “sanctity” of the Sunday Sabbath preserved? And if the Sunday-keeper works on the seventh-day (as nearly all do), how is the “sanctity” of the seventh-day man’s Sabbath preserved? If you say of the first-day man, that he also ought to keep the seventh day, the reply would be that the law had no right to rob him of one seventh part of his time after he had conscientiously given the same amount to the Lord; and he would say truly. And would not the converse also be true? After a seventh-day man has kept the Sabbath conscientiously as he believes God commanded, have his fellow-citizens the right to say, “Sir, you must keep the first day also, that the sanctity of [what the majority holds to be] the Sabbath may be preserved?” And yet one party or both must yield in order that the resolution be carried into law. Again, would those who are compelled to abstain from work, and who would spend the day in sullen idleness, preserve its sanctity or holiness? Or would church attendance be compulsory? And would it not be necessary for a secret legal espionage to be made of the laws of our fellow-men? For to carry the resolution into effect, laws must be passed, must be enforced under penalty, or they are of no account; and so persecution inevitably follows, till “whosoever killeth you will think that he doeth God service.” The laws which led to persecution in the early centuries of the union of church and state, were not less seemingly harmless, nor so evident, as are the tokens of persecution in “the land of the free.” As the Rev. Chas. Beecher truly said: “Our best, most humble, most devoted servants of Christ, have in their midst what will one day, not long hence, show itself to be the spawn of the dragon.” We are pained to see the Prohibition party and the W. C. T. U. give their influence to such things, to suit a few ultra religionists. We are persuaded that the majority of Prohibitionists do not desire to oppress any one. The prohibition of the liquor traffic is the duty of a government as a measure of economy, safety, and to protect the property and lives and chastity of its subjects, especially the weaker ones, wives and children. But many Prohibitionists vote for religious laws without thinking of their effect if enacted, simply to please some in the party. As was said to the writer by a prominent delegate at Gansevoort, “I am willing to do anything for peace, aren’t you?” But we cannot sacrifice principle for peace. First pure and then peaceable, is the gospel order. Another said: “The resolution is to oppose Sunday liquor traffic.” “But,” we asked, “are you not for prohibition seven days in the week?” “Yes, sir,” was the reply. Then is not the Sabbath resolution in the interests of religious legislation solely? We discuss this question on the broad ground of right. If all in this land but ten were observers of the seventh-day Sabbath, they would have no earthly right to coerce the ten into the observance of that day. And it is just as true on the other hand. Human law has a right to compel men not to interfere with the worship of others, but it has no right to define what, or how, or when their worship shall be. “Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s,” are the words of Him who “spake as never man spake.” Caesar can demand only his own. The Sabbath is not a civil institution. Therefore Caesar has no right to demand it. It lies between man and his Maker solely. We write the above in no spirit of controversy. We desire to act intelligently on this subject. We wish to present before our brethren in the temperance cause our reasons. We ask them to weigh them candidly. May God bless the prohibition work, and help its leaders not to stain the otherwise noble work by religious legislation, which will ever lead to religious persecution.