AdventAI

THE PROTEUS OF VICES.

By F. N. Zabriskie

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 22., May 29, 1888

But even the race-course is “slow,” and a minor evil, in comparison with the spirit of speculation which is infecting all legitimate business, controlling not only the stock market, but the dealings in the staple commodities of daily life.

A bona fide purchase with a reasonable expectation of selling at a profit, is the essence and life of trade. But as soon as it becomes a willful taking of risks on an uncertain future, it begins to partake of the nature of gambling. It is betting against the unknown. Especially is the transaction stripped of all distinction from other forms of gaming, when it ceases to be a genuine acquisition and transfer of property, and represents only the paying of the difference between the market prices at the time of the “sale” and at the time of settlement. This is not simply a moralist’s view, but the uniform decision of the courts has been that such transactions are gambling, and hence pernicious in their nature and utterly void as contracts. Taking advantage of this fact, an effort is making in Chicago, New York, and Philadelphia by the stock exchanges, to cut the nerve of the outside “bucket shops” by cutting off from them all telegraphic service, or else to prosecute them on the plain charge of ordinary gambling. “But,” is the pertinent query of a Wall Street “Talker” in one of our leading papers, “suppose some zealous citizen should come along and want to press the same sort of charge against the Stock Exchange?” For the proportion of “sales” in the latter which involve actual transfer of property, is quite insignificant, and the purchases for legitimate investment still more so.

The growth of the “bucket shop” tells the story of the prodigious progress of the gambling spirit among all classes of our people. In five years these establishments have increased in New York from fifteen to 200, and it is estimated that their customers in the city amount to at least 10,000. They have been opened in all the cities of the country, and even in villages of 5,000 inhabitants. The business which five years ago was clandestine, is now plied conspicuously, and the customers are no longer almost exclusively notorious and disreputable gamblers. Respectable-looking people go in and out, and not a few of the frequenters are women. They deal not only in stocks, but in cotton, oil, wheat, and anything in which the various exchanges speculate. There is usually no limit to the smallness of the amount wagered, and the gambler sits watching the blackboard exactly as in a gaming-house he would watch the spots upon the roulette table.

These people, of course, almost always bet for a rise; and it is the interest and the unscrupulous and constant effort of the proprietors to depress the market. Hence a systematic circulation of false reports, whereby a sudden, if only a momentary, decline may be caused. Here, also, we have a miniature of the tactics pursued by the magnates and the minions of the Stock Exchange. Not only does this involve utterly baseless reports of men’s deaths and of political events, but insinuations and prophecies of failure against prominent brokers, bankers, and merchants. In a time of uncertainty no name is safe, and no scheme of demoralization and panic is left untried. Vast loans are called in unexpectedly, vast amounts of stock are thrown upon a staggering market. If in the wheat, or cotton, or coffee, or oil market, a syndicate is formed to buy up so much of the crop as to control it and “corner” other dealers and oppress the bona fide purchaser and consumer.

It is estimated that the clique engaged in the recent wheat operations held at one time 18,000,000 bushels out of a visible supply of probably not more than 25,000,000, and that not less than 100,000,000 bushels were “traded in” in a single day, involving a loss or gain of $7,000,000, or $8,000,000. The whole process is as heartless, malevolent, and nefarious as the “operations” of the robber barons of the Middle Ages, or the buccaneers of the Spanish Main. These “financial freebooters” not only prey upon each other, but more and more are enabled to reach the pockets of the people and even of the poor, who are unable or unwilling to see that speculation, like all other gambling, is a game of loaded dice for the owners of the “bank.” In this class of transactions these practically hold the stakes, and can and will manipulate them solely for their personal advantage. The crash which concludes a “mining spree” in San Francisco will wipe out the savings of thousands of working-men and working-women. The collapse of a wheat, pork, or petroleum “deal,” or a plunge downward in the stock market, will be echoed back all over the country in the ruin of bank officers, trustees, agents, and employees of every kind, usually a class of persons who have been above suspicion.

One of the worst results of the speculative mania seems to be the growing demoralization of the public conscience. Men, high in the church, as well as in respectable society, engage openly and unblushingly in these transactions, till the term “Christians at work” was not inaptly applied to them by a Jewish dealer. How many young men were there who did not follow the career of Jim Fisk or H. S. Ives with a secret admiration, till startled by their fall! And how much truth is there in the following “instantaneous photograph” of public sentiment:— “$1—‘Thief!’ $50,000—‘Defaulter!’ $100,000—‘Shortage!’ $500,000—‘Canadian Tourist!’ $1,000,000—‘Brilliant Financier!’”

Is it an exaggeration to say that we are fast becoming a nation of gamblers? Yet we must not despair of the Republic. In our zeal for other reforms we have lost sight of this. It only needs that the moral sentiment of the people be aroused as it was to the evil of slavery, and as it is now rising to sweep away the drinking saloon. Ten years ago lottery-selling was openly practiced in New York, and it took three years to secure the first conviction. To-day there is not a place where the public can buy a lottery ticket, and there is no difficulty in executing the law. So will it be in time with regard to the pool-room and the bucket-shop. It will be more difficult to educate public opinion to the “sticking-point” as respects betting on race-tracks and on the futures of crops and stocks, because there is more capital involved and more social prestige. It is “so English, you know,” to bet on the races as the royal family, the dukes of Westminster and Portland, Lords Hartington, Rosebery, and Randolph Churchill do. And there are untold millions engaged in the processes of self-ruin, mutual spoliation, and public rapine, which constitute the most brilliant and exciting “operations” of the exchanges. But by a systematic education of the young in the intrinsic immorality of all kinds of gambling, and their restraint in those species of petty gaming which are now cultivating their taste and habits for the vice; by the banishment of all resort to chance from church fairs and from moral society; by the restoration of our rural fairs from little more than race-courses to their legitimate objects; and by the consistent and persistent witness of life and lip and vote on the part of honest and earnest people, we may expect to stem even this threatening “tide of the times.”—F. N. Zabriskie, D. D., in Advance.