THE PROPHECY FOR SPIRITUALISM

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 29, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 22.

Read the full edition

“THE PROPHECY FOR SPIRITUALISM.”

Under this heading appears in a recent number of the Banner of Light (Spiritualist organ) a synopsis of a discourse by a leading Spiritualist, which contemplates the “marked changes in thought which have taken place since the advent of modern Spiritualism,” and forecasts the yet greater changes which it is predicted will be accomplished through its agency. We quote the following extract, the force of which, however unpleasant it may sound, no one familiar with the recent history and present standing of orthodoxy will be likely to deny:—
The theories of scientific men, said Mrs. Richmond, work a change in the world, whether for better or worse; and change prevents chronic fallacies, so that the world does not move in a groove of error as in past times. This change is going on not only in the realm of social science, in the sense of its direct application to human life, but in the still higher realm of the spiritual atmosphere; by which is meant not merely the demonstrated facts of Spiritualism, nor the belief in spiritual communion, but the general acceptance and contemplation of the possibilities of knowing something about man’s spirit here and hereafter. That which was formerly confined to metaphysical speculation has become the theme of almost general enlightened contemplation. Subjects that were forbidden to the human mind, either from theological prejudice, or from ignorance, or from the tendency to materialism, are now themes of daily contemplation and of possible knowledge. It is shown by the tide of thought which is flowing from the Orient toward the Occident in the forms of Oriental religions. Thirty years ago, Puritan Boston was shocked to hear an open defense of the religious belief of the Brahmans. It was thought that we were in danger of going back into heathenism and paganism. There has been a change within ten years. There is no religion upon earth that may not be considered in almost any intellectual, social, or even religious society in the country.
It is even possible now in London, Paris, New York, and Boston to be in rapport with the worship of the Buddhist, of the Indian, of the Brahman, of all the countries of the Orient, without in any way compromising one’s fidelity to the Christian religion in its most enlightened form. And this is due solely to the advent of modern Spiritualism some forty years ago.
Whether this result is “due solely to the advent of modern Spiritualism” or not, may be a matter of doubt; but that it is very largely due to this agency there can be no question. But what have the churches been doing all this time to oppose its alarming inroads upon the ranks of their communicants?—Simply nothing, or the next thing to it. Not that they favor Spiritualism, but the latter occupies a vantage ground upon which they dare not attack it. Securely intrenched in one of the strongholds of orthodox belief, the natural immortality of the soul, it cannot be dislodged without razing that stronghold itself to the ground, which of course never would be allowed. Better that Spiritualism should continue its deadly work of corruption and disintegration unhindered, than that this pet dogma of ancient paganism and modern theology should be cast aside.
Spiritualism approaches the masses through the easy avenue of their belief in man’s natural immortality, and appeals to them through the evidences of their senses, as at the Spiritualistic séance, and the natural longing of the human heart after that which it claims to give. To oppose these powerful influences the arsenal of orthodoxy contains no weapons save those which it has been able to manufacture from such evidences of moral and physical evil, fraud, deceit, and imposture, as the phenomena of Spiritualism have furnished. The Bible contains many inspired denunciations against witchcraft, necromancy, and consulting with familiar spirits; but, on the other hand, it makes mention of numerous interviews between the men of its time and the inhabitants of the heavenly world, and, on the supposition that the dead return to hold again communication with their friends on earth, it becomes rather difficult to distinguish to which class of these manifestations the phenomena of Spiritualism belong. Spiritualists themselves, of course, boldly assert that one is included as much as the other, and challenge their opposers to disprove their claim.
Rev. T. De Witt Talmage, the eminent Brooklyn divine, delivered recently a sermon against Spiritualism, in the Brooklyn Tabernacle, a step to which he was impelled mainly by the charge that he was himself a Spiritualist, and partly, perhaps, from a sense of what the times demanded of him. Orthodoxy can furnish from its ranks no stronger champion of its principles, or more powerful adversary to oppose its enemies, yet the replies called forth by his discourse indicate that he seriously compromised himself in the eyes of many. His denunciations were eloquent and scathing, but had they been accompanied by the “sword of the Spirit,” how much sharper and more effective would they have been! With this terrible weapon, “sharper than any two-edged sword,” which the words of Eccl. 9:5 and similar texts would have placed in his hands, he might have pierced the monster through at a blow, stripped from it its attractive covering, and exposed before his audience and the world the hoofs and horns indicative of its infernal origin. But, alas! he was compelled to discard this all-powerful weapon, because he well knew that in making a thrust with it at Spiritualism he would run his own orthodoxy through, as well as that of his hearers.
Of course the Spiritualists were not slow in replying to Dr. Talmage’s attack, being so well aware of the fatal weakness to which his orthodox views exposed him. As a sample of these replies, we cite the following from the well-known writer, “Eleanor Kirk,” which doubtless voices the sentiments of a large number of those who listened to the doctor’s discourse:—
When the Rev. Dr. Talmage remarked last Sunday that “Spiritualism was an unclean, adulterous, and abominable doctrine, and the sooner it goes down to the hell from which it came up, the better for earth and heaven,” did he forget himself, or did he really mean to consign his chief henchman and deacon, Dr. Harrison A. Tucker, to the fires of sheol? Did he include all the members of his church and congregation who believe in this practical immortality of the soul? And just here I am reminded of a story: On one occasion the Rev. Henry Ward Beecher was approached by a mother whose daughter, a most intelligent young woman and a member of Plymouth Church, had become interested in the subject of Spiritualism. “You must labor with her, Mr. Beecher,” said the lady, “and if you find her obstinate, threaten to excommunicate her.” “That, madam, would be something of a joke,” said the minister with a twinkle of the eye, “because if the folk with Spiritualistic tendencies were to be cut off from Plymouth Church I shouldn’t have a corporal’s guard to preach to.” Now, this is the same with the Tabernacle people. I know of members of this church who go to hear Mr. Talmage in the morning and hold séances at their own or their friends’ houses in the evening. Many mediums are well supported by the Talmage people. The pastor may not be aware of this state of things, but he does know that Dr. H. A. Tucker is a clairvoyant and a trance-medium, and I believe I am correctly informed that this exceedingly wealthy man—made so by this trance traffic—has prescribed and still continues to prescribe for the Talmage family. Now, if this man belongs in hell, why is he allowed to occupy the best seat in the Tabernacle and manage the most important affairs of the church?
Handicapped by such considerations as are here stated, we fear the words of the eminent preacher, however sincere and earnest, must have fallen far short of the effect intended.
It is the confident prediction of Spiritualism that before the advent of the twentieth century, the harvest of the past forty years will be ripened and gathered, and it seems not unlikely that such will be the case. This harvest has been steadily growing in the decrease of faith in the Scriptures, the disintegration of definite religious belief, and the general decay of public morals. There can be no manner of doubt that the leaven of Spiritualism is to-day rapidly though silently permeating all classes of society. The transition from the orthodox stand-point of belief in the natural immortality of the soul, to the platform of avowed Spiritualism, is at the farthest but a step. How long will the masses, drawn by the powerful and subtle cords so enticingly thrown around them from the unseen world, be in taking it? This is a sad question, and one that time will settle.
L. A. S.