A "KNOCK-DOWN ARGUMENT."

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 24, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 17.

Read the full edition

A "KNOCK-DOWN ARGUMENT."

The editor of the Michigan Christian Herald, in a recent issue of that paper, undertakes to commune with himself and the public in reference to the "seventh-day question." The Herald has just finished publishing a lengthy series of articles on the subject, but they were from the pen of a correspondent. The editor was giving his attention to weightier matters. Now, however, apparently by way of giving the question a final "settler," he turns the full battery of his intellect upon it, and says:—
Is it a knock-down argument against the seventh-day Sabbath position that has just occurred to us? The position insists that the identical seventh-day observed in Jewish history must be observed perpetually, or the divine command is violated.
Well, what was the seventh day observed by the Jews in Bible times? Was it the seventh day of our week, as is assumed by those insisting upon the observance of our Saturday?
We have always understood that the divisions of time called weeks and months, under Jewish custom were indicated and measured by the moon. The week began with the new moon, or one of the other quarterly phases. The seventh day was the last day of the quarter. The months of the year, like the moons, were thirteen.
The Jewish seventh days would therefore be the seventh, the fourteenth, the twenty-first, and the twenty-eighth of the lunar month, which began with the new moon.
The editor of the Herald must indeed be a veritable prodigy of controversial prowess. Other men belabor their minds with long and painful study, and sit up nights to ransack "the Fathers," for arguments with which to refute the positions of those who advocate the seventh-day Sabbath; and then without very satisfactory success. He, however, can merely sit in his sanctum and have ideas casually "occur" to him which "knock down" all those positions like nine-pins! It would seem that he should have long ago come to the assistance of those who have been laboring so long and earnestly against "the seventh-day Sabbath position," and thus saved them many years of trouble and effort. Let us bestow a moment's glance at this formidable "argument."
"We have always understood," says the editor of the Herald, "that the divisions of time called weeks and months under Jewish custom were indicated and measured by the moon." Ah! that is just the trouble with the great majority of those who so confidently set out to overthrow the seventh-day Sabbath. Instead of going to the Scriptures for information, they proceed to build an argument on what they "have always understood," and in nine cases out of ten what they have always understood on this question is something altogether different from what the Scriptures teach. Certainly it is in this case. No one can there get any such idea as that "the week began with the new moon, or one of the other quarterly phases;" nor, for that matter, can it be drawn from any other reliable source of information. The Jewish month began with the new moon, but the Jewish week was and is an entirely independent arrangement, identical with the week instituted at creation. The Jewish month might have begun on any day of the Jewish week, though properly there is no such thing as "Jewish week," any more than there is a "Christian week" or an "infidel week." "The week," says the Encyclopedia Britannica, "is a period of seven days, having no reference whatever to the celestial motions—a circumstance to which it owes its unalterable uniformity."
Following out the argument founded on what the editor had "always supposed," the Herald continues:—
Our divisions of time into weeks and months are different. The seventh day of our week is only occasionally the seventh day of the lunar week. In the present week, for instance, the Jewish week would have had last Tuesday as its seventh day. Did our friends observe that as the commanded Sabbath? If not, they are observing other days as the Sabbath than the one which they claim that the Lord commanded. Out of this dilemma we see no way of escape but the one which leads to our own understanding of the divine law of the Sabbath; namely, that a seventh part of time in its seventh day shall be a Lord's day—the "Sabbath of the Lord thy God."
These are remarkable statements indeed, to come from one who has enjoyed the advantages which our free and enlightened country offers to those engaged in the pursuit of knowledge. We venture to say they were not made on the authority of any citizen of the Jewish race. Our divisions of time into months are different; our divisions of time into weeks are not different, but identical, as any school-boy doubtless knows. "The seventh day of our week is only occasionally the seventh day of the lunar week." A very safe statement indeed, since there is no such thing as a "lunar week," save in the Herald's imagination. But the following sentence brings us to the climax: "The Jewish week would have had last Tuesday as its seventh day," and therefore, he says, we should have observed that day as the Sabbath! Truly this is an assertion such as only a misguided devotee of the Sunday Sabbath could be supposed to make! Does not the editor know that the Jews have continued without interruption to observe the seventh day of their week as the Sabbath from the time of Moses till the present time, and that that seventh day is always identical with our Saturday? He talks as though the Jews either did not observe the seventh day of their week as the Sabbath, or else that they were observing different days of our week—as for instance the "last Tuesday" of which he speaks—as their Sabbath. Does he not know that it is because we observe Saturday, the seventh day of our week, that we are accused of keeping the "Jewish Sabbath"? We did not suppose any intelligent citizen of our country, especially an editor, could be so ignorant of the weekly practices of so conspicuous a portion of our community as are the Jews. He would better improve his next opportunity to attend worship in some Jewish synagogue, and ascertain a few facts relative to the subject of which he assumes to speak.
The truth of the matter is, that all classes of people in all civilized nations, whether Jews, Christians, atheists, or any others, begin and end the week on precisely the same day. The Jews, from the earliest period of their existence as a nation, have observed this period precisely as they do now; and Christian nations, by adopting the same order of numbering the days, acknowledge the correctness of Jewish reckoning. If therefore the seventh day of the Jewish week had recently, as stated, fallen on Tuesday, the Christian world, including the editor of the Herald, would have been bound to observe Wednesday as their Sabbath, since all Christendom acknowledges that the first day of the week immediately follows the seventh. The dilemma here is certainly not one which any observer of the seventh day need trouble himself to escape from.
The reaction of hurling this formidable argument against the seventh-day Sabbath is so much stronger than its projectile force, that quite probably it is in one sense a "knock-down argument." But it does not knock down anything in front of it. Amid the fallen ruins of rival man-made institutions, and the shattered weapons directed by puny man through all the ages against it, the institution of the seventh-day Sabbath still towers erect upon the foundation laid by the Almighty at the beginning of time; and thus it will continue until its close.
We presume that ere this the editor of the Herald, if he has given the subject a second thought, has been able to answer his own question with a very subdued and humble negative. L. A. S.