CHANGING FAST-DAY

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 24, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 17.

Read the full edition

CHANGING FAST-DAY.

It seems not improbable that one of the next steps to be taken in the retrogressive journey Homeward of American Protestantism, will be a change in the observance of its customary annual Fast-day, such as will make it coincide with the great Fast-day of the Romish Church—Good Friday. Such a change was proposed at a recent Methodist Conference held in the East, and the proposition was received with favor by all present. The Boston Herald also favors the scheme, as the following editorial clipped from its columns shows:—
The suggestion made at the Methodist conference on Fast-day, and approved of by the vote of the clergymen there present, that the governor of Massachusetts be petitioned to hereafter appoint Good Friday as Fast-day, instead of the traditional Thursday, shows a marked decline in religious prejudice, and an equally satisfactory advance in religious good sense. . . .
As a day of fasting and prayer, the traditional Thursday in April is a pretense which has only the compulsory statutes of the State to justify its existence. It is a holiday, but not a holy day; and if a thing may be said to part with something that it can hardly be claimed to possess, it may be said of Fast-day that it is each year losing whatever slight remnant of sacredness once attached to it. This is due to the fact that the anniversary is not identified with any distinct religious event, and its failure to hold the respect of our people indicates the utter impracticability of having sacred days made to order by the decree of the government.
Now, while Good Friday has never been in this State officially recognized, it is, and has been for years, observed by large numbers of our people, both Protestants and Catholics, with a consideration which throws official Fast-day into contempt. . . . Our Puritan forefathers, in their resolute reaction against the old church, believed it necessary to ignore many of its essentially popular and, as we now look upon them, commendable characteristics. But human nature is much the same all the world over, and we have by degrees slid back to the old and time-honored customs. Our Puritan predecessors would not recognize Christmas, and had their festival on Thanksgiving Day. While we still retain the feast that they created, Christmas has reasserted its claims upon the hearts of men. So, too, with Easter. Deacons and good church-members of half a century ago would be scandalized if they could visit Boston of the present time, and witness the recognition of the annual celebration of the resurrection which is given by practically all of the Protestant churches.
With all that the Herald here says as to the disregard of the present customary Fast-day, the attention paid to the Catholic festivals, and the wide departure of Protestantism from its position of fifty years ago, we can fully agree; but that any good will come from the proposed change, we fail to see. There can be no good reason given for such a change. In the first place, “Good Friday” is no more associated with any religious event than is any other day of the week, since the day of the month on which Christ was crucified, like the Fourth of July, or Christmas, or any other particular day, will fall on a different day of the week in each successive year, and continue to do so through the whole seven days; and in the second place, it ought to be evident to any one that a community which has so far lost its spirituality as to show no regard to Fast-day as now appointed, cannot be made to properly regard the institution by changing it to a different day. A great many specious arguments doubtless can be gotten up for making the change proposed, but it is our opinion that the only perceptible result, should it be made, would be to advance Protestantism one step further in its retrogression toward popery, by bringing the fast and festival days of the two churches more nearly into line, and thus strengthening the bond of union which has for a long time been growing between them.
L. A. S.