AdventAI

CHAUTAUQUA LETTERS.

By C. C. Lewis

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 32., August 7, 1888

Chautauqua, N. Y., July 22, 1888.

EDITOR REVIEW AND HERALD.

DEAR BROTHER: There are so many good things to be seen and heard at Chautauqua—good, too, as viewed from our stand-point—that I cannot be content to keep them all to myself, and must therefore ask you to permit me, in a few familiar letters, to place some of them before the readers of the REVIEW.

Among the seventeen departments which constitute that wonderful institution known as the “Chautauqua Summer University,” none has interested me so much as the “school of the English Bible.” Although the special work for which I came here has prevented my attendance upon the classes of this school, yet from the public lectures given by the teachers, but more especially from information from Bro. Starbuck, principal of our Conference school at Portland, Oregon, who has taken the courses of instruction in three of the eleven regular classes, I have been able to form a good idea of the work done.

The fact of such a school is, in itself, significant. This is the first year of its existence. It was started as an experiment; and the result is watched by the managers with much interest. Was there sufficient interest in Bible study to warrant the bringing together of half-a-dozen of the most eminent Bible teachers of the United States and Canada to act as instructors? Would men and women spend their time, and pay their money, for the sake of studying the English Bible? Could enough be accomplished in three weeks to warrant the effort? These were questions the answers to which could be obtained only by trial. The result is a further illustration of the great increase of interest in Bible study leading to its introduction into the colleges of the United States, as mentioned in the editorial notes of the REVIEW of July 17. The classes are well filled, and the interest is intense. Although it will probably not be a financial success this year, yet the school will doubtless become a permanent institution at Chautauqua.

It is interesting to note the methods here employed in teaching the Bible, because the teachers are from different sections of the country,—East, West, North, and South,—and represent the best teaching power in Bible work. It may be interesting to know the names of the teachers and the colleges from which they come, as well as the denominations to which they belong; especially so, as I shall from time to time refer to their teachings. They are all “D. D.’s” or “Ph. D.’s,” and their names are as follows: Geo. S. Burroughs (Congregationalist), Amherst College, Amherst, Mass.; W. R. Harper (Baptist), Yale University, New Haven, Conn.; J. F. McCurdy (Presbyterian), Toronto University, Toronto, Canada; J. A. Broadus (Baptist), South. Bapt. Theo. Seminary, Louisville, Ky.; M. D. Buell (Methodist), Boston University; and R. F. Weidner (Lutheran), Augustana Theo. Seminary, Rock Island, Ill.

In the class-room they bring their pupils directly to the Bible, using as the basis of their work the revised version. They hold that it is the work of the teacher, as it is also that of the commentator, to throw upon the text whatever light may be obtained from history, from ancient manners and customs, from the original languages, or from whatever other sources. He should aid the student in correctly understanding the meaning of the text, but should leave him to draw his own conclusions; and the teacher should not come between his pupil and the sacred word, as the pupil applies its teachings to his own conscience, and in forming his own religious beliefs. They aim to carry this principle into the class-room, and it must be said that they are very successful,—there being in the class a spirit of liberty to ask questions, to offer opinions, but not of controversy or debate.

They recommend the use of a Bible dictionary and a concordance, in the study of the Bible, but notp. 506 of commentaries, until one has thoroughly studied the text, and has formed his own conclusions. This feature of their work has especially pleased me. Dr. Buell upon one occasion even used language like the following: “It is a sin; it is worse than a sin,—if anything could be worse—to consult commentaries before one has made an effort to understand the text for himself.” They discourage the purchasing of a commentary upon the entire Bible (written by one author), but recommend one to get a small work on a single book when he is studying that book, and to choose from different authors those who have made a specialty of certain books. As a commentary on the entire Bible, I have twice heard that of “Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown” highly recommended.

An amusing incident happened in one of the classes,—I think Dr. Burroughs was the teacher,—which well illustrates the general feeling toward the use of commentaries. The class had finished the study of one of the minor prophets, and the teacher, according to his custom, was calling upon the pupils for their conclusions concerning the book. Several had spoken, showing unmistakable evidence of having obtained their views from books. Finally he called upon Bro. Starbuck, who replied that as he never had consulted commentaries in his life, he felt backward about giving his views.

The teacher laughed as he remarked, “Well, I guess you are better off, after all.” He then insisted upon hearing the conclusions of one who had not followed commentaries, and when given, he agreed in them all. More anon.

C. C. LEWIS.