AdventAI

THE BLAIR AMENDMENT IMPRACTICABLE.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 7., February 12, 1889

The definition given by Senator Blair to the term, “principles of the Christian religion,” as used by him in his proposed Constitutional Amendment, and noticed in last week’s REVIEW, affords an opportunity of subjecting the working of his amendment to a practical test, by the aid of a few facts, which are too well known to be disputed. We give again the paragraph in the Senator’s letter to the New York Mail and Express in which this definition is contained:—

There is a great deal of old-style depravity in the alleged apprehension that our liberties will be endangered by informing the otherwise heathen Anglo-Saxon child of the contents of the Ten Commandments, the Sermon on the Mount, and even teaching him to recite the Golden Rule.

This was written by Senator Blair as a direct comment upon his pending amendment, and was therefore intended as a definition, in part, at least, of those words of the amendment to which it evidently refers; namely, “the principles of the Christian religion.” To teach these “principles,” then, in our public schools, with the construction put upon the term by Mr. Blair, will be to give the pupils of those schools a knowledge of the ten commandments and the sermon on the mount. Let us imagine a teacher in one of our public schools attempting to carry out the instructions of the amendment in this manner.

Suppose, for instance, the teacher be a Methodist. He will give the pupils under his charge such a knowledge of the ten commandments as is in accordance with the faith of the Methodist Church. Among the latter, there will be, not unlikely, one or more children of Catholics, or of Jews, or Sabbatarians, or antinomians, or possibly atheists. Following the line of belief adhered to by the Methodist faith, the teacher instructs all these that the ten commandments, as given in Ex. 20:3-17, constitute God’s moral law, which is unchangeable, and binding upon all. Result: The Roman Catholic parent raises an objection on the ground that the ten commandments have been changed by the church,—the second having been dropped and the tenth divided,—and he does not wish his children taught otherwise; the Jew and the Sabbatarian object on the ground that the fourth commandment makes it binding upon all to keep Saturday as the Sabbath, and do not wish their children taught that Sunday is the Sabbath, or that the commandment does not refer to a particular day of the week; the antinomian believes that the ten commandments have been abolished, and hence does not wish his children taught that they are yet binding; and the infidel of course objects in toto to any teaching, in school or out, of a distinctly religious character. How long could that teacher proceed in his new task of expounding the “principles of the Christian religion”? How long would it be before a howl of dissatisfaction and indignation would be heard throughout the land? What would be the effect upon the public schools themselves? and what upon the community? None of these questions are difficult to answer.

And thus it would be, were the teacher of any other faith than the Methodist, so long as the children of these various classes were represented in the public schools. To carry out the provisions of this amendment therefore, would result in withdrawing from the public schools the children of parents of the Catholic, Jewish, Sabbatarian, antinomian, and infidel faiths, and the exclusion from the same of all teachers belonging to these classes,—a result which Mr. Blair probably did not contemplate, though the sequence seems too plain for any person of intelligence to have overlooked. And if so plain and unequivocal a document as the ten commandments cannot be understood alike by the leading denominations of Christendom, what difficulties will they not encounter when they come to deal with the sermon on the mount? Such an experiment, it is needless to say, will never be successful in this country. The Sabbatarians, being few in numbers, might be ignored by the more numerous representatives of other faiths, and probably would be; the antinomians and Jews might share a similar fate, though the supposition is not very probable; but the Catholics, the largest denomination in the land, would certainly have equal representation with the rest.

Senator Blair, therefore, by giving this elucidation of the intent of his proposed Constitutional Amendment, simply helps to demonstrate its utter impracticability on any consistent basis. For, as the Senator very naturally thought, a knowledge of the “principles of the Christian religion” must certainly include a knowledge of the moral law; yet no such knowledge can be taught in the public school without meeting at once the insuperable objection already noticed. How, then, do those who are working so hard for the Blair Amendment propose to meet this difficulty? Will they attempt to have the principles of the Christian religion taught without reference to the law of God? Such a thing cannot be done. Clearly, there is a dilemma in the path of this amendment; and it is strange that its supporters do not see it. But zeal in behalf of National Reform is always unaccountably blind. It can neither discern the dilemmas lying near at hand, nor the stupendous catastrophe looming up at the termination of its course. L. A. S.