A BROTHER writes asking if the petition we are circulating, that Congress enact no law for Sunday observance, is not too restrictive; and whether it would not be well for the nation to enact a Sunday law for the benefit of the working classes; and further, whether an exemption from such Sunday law is not all that we could consistently require.
The plea for the workingman is, of course, a very specious one; and it is being worked for its utmost value by the friends of Sunday legislation. Thousands, influenced by their sympathy for the workingman, and seeing in the movement nothing but an effort for his relief, will range themselves on the side of those who are seeking for a Sunday law.
We have nothing to say against sympathy for the workingmen. Their cause, as against the oppression of capital and monopolies, is worthy of all aid. But we do not imagine they will ever be benefited five cents' worth by any additional Sunday legislation that may be secured. Do not all have exemption from Sunday labor now, if they choose to take it? Can any man be compelled to labor on Sunday? Have not, then, the workingmen this matter in their own hands, if they choose to assert their privileges?
But the animus of this movement is revealed in a remark by Joseph Cook, that “the privilege of rest for one, is a law of rest for all.” Just as though one could not rest unless there was a law compelling everybody else to rest also. So it appears that the design is not any more to secure rest to those who may desire it, than to compel others to rest on that day, who may not desire it; and with such an element, no exemption clause would be compatible.
Secondly, no legislation in behalf of Sunday observance can be anything else but religious legislation; for Sunday is a religious institution. To this element alone, it owes its prominence and recognition. Without this, no claim would ever have been set up in its behalf. But any government goes beyond its legitimate province when it legislates in regard to institutions or questions which are of a purely religious nature.
For these reasons it seems to us clear that government has no right, disguise it as it may, to legislate in any manner in behalf of Sunday rest. Hence we say, Let Congress pass no law for the Sunday, or so-called Lord’s day.