With much interest I read the article in a late number of the REVIEW on the subject of the removal of the papal chair from Rome. The statements in that article are well made. It is impossible to say to what extent the facts of history might be compelled to give way in case of emergency; the papacy has always been fruitful of expedients, and the times have been when the infallibility of to-day has found it convenient to correct the infallibility of the past. But one thing is certain: the popedom cannot legally exist out of Rome.
The primacy was conferred on the bishop of Rome, and on that of no other city. The only chance for evasion would seem to be this: the pope would be confessed as bishop of Rome still, but claim to be exiled from his see by force. This of course would be only a pretense, just as it is but a silly pretense that the pope has been a prisoner in the Vatican since the organization of the kingdom of Italy. He is and has been free to go and come at his pleasure, but he has refused to go, in order to impose upon the credulity of his subjects. If he were away from Rome, it would be possible for him to assume the title of king of Rome also; which he dare not do at Rome. But that would probably cause a rupture between the kingdom of Italy and the power that would give him refuge under that usurped title.
There is an important fact to be considered in connection with the location of the papacy,—a fact in direct contradiction of Catholic history, or of history as falsified by the Catholic Church. That fact is this: The primacy was not conferred by reason of any supposed or imaginary succession from St. Peter. Such an idea was never entertained by the council that established the primacy. In the organization of the Catholic Church by Constantine, the bishops were given dignity and authority according to the importance of the cities over which they were severally set. Of course the primacy was given to Rome because it was the imperial city, and for no other reason. This was decided by the Council of Nice, A. D. 325, when Constantine was at the height of his glory. It was confirmed by the Council of Chalcedon, A. D. 451, and the royal commissioners whom Marcian deputed to attend that council, though the bishop of Rome, Leo the Great, was rebuked in the action of that council for his ambition and arrogance; yet the primacy was confirmed to that see. Again it was strongly confirmed by Justinian, Emperor of the East, in his letter to Pope John II., A. D. 533, and yet again by Phocas, also emperor of the East, early in the seventh century.
The fact that the primacy was conferred by reason of the dignity of the city, and not by reason of any supposed apostolic succession, is confirmed by the action of the bishops of Constantinople, who continued to make efforts to have the primacy transferred to them, or at least to have the see of Constantinople raised to equal dignity with that of Rome, because Constantinople became the imperial city. Had the primacy been conferred upon the bishop of Rome because of the succession from Peter, as the Catholic Church now falsely claims, the bishop of Constantinople could have had no possible ground for his claim. But his claim was plausible, and might have been granted, had it not been for the exigencies of the Eastern emperors, who were almost compelled by circumstances to secure the influence of the West by favoring Rome in its primacy.
In connection with this point, there is another of equal interest, because it throws light upon the claim of that church that the bishops of Rome were men of great consistency and integrity; that they maintained the orthodox faith without wavering, through all the vicissitudes and changes of those stormy times. As for the integrity of the popes of Rome, there has probably been no class of men of prominence in all history, whose characters will not bear favorable comparison with those of the popes. The following comments on the lives of the popes are no exaggeration of facts. They are from Robinson’s “Ecclesiastical Researches,” page 160, and will refer as well to almost any period as to the centuries of which he was speaking:—
There were, in this period of three hundred years, about fifty bishops of Rome, who may be divided into three classes; the first saints, the second sinners, the third neutrals. The church has thought fit to canonize about twenty; to give up others as reprobates; and to record of the third sort nothing more than that they were born of some parents, and lived in some places, and died, in due order of succession, bishops of Rome. Of the sinners, it may truly be affirmed that they were sinners of size; for it would be difficult to mention a crime which they did not commit. To obtain the papal dignity by bribery, and to lose it by being poisoned to make room for a successor; to be so wicked, and in a wicked community, as to be distinguished for multiplicity or enormity of criminal actions, are the articles that compose the lives of these very bad men.
Now what about their reputation for consistency and integrity? The Council of Nice adopted the creed of Athanasius, and condemned the faith of Arius. Had Constantine favored Arius, and had the council decided in favor of Arius, the doctrine of the trinity would have been a heresy through all succeeding centuries. We know that the opinions of the emperors often caused an entire change in the faith of the church; the opinion of Justinian caused John II. to accept that as truly orthodox, which Hormisdas, his predecessor in the papal chair, had condemned as heretical. Speaking of such changes in the faith of the church, Theodoret said it was no wonder, since they had no other rule of faith but the will of the emperor.
Constantine himself, after he professed Christianity, denied the creed of Nice, and adopted the faith of the Arians; but the bishop of Rome adhered to the faith of that council. The historian Gieseler says that even Theodoric, the Arian king of Italy, admired the steadfastness of the Roman bishops, which was in strong contrast with the vacillations of the Eastern bishops. No matter how many other bishops seceded, nor what was the opinion of the emperors, the bishops of Rome were constantly true to the doctrine of the trinity. Indeed, such was their devotion to that doctrine, that for centuries it was regarded as a sufficient test of orthodoxy. Why was this so? Why was it that the Roman see, no matter who was the incumbent, no matter what was his faith in other respects, was ever set in defense of the creed of Athanasius?
We need not go far to find the sufficient reason. As Athanasius and Arius were the two conspicuous men before the Council of Nice, the question of the unity or the trinity of the Godhead was the exciting question before the council. The council adopted the doctrine of the trinity; and thenceforth, to swerve from the Athanasian creed was to discredit the Council of Nice. But the primacy of Rome rested entirely on the decision of the Council of Nice; therefore to discredit that council was to strike at the foundation of the Roman primacy. Never was found a Roman bishop who was so unmindful of the dignity of his see as to permit a breath of reproach to be breathed against the Council of Nice. This is the great controlling reason why the church and subsequent councils were bound to conform to the canons and confession of that first general council under Constantine. Other councils were larger in numbers, and the bishops were equal in ability and dignity to those assembled at Nice, and they might contradict each other in direct terms, and the contradictions were lightly passed over, but there were the most persistent efforts put forth to keep the Council of Nice as the standard of orthodoxy for all time.
It is this that makes the Catholic Church emphatically the Church of Rome. The seat of dragonic power was Rome, and this seat was given to the papal beast; and it could not be transferred to any other city, unless, as before said, it were removed temporarily, under the pretense of the bishop of Rome being exiled. But that pretense would not receive any credit among the nations, unless the pope were restrained in the exercise of his legitimate power over the spiritual affairs of the church. But the kings of Italy have shown no disposition to interfere with him in that respect. To receive respect as the pope, he must remain at Rome.
J. H. W.