Spiritualist Communication on Catholic Prayers for the Dead
In a recent number of the Banner of Light (Spiritualist organ) there was printed a spiritualistic communication touching the Catholic custom of offering prayers for the dead. In the course of the revelation appears the following:— The Catholic Church recognizes a great truth, and a great psychological law, in the acknowledgment that souls in purgatory, or in a state of unhappiness, may be assisted by the prayers of their mortal friends. Now it strikes us that there is considerable difference between the Catholic conception of purgatory and a mere “state of unhappiness.” Purgatory is an abode of torment, a place where the souls which miss an immediate entrance into heaven experience the fierce pains of sulphurous fires, from which there is no escape, except by the avenue of the prayers and alms of the living, until the flames have fully accomplished their intended work. But when the soul is released from purgatory, it goes at once to heaven. In both these particulars, therefore, and especially the latter, the Catholic and Spiritualist conceptions of purgatory, or an intermediate state of unhappiness, widely differ, and it is not easy to see how Spiritualism, without contradicting itself, can say what it does in the paragraph quoted above. Spiritualism affirms that there is no such thing as the Catholic purgatory. How, then, can the Catholic Church recognize a great truth in trying to pray souls out of a place of torment which is wholly imaginary? The spiritual source whence this bit of information was derived must have been rather partial to Catholicism, or it would have been stated that the amount of error recognized in the Catholic doctrine and practices relative to purgatory far overshadowed what little truth it might seem to contain.