AdventAI

INCONSISTENCY OF THE BLAIR “SUNDAY REST” BILL.

By J. O. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 5., January 29, 1889

WASHINGTON CITY was invited to hear Rev. Wilbur F. Crafts speak on the necessity of legislation in behalf of Sunday. He occupied the desk of three of the leading churches in the city last Sunday, Jan. 20. In the morning he spoke in the First Presbyterian church (Dr. Sunderland’s), and treated the question which evidently lies very near his heart—the American Sabbath. He opened by stating that the present agitation of the subject was not brought about by the churches, but by the clamor of the workingmen everywhere, in behalf of a weekly rest-day. The popular demand for a Sunday rest he thought to be the only defensible ground for Sabbath observance.

In order to allay any apprehensions which might arise, he stated that the bill now before Congress, known as the “Sunday rest” bill, only contemplated giving to the District of Columbia and the Territories directly under the jurisdiction of Congress, the same kind of law that every State but one in the Union already enjoyed. But singularly enough, instead of showing the necessity for such a law in these Territories, and in Washington City particularly, he said that in the latter place a very quiet Sunday was already enjoyed; but the trouble was in New York, and in some Western cities, where saloons were kept open, and the Sunday newspapers were published. The query that naturally arose in my mind was, how a Sunday law enacted by Congress, substantially the same as that enjoyed by all the States, where so much Sunday desecration is indulged, could help in the Territories where, without such a law at all, the people already enjoy quiet Sundays. But before he was through with his speech, it was evident that his first statement was only a mask to cover up the real design of the bill.

The burden of his appeal was to the working class. He would demand a law against hiring work of any kind done on Sunday; as though he were the great friend of the workingman. In his appeals for sympathy for this class, in their oppressed condition, he cited cases where men had reported to him that they had had only three Sundays’ rest in a year, in which to enjoy the society of their families. He succeeded very well in creating sympathy on this point; but when he came to speak of Sunday excursions, he virtually denied all he had said about the laboring men’s lack of time for rest. He said that some pleaded for Sunday excursions, because that day was the only one on which the laboring classes could really find time for such recreation—all the rest of the week being absorbed in their efforts to secure a livelihood for their families. He met this by saying that such reasons were not valid, from the fact that the laboring men of this country averaged three weeks apiece each year in strikes, besides Saturday half-holidays, Christmas, Fourth of July, etc., on which they might go with their families on excursions. But notwithstanding this, the laboring man greatly needs Sunday rest, because he has no time to be with his family!

This is a sample of his reasoning (?) all along till the real point was reached. He finally thought that the whole thing should rest on the basis of the fourth commandment, and men should be educated to believe that precept binding as a religious duty. But how was this to be done? Simply by urging Congress to legislate on the matter, and oblige all to observe Sunday strictly. All should be made to see that Sunday is not a human, but a divine, ordinance, yet the only proper way to do this is by human legislation. Works of necessity should be exempted, “but,” said Mr. Crafts, “all do not understand alike just what constitutes such works.” He then cited, as an illustration, the case of a New England barber who was arrested for shaving a man on Sunday. The Justice before whom his case was called, fined him for the act; but when his case was appealed, and came before another Justice, that one dismissed the case on the ground of his having done a work of necessity. This was enough to show that while such cases are left to be decided by different tribunals, they will not all be treated alike. It is therefore necessary, the speaker thought, for the laws of the country to specify, in every case, just what are, and what are not, works of necessity. In other words, Congress should descend in its legislation to define even what part of the house-wife’s work shall be considered necessary to do on Sunday, that she may be forbidden to do more than the specified amount on that day. What a pass will this be for a great nation to arrive at, when grave legislators shall be called to step down from their official dignity to discuss in Congress what part of a woman’s household duties are really necessary to be done on Sunday!

This is not overdrawing the matter in the least; for the Reverend Doctor gave as one reason why Congress should pass such a Sunday law, that servant girls were now obliged to do more than necessary work on that day. Well, well, has it come to this, that the people of this nation have become so imbecile that they are not able to longer exercise their judgment in matters of conscience, and must therefore have legislation on the minutest points of religious duty, and be held amenable to the civil laws, if they overstep the prescribed bounds? That would be a church and state combination with a vengeance; that would be a government standing in the place of God to its subjects; that would be the laws of the nation superseding the Bible and the laws of God.

These people mean to force their proposed measures, too. Notwithstanding Mr. Crafts said at first that the only thing demanded by them was just such a Sunday law as is now in force in all the States except one, when he was through speaking, Dr. Sunderland arose, and told the audience that he hoped soon to present before them the “Sunday rest” petition for their approval. “But,” said he, “there is one clause in it I do not indorse, and do not like to bring before you. That is the clause exempting seventh-day keepers, such as Jews and Seventh-day Baptists.” He was here interrupted by Mr. Crafts with the remark that all their petition-heads were now being printed without that clause. “Good,” said Dr. Sunderland, as his voice changed into that tone one could well imagine an inquisitor of the Dark Ages might assume, “we want but one Sabbath in this country; we don’t want any Judaizing here. The Bible itself has been corrupted for the last eighteen hundred years by Judaizing translators, which has permitted this state of things. This eternal Judaizing, Judaizing, JUDAIZING, has been going on long enough. It is time we were getting into the Christian dispensation.”

The boldness of this statement was startling enough to me; for I did not suppose the Sunday agitators had yet arrived at that point where they would openly avow their intolerance. But they have come now where they think their success is fully insured, and where they are warranted in pouring out Jesuitical hatred against all dissenters. Our brethren everywhere may be assured that the promoters of the Sunday-rest bill will now stop short of nothing that can lend strength to their cause. They will appeal to the natural desire of the working class for less work and more ease, and at the same time they will excite prejudice against all who cling to the Bible, by denouncing them as Judaizers. “Here is the patience of the saints.” The battle-cry is sounding all along the line. The forces of the enemy are marshalling, and now is the time for every lover of truth to gird on his armor for the affray. Give all to the work. Hold nothing in reserve. Let the means in our possession be set apart to the work now before us, which is so soon to close in triumph on the side of truth.

J. O. C.

Washington, D. C. Jan. 21, 1889.