AdventAI

THE FAILURE OF CHRISTIAN MISSIONS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 44., November 6, 1888

In a paper read before the last Church Congress of England, Canon Taylor astonished his associates by expressing grave doubts whether the results of Christian missionary enterprise were sufficient to justify the prodigious efforts expended upon it. Now he sums up in the Fortnightly Review the facts brought out in the stormy controversy which arose over his paper, and reaches the positive conclusion that the attempt to convert the world to Christianity by the overthrow of other religions has been a total failure. “The Great Missionary Failure” is the title of his article.

Leaving out Thibet, Borneo, and other regions of which the population is unknown, the most recent estimates make the non-Christian population of Asia and Africa upward of 920,000,000, of which the natural increase by the excess of births over deaths must be more than 11,000,000 annually. Dr. Maclear, who is the principal of a training college for missionaries, and “perhaps the greatest living authority on the subject,” estimates the annual increase of native Christians due to missionary efforts, at 60,000. At that rate, then, it would take the missionary societies 183 years to overtake even this natural increase of the non-Christian population in a single year. “In spite of our advance, instead of overtaking the work, the work is overtaking us. It is like the tortoise racing with a railway train; the longer the race continues, the farther the tortoise is left behind.” Something like $10,000,000 is spent annually on Protestant missions, and there are about 6,000 American and European missionaries, with about 30,000 native agents; and yet there are to-day upward of 10,000,000 more heathen and Mohammedans than there were a year ago.

The greatest of the missionary societies is the Church Missionary Society, with an expenditure of about $1,500,000 yearly; and yet the annual increase of native Christians due to its labors is not more than 4,000, at the outside. Therefore it would take the society 2,750 years to convert as many Moslems and heathen as are gained by birth in a single year. If the population remained stationary, and all the converts steadfast, it would take more than 330,000 years to convert the world, or nearly a million years, if the relapses are taken into account.

The annual increase of native Protestant Christians in India, due to the labors of thirty-five societies, is reported to be 19,311, and of Roman Catholics 21,272, or 40,583 in all. At this rate, it would take sixty-four years to come up to the increase of the non-Christian population of India in a single year. In China the situation is even more disheartening. The number of adults baptized by the Church Missionary Society last year was only 167 out of a population of 382,000,000, with an annual gain of at least 4,580,000 by the excess of births over deaths. At this rate, the society would have to work 27,000 years to come up to the natural increase of one year, and more than 1,680,000 years to convert China, even if the population remained stationary. The expenditure, too, is enormous; in any other department of effort, it would be called wasteful. In China, the cost of the 167 conversions was about $75,000. In Ceylon, last year, 424 agents of this society spent $55,000 in making 190 adult converts out of a population of nearly 3,000,000; and yet the relapses were more numerous than the conversions, for there was an actual decrease of 143 in the number of native Christian adherents. In Northern India it costs $170,000 and the labors of 715 agents to make 173 converts. Many of the converts are paid, thirty-five of the ninety-four communicants in Hong Kong being paid native agents, and also seven of the ten in Egypt and Arabia. In the missions to Egypt, Persia, Palestine, and Arabia, the society employs 119 agents, and has expended over $117,000 in the last two years, with absolutely no conversions. All the efforts of the Protestant missionaries against Mohammedanism have been utterly unavailing. Islam stands out firmly against Christianity, and is far more successful than it in propagandism.

Canon Taylor furnishes us with all of those statistics, and the method of treating the subject which we have pursued is wholly borrowed from him. Having thus shown the quantity, he then proceeds to consider the quality of the converts, with results not less discouraging. He quotes the English Vice-Consul in the Cameroons as reporting that after twenty years of labor the missionaries in many important districts can scarcely number twenty sincere converts; and in other parts of Africa the religion of the nominal Christians “is discredited by numbering among its adherents all the drunkards, liars, rogues, and unclean livers in the colony. In the oldest of our West African possessions, all the unrepentant Magdalens of the chief city are professing Christians, and the most notorious one in the place boasts that she ‘never missed going to church on a communion Sunday.’” After a quarrel in a nominally Christian village, three years ago, the victors proceeded to cook and eat the bodies of the slain. The Vice-Consul says that, with rare exceptions, the native African pastors, teachers, and catechists whom he has met are “more or less bad men.” A missionary reports the same.

The competition between Christian churches and the rivalry of the many missionary societies, of course, greatly hinder progress. Dr. Legge, a missionary for forty years among the Mohammedans, declares that “we shall fail to make converts so long as Christianity presents itself infected with the bitter internal animosities of Christian sects, and associated in the minds of the natives with the drunkenness, the prodigacy, and the gigantic social evil conspicuous among Christian nations.” There are 224 societies which work for converts. One missionary complains that one of his “inquirers” has been “deceived” and baptized by the missionary of another society. Another records that an inquirer, to whom he was paying five dollars a month, struck for higher pay, and ran off to a rival missionary. A third discovered that a hopeful inquirer of his had adopted inquiry as a paying business, and was going the round of the missions.

Now, these are facts gathered and presented, not by an unbeliever, but by a distinguished clergyman of the Church of England. Yet they constitute by far the most telling attack on the methods and results of missionary enterprise which has ever been made. Canon Taylor, too, is sustained by Bishop Steere, who has written to him to say that “all missionaries owe a debt of gratitude to those who call attention to the mistakes and failures of missions.”—N. Y. Sun.