AdventAI

Chinese Exclusion Bill and Religious Liberty Concerns

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 44., November 6, 1888

The Christian Statesman, organ of the National Reform Association, has no difficulty in seeing that the Chinese exclusion bill recently passed by Congress, is a glaring infringement upon personal liberty. It prints a communication from a correspondent, which starts out with, “Talk not of liberty! No more call our country the land of the free!” and continues with such expressions as “The Government has forgotten the Declaration of Independence,” “The United States is a despotism,” etc. It is not our purpose to question the truthfulness of these assertions; but we would merely ask why, if the United States has already become a despotic government toward a portion of its inhabitants, the Statesman and its coadjutors should wish to make it any more so by extending this despotism over other classes. If it objects to a law which affects the liberties of a foreign and alien class of residents, and that only their civil liberties, why should it favor a law which is aimed at the more sacred religious rights of an equally large and respectable portion of its native citizens? There is no more consistency in such a course than there would be in attempting to ride at the same time two horses going in opposite directions. Yet this is just the course the Statesman and its party are now taking, by working to secure a law which will compel all persons to observe strictly the Sunday Sabbath, albeit at the sacrifice of conscience and of one sixth of their time, under penalty of ostracism, disfranchisement, confiscation of property, imprisonment, and even death, for disobedience.