AdventAI

THE RICH MAN AND LAZARUS.

By L. R. Conradi

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 6., February 5, 1889

BY ELD. L. R. CONRADI.

(Continued.)

“FIGURATIVE, INSTRUCTIVE NARRATIVE.”

Zeller’s Bible dictionary judges correctly, when it places the parable of the rich man and Lazarus among the fictitious, instructive narratives of our Saviour. According to our careful investigation of the place where this event should occur, and the condition of it in the light of the Bible, it can only be such. That “the dead know not anything” must remain true; and if in Isaiah 14 and in Luke 16, the dead are represented as if they knew something, these cannot be actual, but fictitious, events. Had the persons in the realm of death life and knowledge of the past and future, they would thus talk and act. The representation is a true one; but the transaction is not real. These facts are still more confirmed when we investigate the whole transaction in Luke 16 somewhat more closely.

The Saviour here describes a rich man, who, while himself living in joy and faring sumptuously, overlooks the suffering and needy Lazarus at his gate. The dogs manifested more sympathy than the rich man, who does not give even a crumb which falls from his table. At death, however, a different picture of both is represented. The rich man finds himself in hades in torment, and from there he sees Lazarus in Abraham’s bosom. This gives rise to a conversation between him and Abraham, and he desires that this formerly despised Lazarus be sent to dip the tip of his fingers in the water, that his tongue may be cooled.

Now, is this narrative a real event? Has this conversation between Abraham and the rich man ever taken place? Can the righteous and the unjust see each other and converse together after death? Have the dead in the intermediate state, eyes, fingers, and tongues? Do all the righteous lie in Abraham’s bosom? Does the ungodly man in hell wish the salvation of his brethren on earth? and does he intercede for them? or is the whole a representation, as in Isaiah 14, freely sketched by the Saviour, according to a well-understood figure of speech, to heighten the impression, and to bring those for whom it was designed, sooner to understand and realize their own case? It is either one or the other. Either all is literally true,—a real event in the spirit-world, a real conversation between Abraham and the rich man,—or else unconscious dead persons, as Abraham, Lazarus, and the rich man, are here represented as living and acting, while in reality they are not. In case we believe that the conversation between the rich man and Abraham really took place, we must also admit the possibility that the wicked, in general, can speak with the righteous; yes, that they can blaspheme and slander, and that they can see each other! What a paradise would that be, were parents obliged to see their prodigal children for thousands of years in torment, and to hear their calls, prayers, and groanings! Yes, what a paradise, were the righteous to hear the prayers, howls, curses, lamentations, and groans of millions and millions of ungodly ones, until the resurrection! If such were really the case, none among the living need envy Abraham his place, and the righteous dead would have anything but peace. Such a paradise we must accept, if we consider the parable of Luke 16, as a literal, actual occurrence.

Luther makes this whole transaction a figurative one; but he lets it transpire in the conscience of the rich man at the hour of his death. He says:—

The other question, How does this conversation between Abraham and the rich man happen? Ans.—It certainly cannot be a real conversation, since the bodies of both are buried in the earth; just as little can the tongue be literal, concerning which the rich man laments in the heat, nor a literal finger or water, which he demands from Lazarus. Therefore, all this must take place in the conscience in this manner: when the conscience is troubled in the hour of death, then one realizes his unbelief, and sees for the first time the bosom of Abraham, and those that are in it; &c., the word of God, on which he should have believed, and has not done it. Consequently, he has the greatest torment and anguish, as though in hell, and finds no help and consolation. . . . Then such thoughts arise in the conscience, which would hold such conversation, if they could speak, as here the rich man holds with Abraham. . . . Finally he feels that it is said to him that there is a great gulf fixed between him and the believing ones, and that they could never come together. These are the thoughts of desperation, when the conscience feels that the word of God is forever denied him, and there is no further help for him. After this, the thoughts of his conscience wrestle, and desire earnestly that the living might know that it is thus in the hour of death, and they wish that some one would tell them. But this also remains unfulfilled; for he feels the answer in his conscience, that Moses and the prophets are sufficient; they should believe these, as he also should have done.—Luther’s Sämtliche Werke, Vol. 13, Sermon 39.

But how do modern commentators meet these difficulties? While they even seem indignant, if we, with Zeller, call the transaction a fictitious narrative, yet when they come to explain the parable, they themselves are obliged to admit that not all is to be taken as real. So, for example, we read in the German commentary of Dr. Nast of Cincinnati, editor of the German Methodist church organ: “That the seeing into paradise, the conversation between Abraham and the rich man, the dipping of the finger to cool the rich man’s tongue, etc., is not to be understood in a material sense, no one will dispute.” We certainly will not dispute it; we would only like to know how many, etc., there remain? Had this worthy commentator done as Luther did, and taken the whole, torment and all, as figurative, he would have stated the truth. If one part is to be figurative, and not literal, why not the whole?

In the explanation and use of this parable, many of the theologians entangle themselves in wonderful contradictions and absurdities. At first, they assert that man after death continues to exist as a disembodied being. But if any one calls this in question, and asserts that, according to the Bible, there is no consciousness without the body, they point immediately to Luke 16, as proof. One investigates this, and drops the remark that all three persons here mentioned have bodies. Abraham has a bosom, Lazarus a finger, and the rich man a tongue; but not a syllable is here mentioned about disembodied spirits; the word “spirit,” or “soul,” is not once named. The answer comes back: One must not think that they have bodies; it means just the opposite; the language is figurative. Just what they should prove only rests on their assumption, and whatever contradicts this must be figurative! In other words, at first, this parable is said to prove as true, the existence of disembodied, immaterial beings; then every particular of the parable which stands in contradiction to this, is represented as figurative, and of little significance, and then they boast of this so disfigured parable as a full proof of their assumption! Others may so treat the word of God if they choose; we will not take such responsibility.

If the word of God should teach that the dead know more than the living, instead of teachingp. 82 that they know not anything, then we should be compelled to take this parable throughout as literal, and as an actual event; but as such a view contradicts the word of God, and we have already an illustration of the same nature in Isaiah 14, we believe that the representation is true, but the event fictitious, and not real. In this latter case, not the event itself, but the moral, is the principal thing.

No more than in Isaiah 14 the dead were awakened at the death of the king of Babylon, and arose from their thrones and mockingly greeted him, is the rich man in torment, or does he talk with Abraham or see Lazarus. Worms are his bed, and worms cover him, and all rest until the day of resurrection. God’s word represents figuratively, as in Isaiah and Luke, the dead as acting and talking; but in Eccl. 9:6, and in many other places, it states literally that the dead know not anything, but sleep. The infidel may bring forth this apparent contradiction with triumph, as a support of his unbelief; orthodoxy may regard the Old Testament as of little importance because its teachings on the intermediate state do not harmonize with its heathen philosophy, and in the New Testament itself, mutilate and distort such cases as the one under consideration; but we, for our part, acknowledge the whole Bible as coming from God, and as the only rule of our faith, and we feel in duty bound to study and compare until all such apparent contradictions are solved, and the kernel found. With the help of God, we have now solved every contradiction. The evident design of the parable is not to impart instruction to us concerning the intermediate state, or concerning the continuance of disembodied spirits, or whether the unjust can converse with the righteous after death, and whether one is in torment and the other in bliss.

The real object and the moral will appear more manifest as we further investigate the parable and its connections. Four points are here to be observed: 1. The cause; 2. The direct reference; 3. The real meaning; 4. The moral for us to-day.

(Concluded next week).