What Does Paul Here Teach Is Done Away?
If there is any one portion of the writings of the apostle Paul, to which, more than another, the language of Peter (2 Peter 3:15, 16) is applicable, it would seem to be the 3d chapter of 2d Corinthians. Not that this chapter necessarily comes under the designation, “hard to be understood;” but it does seem to be one which certain classes appear more especially inclined to “wrest,” than they do the other scriptures.
No-law and no-Sabbath men, of every stripe and feather, flee to this chapter as if it offered them a secure intrenchment, and then, from its supposed impregnable parapets, with no little smell of powder, and much noise and smoke, they hurl forth their cannon balls, labeled, “Done Away” (verse 7), “Done Away” (verse 11), “Abolished” (verse 13), “Done Away in Christ” (verse 14), “Taken Away” (verse 16), and “Liberty” (verse 17).
But what is most surprising is that they direct these missiles against the Sabbath, which Paul scrupulously observed, and against the moral law, which he has elsewhere abundantly taught is fundamental to the gospel of Christ. Either, then, the apostle’s words in this chapter are perverted by this class of teachers, or he is shown to have contradicted himself.
Peter says that they who wrest Paul’s words, do so “to their own destruction.” So the case before us would not be so serious, were not the subject one which vitally affects the character of men in this world, and their eternal destiny in the world to come. For if, for instance, we teach men that they are not under obligation to keep a certain law, and then the keeping of that law proves to be essential to their salvation, the appalling results of such teaching can never be estimated, nor the loss ever measured which some may thereby be led to incur.
The question to be examined in the discussion of 2 Corinthians 3, is one in which is involved no less an issue than obedience or disobedience to the commandments of God. It is sought to be used, primarily, to prove that the seventh-day Sabbath has been “done away,” and is consequently no longer binding upon Christians. But the chapter says nothing specifically about the Sabbath, but only about something which is interpreted to mean the ten commandments, the only law enjoining the Sabbath; and hence to dispose of the Sabbath, some do not even hesitate to argue the abolition of all ten of the precepts which were engraven on stone.
If 2 Corinthians 3 refers to any one of the commandments of the decalogue, it refers to them all; and if one is abolished, all are. This consideration alone ought to deter any one from trying to use this chapter against the Sabbath; for it is utterly absurd to talk about abolishing ten commandments (nine of which must still continue, or all morality be abandoned), in order to get rid of one.
There is involved in the antinomian theory, that which appears to us to be not only transparently absurd, but positively untrue, and which we would like to have explained, if it can be done. For instance, we are told that what was written on the tables of stone has been abolished, and taken out of the way. But we find written on the stone, such commandments as these: “Thou shalt not kill. Thou shalt not commit adultery. Thou shalt not steal.” And are not men still under obligation to refrain from doing these things? Would not the commission of these acts be an offense against God, and disobedience to his laws?—Of course it would. Then this much that was written on the stones has not been abolished. But was there ever an instant when men were at liberty to do these things?—Certainly not. Then, in the name of reason, in what sense have they ever been abolished? Who can tell?
But we are told that these that remain were immediately re-enacted. Such a transaction would be an impossibility. As noticed above, there must not be an instant when some of these commandments at least were not binding upon men, or in other words, when the commission of the acts which they forbid would not be sin; but to abolish these and make known to the world their abolition, and then re-enact them, would necessitate a space of time when they would not be binding; and that, as already remarked, cannot for a moment be admitted. The only way to get by this point would be to assert that they were abolished and no man was informed thereof, and no one knew anything about it; and that in the same flash of an instant they were re-enacted, and no living being was informed of the fact, nor how nor why it was done; from which it would follow that the abolition and re-enactment were both performed in reference to these commandments, and yet the commandments themselves enjoyed a continuous and uninterrupted existence without the interval of the smallest fraction of time. Think what a farce would be attributed to the God of all wisdom by such a view. Dear antinomian friend, please do not charge the infinite God with a degree of folly which men, even in their finite transactions, would blush to own.
But even if we grant all this, another difficulty still remains; and that is, Why should the apostles, years afterward, writing for Christians in all coming time, take up and dilate upon this abolition, as it is claimed that Paul has done in Romans, Galatians, and particularly in 2 Corinthians 3, and yet say nothing about the re-enactment? Why say anything about it at all? If certain commandments maintained their claims upon men, constant and uniform,—claims just as binding now as before Christ came,—why should the apostles ever enter upon a dissertation upon their abolition, and then leave the matter there?
Suppose that at some session of the legislature of Michigan some member should be simple enough to introduce a bill something like this: “Be it enacted by the people of the State of Michigan, that the laws against theft be hereby abolished and re-enacted;” and suppose that for some unaccountable reason the legislature should tolerate such a farce, and pass the act; that would be doing just what some claim that God has done with reference to his law. But then suppose that six months afterward, some one should go through the State, proclaiming that the legislature had abolished the laws against theft. How soon he would be told that nothing of the kind had been done; that the action was only a farce, for the same vote that abolished the law re-enacted it; and that we are just as much under laws against stealing as we were before.
The same may be said of every portion of what were once the commandments of the decalogue, which are acknowledged in any form to be still binding. It is idle to say that such have been done away, for they have not, no matter how, when, nor in what form they existed before. If they continue, then they continue (pardon such a truism), and have not been done away.
But when the writers of the New Testament speak of anything as abolished and done away, we may be certain that it signifies that Christians are released from obligation to regard, follow, or obey that thing; and if it is the ten commandments, as they existed on the tables of stone, the issue must be squarely faced, that we are released from obligation to obey them. If the commandments, “Thou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not commit adultery,” and “Thou shalt not steal,” have been abolished, then the acts which the commandments forbid, may be committed without incurring any condemnation in the sight of Heaven. If there is any blind by-path, or cunning fox-hole out of this horrible conclusion, we have yet to see it pointed out.
But, some one may say, I do not mean that the principles of these commandments have ceased to exist; they still continue, and we are restrained from all those specific acts of transgression; but I mean that that economy which called for these commandments to be written on stone, has passed away, and we do not now keep the commandments because they were written on the tables of stone, and performed the office they did in the former dispensation.
Very well, that is altogether a different thing. But remember that with this view, from which there will be no dissent, 2 Corinthians 3 cannot be used to prove the abolition of the law itself. You cannot quote that chapter to prove that what was written and engraven on the stones was itself done away, but only that a certain relation which that writing sustained to other arrangements, has passed away, been abolished, etc., but that the writing itself still remains to occupy a different position under the gospel. Such is not the antinomian use of 2 Corinthians 3.
(To be continued.)