AdventAI

SUNDAY IN SCOTLAND.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 47., November 27, 1888

It is not strange that in Scotland, as in other countries, where the idea of the sanctity of Sunday as a continuation of the Sabbath of the fourth commandment has been persistently drilled into the minds of the people for generations, a fancied infraction of the holiness of the day should create no little excitement. Such it seems is the case in Lairg, a little town in Scotland; and such being the case, the following lecture read to them by the editor of the Daily Telegraph of London, in his issue of Sept. 21, 1888, is most refreshing. While the inhabitants of some by-places and interior towns may still be laboring under the impression that Sunday is a divine institution resting upon the authority of the fourth commandment of the decalogue, those who reside at the centers of intelligence, the foremost leaders of thought, and the editors of our most influential public journals have learned that such claims are wholly groundless and inadmissible. They well understand that the only Sabbath known to the Bible is the seventh day of the week, and that Sunday is without divine law or apostolic sanction; and they are not afraid to state to the public the truth on this point. The distinction between the Sabbath of the fourth commandment and Sunday, is clearly stated by the Telegraph; and the point that the latter is “not divine, not old, not universal,” and that “it cannot even claim to be British,” is well put. Though the editor of the Telegraph seems to have gone to the other extreme of supposing that there is no divinely-appointed day of rest in this dispensation, his remarks are nevertheless of value as calculated to dispel the heretofore popular illusion that the fourth commandment can be appealed to in behalf of Sunday, and that the first day of the week can by any means be switched into the place of the seventh. All such articles as these are preparing the way for the Sabbath reform in the British realm; and, as such, our readers will peruse it with interest:—

“Lairg is a Scotch village that has hitherto not made its mark in history. It is in remote Sutherlandshire, and its inhabitants probably know little of the world outside the boundaries of their small town. Like many other Scotchmen, they have a sheet of water at their doors, and Loch Shin, though not very large, nor embellished in poetry, has picturesque attractions. The townsmen of Lairg regard the lake as a kind of property of their own; and when, the other Sunday, they beheld a small steamer ruffling its placid waters, their indignation grew high. They are simple and unlearned folk, who think that Sunday is the Sabbath, never having heard probably that Saturday is the day referred to in the fourth commandment. They therefore resolved to hold an indignation meeting, and to denounce Mr. Murphy, the owner of the little vessel, for using it on Sunday, and to forward to him a copy of the denunciation. They freely assailed it as a ‘profanation’ and ‘desecration,’ and declared that it tended ‘to a general lowering of the moral tone of the community.’

“The people of Lairg are perfectly entitled to hold this or any other opinion as to the conduct of Mr. Murphy or anybody else; thought is free. They would be also within their rights if, in their village gatherings over pipes and whisky, they shook their heads, and predicted a judgment on this Irish visitor for his relaxation of Scottish restraints. Still it seems to us that the despatch of their angry resolutions to Mr. Murphy himself—and the publication of their vote of censure—constitute dangerous precedents. Do they publicly reprehend all local sins in the same way? The stool of repentance is not now used in Scotch kirks, but do the elders and other ‘inhabitants of Lairg’ hold up to popular and personal reprobation every lassie in the town or neighborhood who has made a slip? Do they also condemn by name, and address all the drunkards of the parish, and all the shop keepers who adulterate their goods? If not, why should they single out ‘Sabbath breaking,’ as they call it, for published rebuke? Why do they not form themselves into a vigilance committee, to secure respect for other commandments besides the fourth? Or do they, like the Puritans of old, ‘compound for sins they are inclined to, by damning those they have no mind to?’”

“The Lairg remonstrants not only objected to Mr. Murphy’s little steamer, but to his ‘driving about in vehicles’ on Sunday. His reply is calm, courteous, and well considered. He says: ‘I have just as much respect for the due observance of what you call the “Sabbath,” and I call the “Sunday,” as you have; but, whilst you seem to think that God’s will is best accomplished by a gloomy, morose observance of this day, I hold that when prayers are over, a cheerful, genial enjoyment of God’s gifts is the proper course for his creatures. I am happy to think that the vast majority of the queen’s subjects agree with me and not with you.’ We believe that, as regards ‘driving’ or boating on Sunday, Mr. Murphy might have added that not only the majority of the queen’s subjects, but the majority of the people of Scotland, agree with him. There are many working-men in Glasgow, Edinburgh, Dundee, and other Scotch cities and towns, who have no chance of breathing country air or walking in the fields, except by taking steamer or train for a Sunday excursion. If they stayed at home in their narrow rooms, looking out on foul alleys or pent-up lanes, drinking whisky all day, or in the intervals between services, they would escape the censure of their pious neighbors; whereas, because they take their wives and children a short trip, necessary for bodily and mental health, they are held up to public odium as sinners, while the offenses of others go entirely unrebuked. As to the ‘driving’ denounced by the people of Lairg, Mr. Murphy explains: ‘I have spent the autumn, during the last twenty-one years, in the Highlands of Scotland, on terms of the most perfect harmony with my neighbors of the Free and Established Church; and, though I have habitually driven the members of my family on Sunday afternoon, I never heard that my doing so “distracted people on their way to church,” or was considered as the “lowering of the moral tone of the community.” I cannot help thinking that if the people who were distracted would practise a little Christian charity, and think more of their own failings than of the imaginary sins of their neighbors, they would be acting far more in harmony with the wishes of our common Master.’”

“Thus we have here an old and respected member of the community, a man on friendly terms with all his neighbors, deliberately insulted by a number of foolish busybodies, calling themselves ‘the inhabitants of Lairg.’ Surely it is only in Scotland, and in a very remote village, that such an impertinence could be committed at the present day.”

“To add to their insolence, the local censors demanded an ‘answer.’ Mr. Murphy replied: ‘My answer is this, that, whilst I regret to have become involved in a controversy with my neighbors on any subject, I regard your “resolutions” as a somewhat offensive attempt to dictate to me on a matter with which you have no concern; and I shall treat them accordingly, believing, as I do, that I am at least as capable as you are of deciding between what is right and what is wrong.’ In short, life would be intolerable if, in every village and parish throughout the United Kingdom, the local gossips had the presumption of these ‘unco guid’ people at Lairg, and held a public meeting whenever one of their neighbors committed what they considered a sin. If Mr. Murphy watched the lives of the inhabitants of Lairg as they watched his proceedings, he would probably discover a series of acts much more repugnant to morality and law than the use of a little steamer upon a lake on Sunday.”

“For the day of rest as a useful institution, we have every respect. It cannot be considered a divine ordinance, unless by the small sect of English Christians who observe Saturday. They and the Jews are the only people who obey the fourth commandment; all others deliberately violate it when they work on Saturday. The resolve of the early Christians to discontinue the observance of the Sabbath—if the phrase is not tautonomous—and to institute the next day as a new holiday in honor of our Lord’s resurrection, has the prestige of antiquity about it, but it has no divine or scriptural authority whatsoever. It is also evident that the event celebrated gave to Sunday not the characteristics of a fast day, but the associations of a ‘Te Deum’—a day of thanksgiving and joy. The idea of the Puritans to make Sunday a day of gloom is not only not divine and scriptural, but is essentially modern. They turned all religion into something very dark, and they transferred the obligations of the fourth commandment from the seventh day to the first. This they had and have a right to do, as independent human beings, but they have no right to call their Scotch idea of Sunday a ‘divine institution, of permanent and universal obligation.’ It is not divine; it is not old; it is not universal; it cannot even claim to be British.”

“We fully admit that the setting apart of one day in the week for a change in our occupations, our ideas, and our exercises, is extremely beneficial. Even the French Revolutionists were obliged to institute a holiday every ten days. ‘The world is too much with us’; and, as a means of moral, mental, and physical refreshment, it is well that our marts and markets, our warehouses and shops, should be closed, and that men should be tempted, though not forced, to think of higher and nobler things than the stormy debates of politics or the keen competitions of trade. We should prefer a Scotch Sunday itself—unwise, purely human, and grossly mistaken as we think it—to the Sunday of Belgium or France, where shops and theaters are open, where political meetings, horse races, and military reviews are held, and where the workmen are forced to toil. It is this feeling that induces the majority of our artisans to look askance even on the innocent proposal for the opening of museums. They fear that seven days’ work may follow the breaking down of an old barrier. On this rational ground, we do not see why there should not be reasonable compromise all round. The poor benighted worthies of Lairg, who, in their ignorance of Scripture and of church history, believe that the fourth commandment applies to Sunday, are, of course, entirely out of court. They are victims to a painful superstition; but all intelligent men, whether they accept the dogmas of the churches or not, must agree that, in the main, the English Sunday, as it stands, is an excellent institution. But for it, thousands of poor men and women would work all the year round, without cessation. Sometimes rich people resent the dullness of the day, as if six days’ pleasure were not enough; but they should put themselves in the place of the hard toilers in the mill of human life, who see in that one interval the only oasis of rest in the week.”

Such an oasis of weekly rest is indeed needed by mankind. This need is written in man’s constitution. This need, the Sabbath, as at first instituted, and afterward enforced in the decalogue, was designed to supply, and so long as men regarded it, did supply. Where, then, is the consistency in supposing that God took away from men so beneficent an institution, and left his church, without any divine sanction, to make up the lack? Such an inconsistency men charge upon God, when they argue that God has abolished his Sabbath, and then laud Sunday as a glorious institution brought in by men. Better return to the old paths, to the original Sabbath, which, while it possesses all the physical blessings of any other day of rest, can alone claim the moral blessings which belong to such an institution, and, more than all else, can alone challenge obedience on the authority of God’s unrepealed, unalterable law.