AdventAI

THE “CHRISTIAN SABBATH” IS UN-CHRISTIAN.

By Frank W. Howe

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 46., November 20, 1888

BY FRANK W. HOWE.

(Continued.)

Having shown that Christ did not teach the sacredness of the first day, we wish now to offer the following proposition:—

Sunday observance was not taught by the apostles, either by precept or example. As before, we deny that any positive testimony can be found in the Scriptures showing that the disciples taught the observance of the first day. No such testimony has ever been offered, and so we simply dispose of the first half of the proposition by leaving the burden of proof with Sunday advocates. But lest we should appear to ignore the only bit of evidence which has been distorted to that end, we will notice 1 Cor. 16:1–3, which is supposed to present an undeniable precept of Paul’s for the observance of Sunday: “Now concerning the collections for the saints, as I have given order to the churches of Galatia, even so do ye. Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath prospered him, that there be no gatherings when I come. And when I come, whomsoever ye shall approve by your letters, them will I send to bring your liberality unto Jerusalem.”

Here the Sunday apologist sees a plain intimation that Paul directs the Corinthians to take up a collection every Sunday when they assembled for religious services! Now were we to grant that a public collection was here commanded, the conclusion would not follow that the day on which it occurred was necessarily sacred. If it did, we should have more holy-days than Rome can boast. No one even who believes that Sunday is sacred, and regards the passing of the contribution box as an appropriate method of supporting the gospel, would argue that the day received its sacredness from that act alone. Still it is not claimed that this text offers a better reason than that; for no attempt is made to show that the collection was merely an incident of worship, and that the Corinthian church habitually observed Sunday as holy time. The uselessness of any effort to prove such a custom is well known by Sunday observers, and is admitted by their conspicuous silence in that direction.

But we deny that Paul directed a public collection. He says: “Let every one of you lay by him in store.” The words indicate a storing away privately—just the reverse of giving into a public collection-box. Many versions translate the passage “at home.” See Greenfield’s Lexicon, the Vulgate and the Latin version of Castellio; three French translations of Martin, Osterwald, and De Sacy; Luther’s German, the Dutch version, the Italian of Diodati, the Spanish of Filippe Scio, the Portuguese of Ferreira, Theodore Beza’s Latin translation, and the Syriac Bible. Dr. Justin Edwards, a noted first-day writer, confesses there is no foundation for the idea of a public collection. In his “Notes on the New Testament” he says, in commenting on this text: “Lay by him in store; at home; that there be no gatherings; that their gifts might be ready when the apostle should come.”

Having thus disposed of this favorite precept, let us examine a so-called example of Paul’s Sunday observance. Acts 20:7: “And upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them, ready to depart on the morrow; and continued his speech until midnight.” Here is the long-looked-for religious meeting on the first day of the week! Here is the citadel, the unfailing resort of every first-day champion! And yet it is the only account in the whole Bible of a religious meeting on the first day. It affords no aid or comfort to those who would see in it a proof of habitual Sunday observance. On the contrary, it was obviously a special meeting,—Paul was “ready to depart on the morrow.” It was an evening meeting, as “there were many lights in the upper chamber, where they were gathered together.” Nothing is said about the “Christian Sabbath.” All this is evident at once. Hence nothing in the mere fact of meeting, or of preaching, can be claimed as showing the sacredness of the day.p. 722 Christians hold many religious services, both special and regular, in the evening; and yet not even a Sunday apologist regards the corresponding day as holy time.

But such a one would see an undoubted evidence of the sanctity of this particular day, because Paul “broke bread” on the occasion. That fact must surely show it to have been the “Christian Sabbath!” Let us grant, for the argument, that the act of breaking bread indicated the sacredness of the day on which it occurred. Now let us see when Paul broke bread. He preached until midnight (verse 7); then he went down and restored Eutychus to life (verse 9); and when he had “come up again, and had broken bread, and eaten, and talked a long while, even till break of day, so he departed.” Verse 11. It is perfectly obvious that he broke bread after midnight! Now we leave our friends to choose whether this day was marked by Roman or by Jewish time. If by Roman time, then Paul broke bread on the beginning of the following day, and Monday is therefore sanctioned as the Sabbath for Christians! If by Jewish time, then the meeting was held on Saturday night after sunset, and Paul continued his long journey to Jerusalem on the “Christian Sabbath”! Which portion of his example is the more significant? Which alternative is the more to be preferred by Sunday advocates? The very beginning of this meeting was on the “first day of the week,” and we must accept one reckoning or the other. In either case, we are forced to conclude that the sacredness of a day is not indicated by breaking bread upon it. Christ himself instituted the Lord’s Supper on Thursday. And we find (Acts 2:46) that at one time the apostles broke bread “daily.” What must be our conclusion from a consideration of all these facts? That Paul, the only apostle whose precept or example is ever quoted from the Bible in this connection, gives no authority for the obligation of Sunday observance.

We have now shown that no command or example, either by Christ or the apostles, can be produced, showing the observance of the first day of the week to be a Christian duty. Hence it is not Christian, in the first sense stated above; namely, its observance is not of universal obligation upon mankind. But to make this discussion complete, we desire to show that it is un-Christian in the other sense,—it did not originate in the Christian dispensation, as an obligation upon Christians exclusively. We have clearly shown that it has never been instituted by divine or apostolic authority. So there remains only this part of the proposition:—

Sunday observance did not originate in the Christian church. Bear in mind that we have proved that there is no Bible authority for its obligation; we wish now simply to show that worship on that day originated before the Christian era. We need only to examine the derivation of the word to be convinced of this fact. Webster says: “Sunday; so called because this day was anciently dedicated to the sun, or to its worship. The first day of the week; the Christian Sabbath; a day consecrated to rest from secular employments, and to religious worship; the Lord’s day.” Worcester says: “Sunday; so called because anciently dedicated to the sun or to its worship. The first day of the week; the Christian Sabbath, consecrated to rest from labor and to religious worship; the Lord’s day.” It will be remembered that lexicographers do not assume to settle theological disputes, or impose any religious obligations, but simply to define words as they find them commonly employed in the language; so they call Sunday the “Christian Sabbath,” but they expressly state that it was anciently dedicated to the worship of the sun.

Verstegan, in his “Antiquities,” p. 10, says that “the most ancient Germans being pagans, . . . appropriated their first day of the week to the peculiar adoration of the sun, whereof that day doth yet in our English tongue retain the name of Sunday.” The North British Review styles Sunday, “The wild solar holiday of all pagan times!” Worcester says these sun-worshipers, or Sabians, were a “sect of idolators more ancient than Moses.” Dr. Adam Clarke, in commenting on Job 31:26–28, says:—

In this verse [26], Job clears himself of that idolatrous worship which was the most ancient and most consistent with reason, of any species of idolatry.

McClintock and Strong’s Cyclopedia, art. Idolatry, bears testimony to the same effect. Is any stronger proof needed to show that Sunday observance for purposes of worship originated long before the Christian era?

Did the limits of this article permit, we might multiply evidences that the apostasy of the Romish Church led to that edict of Constantine by which Sunday was adopted from paganism, and its observance established upon a legal basis, for Christians. And it is a significant fact that a large Protestant body, at the present time, are likewise seeking the support of civil law. We cannot forbear to present one more testimony regarding the un-Christian origin of first-day observance. It is from an attempt of the North British Review to defend the adoption of this ancient heathen festival into the Christian church:—

That very day was the Sunday of their heathen neighbors and respective countrymen, and patriotism gladly united with expediency, in making it at once their Lord’s day and their Sabbath. . . . If the authority of the church is to be ignored altogether by Protestants, there is no matter; because opportunity and common expediency are surely arguments enough for so ceremonial a change as the mere day of the week for the observance of the rest and holy consecration of the Jewish Sabbath. That primitive church, in fact, was shut up to the adoption of the Sunday, until it became established and supreme, when it was too late to make another alteration; and it was no irreverent or undelightful thing to adopt it, inasmuch as the first day of the week was their own high-day at any rate; so that their compliance and civility were rewarded by the redoubled sanctity of their quiet festival.

Comment upon this testimony is unnecessary. The discerning reader cannot fail to see that Sunday-keeping owes its present position in popular Christianity to that early apostasy and spirit of antichrist, which considers it no sin to violate the very essence of God’s Sabbath law, and to ignore the day which was divinely sanctified and hallowed.

(Concluded next week.)