BY ELD. J. H. MORRISON.
AN EXPOSURE.
Sometimes in the course of human events it becomes necessary to show up the perversity of men, that they may appear to the world as they really are, and be dealt with accordingly. Sin is deserving of no attention because of any inherent merit it possesses,—for such it does not possess,—but only because of its injurious effects. Likewise sinners sometimes demand attention, not because they themselves are deserving of it, but because they throw themselves in the way of the progress of truth. Men who are honestly seeking after truth, though still clinging to error, are entitled to a just consideration, and to feelings of sympathy and commiseration. But those who knowingly and persistently disregard truth are to be shunned and avoided on all possible occasions, and held as the enemies of truth. The Bible gives instances of such men, and tells how they should be regarded. 2 Tim. 2:16-18; 4:14, 15.
The Sabbath reform of these last days has been a source of great annoyance to those who are wedded to the customs and traditions of their fathers, and opposed to the spirit of true reform. They have been greatly perplexed to know what to do, and which way to turn. Obstacles and difficulties have presented themselves with every plan suggested. Many expedients have been tried, but none seem to have given general satisfaction. This accounts for the many and contradictory positions taken by the advocates of Sunday observance. Their various arguments are but an array of contradictions,—a mass of confusion. About the only point of agreement is the object aimed at. Sunday-keeping must be maintained at all hazards.
One of the most pernicious and shocking expedients tried has been the abolition of the law,—the heresy of antinomianism. Notwithstanding how harsh it may sound to say that Christ came to destroy his Father's law, which Paul declares is holy, just, and good (Rom. 7:12); notwithstanding that law contains such commandments as, “Thou shalt not kill,” “Thou shalt not steal,” and “Thou shalt not covet”; notwithstanding Christ himself said he did not come to destroy that very law, yet, for all this, rather than make a change, and keep the day God has commanded to be kept, some have dared to declare that law abolished.
We have ever claimed that it has been a blessing to the world that the advocates of this doctrine have not yet fallen to the low level of their teachings. The doctrine, however, is not to be credited, and is none the better for that. It is the open flood-gate to all forms of sin and vice. While other considerations may influence the advocates to maintain a degree of honor and honesty, yet when the royal law of Jehovah is no longer regarded as binding, the great moral and restraining influence is gone, and we need not be surprised to find such men, when brought to defend the very practice that has driven them into this position, manifesting more of the logical results of the theory than mere Sabbath-breaking. To show that such is the case, we present the following facts concerning Eld. D. R. Lucas, a prominent Disciple minister in Iowa, and editor of the Christian Oracle.
Most of our readers are doubtless aware that Eld. Lucas and myself held a discussion on the Sabbath question at Abingdon, Ia., last March, as the result of a challenge previously made there by him. The propositions discussed read as follows:—
1. Do the Scriptures teach that the ten commandments, as recorded in the twentieth chapter of Exodus, are now binding, the fourth precept of which enjoins the observance of the seventh day as the Sabbath, or Lord's day, as taught and practiced by the Seventh-day Adventist Church?
2. Do the Scriptures teach that the first day of the week is the Lord's day, and should be observed as taught and practiced by the Christian church?
According to articles of agreement written and signed by Eld. Lucas himself, each of the above propositions was to be discussed for four sessions of two hours and twenty minutes each, two sessions each day, one in the forenoon and one in the evening, with either party having the privilege of extending the time on either proposition, if desired.
This agreement was written and signed Tuesday afternoon, March 6, 1888. The discussion began that evening. A discussion of eight sessions, with two a day, one in the forenoon and one in the evening, beginning Tuesday evening, could not possibly close before Saturday forenoon. And yet in the Oracle of June 21, Eld. Lucas says, “When the debate began at Abingdon, the time was arranged to close on Friday night.”
Again, according to the privileges granted in the written agreement, I took an extra session on my proposition, affirming until the close of the session Thursday night. Eld. Lucas began affirming Friday forenoon, stating then that the discussion would close with the coming evening session. And close it did, in spite of all that could be brought to bear upon him. Consequently, he affirmed but two sessions, and the discussion closed with the seventh.
But observe the Elder's statement in the Oracle of July 5: “Morrison affirmed five sessions and Lucas three, making the full eight.” We leave the reader to use his knowledge of simplest mathematics in drawing his conclusions as to the truthfulness of the statement.
Eld. Lucas claimed to have an important engagement to fill, that prevented him from staying longer. But if that engagement was made before the discussion began, why did he enter into a written agreement which, if lived up to, would absolutely prevent him from meeting it? Nothing, however, was said about a previous engagement before the discussion began. But if the engagement was made after the discussion had begun, we ask what right he had to make it, and what could have been his object in doing so? Again we leave the reader to soliloquize. The Elder is in a dilemma, whichever way it may have been.
These facts becoming known, and being reported, Eld. Lucas at once branded them as “lies,” at the same time making a challenge for another discussion, agreeing this time to put in full and equal time. His words are:—
We hereby challenge Mr. Morrison or any Adventist (except W. A. Colcord) in Iowa, to select a place for debate, and we will meet him and debate just as long as the Adventist may wish.—Oracle, June 21, 1888.
And again:—
We now say that we are ready to meet Mr. Morrison at any time and place he may select, on the very same propositions and terms we discussed before. The only exception we make is that our time from Aug. 5-20 is engaged, an engagement made some six months ago. Now let him fix time and place, and see who is afraid to debate.—Oracle, July 12, 1888.
Accordingly I wrote Eld. Lucas, accepting his challenge, stating time and place, and requesting that my acceptation be published in the Oracle. My closing words were:—
I hereby accept your challenge, with the understanding that you bear half the expenses connected therewith. Will accommodate you by meeting you in Des Moines in discussion, beginning Oct. 2, at 7:30 P. M., 1888.
This appeared in the Oracle of July 26, 1888. After complaining at considerable length because the time was appointed for over two months in the future, Eld. Lucas says:—
We are not now sure that we shall be able to accommodate Mr. Morrison at the time he sets, owing to some other engagements at that time.
He says, “Select any time you choose, Aug. 5-20 only being excepted, and we will meet you.” I do so, and then he says he is not sure he can meet me. “Other engagements” appear to stand in the way. Yes, that was the trouble (!) down at Abingdon. An “important engagement” prevented him from putting in the time he had expressly agreed to. But let us look at this matter of engagements a moment, and see how much investigation it will bear. In his challenge as above quoted from the Oracle, July 12, he excepts Aug. 5-20, stating he is engaged for that time, “an engagement made six months ago.” In my acceptance, I respected this exception, placing the date a little over a month in the future from that time. But the time selected did not suit. It interfered with some unmentioned engagements. But of how much importance does he treat the engagement made so long before, for Aug. 5-20?
In the same article in which he complains because the time selected was a month or two in the future, and at a time that would interfere with some of his “engagements,” he says:—
Will our brethren in the various parts of the State notify us at once where these Adventists have their tents now pitched in this State, or anywhere in the Northwest? and we shall take the occasion of notifying Mr. Morrison of the time we shall visit the places. . . . Now as they cannot get ready till October, we would like to put in the summer by exposing this most injurious of all systems to peace and piety, in all its phases. . . . We do not believe we can wait until October.
This was written July 26, 1888. He here expresses his intentions of taking a tour among our tents for the purpose of exposing our doctrines, and of putting in the remainder of the summer at it. But what would this require him to do?—To ignore that engagement for Aug. 5-20, made six months ago,—to put in the very time he had expressly stated he could not engage in a discussion with me, in making a circuit among our tents, exposing our doctrines, inviting me to be present. It thus appears that the engagements which he deems of enough importance to specify, he can ignore without concern; but those he does not mention are so imperative they cannot be interfered with? The written engagement at Abingdon, to discuss for eight sessions or more, had to be broken to meet one he had not mentioned! The published engagement for Aug. 5-20 could be totally disregarded, while the one for October, which he had said nothing about, must be heeded! It seems, then, that some of his engagements are not so important, after all, and that others are only convenient ones he has to throw in, to avoid meeting an opponent and standing by the Sunday, even after making the most open challenges and definite agreements. He has not even made his proposed tour over the State. We have failed to receive any notice from him, and no tent company has reported his presence. The very evident reason for it all is, it is not so desirable a thing to defend the Sunday, neither is it so easy a matter to affirm forp. 724 the teachings and practices of a church that teaches the ten commandments abolished only when considering the Sabbath question, but binding when teaching Sunday-school lessons, as instance the following quotations, all of which are from Disciple works:—
ANTI-SABBATH WORKS.
They [S. D. Adventists] affirm that there are two laws,—one the ceremonial, and the other the moral law. This is a bald assumption. Where can we find this distinction of moral and ceremonial law?—P. Widow, in the Sabbath Question, p. 22.
Neither of these (the two great commandments, Matt. 22:37, 39) is to be found in the decalogue, and yet they were chief. This is not all; a man might observe every one of the ten, and not keep either one of them.—D. E. Dungan, in Sabbath or Lord's Day, p. 34.
The decalogue was written on two tables of stone, by the finger of God. But what has that to do with its perpetuity?—D. E. Dungan, in Sabbath or Lord's Day, p. 33.
The law of which the Sabbath was a part was done away in Christ.—D. R. Dungan, in Sabbath or Lord's Day, p. 35.
Now, to my mind, the question resolves itself into this: Are we now under the law of which the Sabbath was a part, or is the Sabbath now binding on Christians? For certain it is, if we are to keep the Sabbath, then we are bound to observe the seventh day of the week.—D. R. Dungan, in Sabbath or Lord's Day, p. 7.
The Sabbath reminded the Jews of their bondage in Egypt.—P. Widow, in the Sabbath Question.
SUNDAY-SCHOOL WORKS.
No reader of the pentateuch can fail to mark the fact that a special importance belonged to the commandments. They were spoken directly by the voice of God, . . . while the other precepts bearing on things civil and ceremonial were communicated through Moses.—Standard Bible Lesson Quarterly for 1887, p. 129.
The first four are summed up in the golden text of that lesson; the second table of six, in the golden text of this lesson. (Golden text: Matt. 22:37, 39.)—The Bible Student for 1887, p. 176.
They were written on two tables of stone by the finger of God, thus indicating that they were designed for permanence.—Standard Bible Lesson Quarterly, p. 129.
The divine law has never been repealed. The decalogue is the basis of human law,—“the common law,” the world over.—Christian Sunday-school Teacher for 1887, p. 133.
The first table of the law, which came before us last Sunday, defines our duties to God; the second table defines our duties to each other. Both must be kept.—Ibid., p. 133.
God speaks, and I must hear; God calls, I must obey; Him must I serve, and him alone, All idols put away. His name I must revere, And never lightly speak; His holy day I must observe, The best of all the week.—Primary Quarterly, '87, p. 67.
Our God is a royal God, requiring of men the tribute of one day in seven for his service. With a proper keeping of this day are linked the best interests of both society and individuals.—Christian Sunday-school Teacher, p. 187.
To the Jews, the seventh day was a Sabbath, or rest, reminding them of God's rest from the work of creation.—Standard Bible Lesson Quarterly, p. 133.
Why the no-law theory is advocated, is too transparent to need comment. Such a zigzag course cannot be in consequence of following the teachings of the Bible, but from a labored effort to bend its teachings to suit an institution of which the Bible knows nothing. To affirm for such contradictory teachings as above presented, would indeed be a difficult task. And this doubtless is one reason why Eld. Lucas has sought to avoid it.
After waiting till Sept. 25, to hear definitely from him in regard to my acceptance of his challenge, I addressed the following letter to Eld. Lucas, to be inserted in the Christian Oracle, and sent it by special messenger.
Des Moines, Ia., Sept. 25, 1888.
Eld. D. R. Lucas, Des Moines, Ia.
DEAR BROTHER: In further accepting the terms of your challenge for a theological discussion between you and myself, permit me to announce Good Templar's Hall, West 7th St., between Walnut and Locust, Des Moines, Ia., as the “place” for our first session. Respecting the “time,” as before stated, providence permitting, I will meet you, Tuesday night, Oct. 2, 1888, at 7:30 P. M.
Yours truly, J. H. MORRISON.
The party carrying the letter met with a positive refusal to insert it in the Oracle of that week, although presented in ample time. The resident editor also refused to insert any notice whatever relating to the discussion. This will appear strange when it is known that the Oracle had, thus far, contained all the published information in regard to it, and that there was appearing in the very issue in which we desired the notice, a question from Eld. Van Kirk, of Ames, asking the identical information that our notice would have given.
On inquiry, it was learned that Eld. Lucas, the senior editor, was at Indianapolis, Ind., acting as substitute pastor for the Disciple church of that city, and under obligations to remain at least over next “Lord's day.” The notice was forwarded to the Elder. Agreeably thereto I began the circulation of the appointment, and at the time specified, went with our own people to the place designated, to participate in the expected discussion. But few of the Disciple church made their appearance, and what was most striking of all, Eld. Lucas failed to materialize.
Prof. D. E. Dungan, of the Drake University, appeared, however, to impersonate him. He tried to apologize for the Elder's absence, by stating that he was a poor man, and having received an offer of a very liberal salary from the Disciple church at Indianapolis, Ind., had gone to that place. He also stated that in a letter he had just received from Eld. Lucas, the Elder said he “supposed that the discussion had blown over,” but requested him to go to the hall specified in the notice, and if a discussion must be had, for him to take his place. I informed the audience that the case in hand could be settled only with Eld. Lucas; but that if Prof. Dungan had any charges to prefer, and would present them, I was ready to meet him; but that that would by no means release Eld. Lucas from his obligation. Further, I asked Prof. Dungan if he was willing to accept of the propositions agreed upon between Eld. Lucas and myself, and could continue for eight sessions or longer? He replied he could not, owing to other engagements; that he could put in but two evenings that week. Thus he was not prepared to fill the Elder's engagement. Consequently, the discussion was declared off, on account of a non-compliance of Eld. Lucas with his agreement.
Why Eld. Lucas should have treated this matter as he has; why he should have thought the discussion “blown over,” when not the slightest zephyr was ever breathed on my part to blow it over; why he should have so lightly regarded his word, are causes for no little astonishment. His challenge was made in the most definite terms, and, apparently, in all seriousness. It was treated accordingly. But it seems that when the Elder became aware that I took him at his word, and meant what I said, he decided to let the matter pass as a light and trivial affair, leaving one naturally to conclude that the challenge was made merely for a bluff. However, the reasons for all this, shall be left for others to conjecture. The facts are before the reader.
A brief summary of the foregoing will perhaps not be out of place.
1. Eld. Lucas has stated that the time agreed upon for the Abingdon discussion (eight sessions or longer) was filled up, whereas there were but seven sessions held.
2. He has stated that the understanding was that the said discussion was to close Friday night, whereas, according to an express agreement written and signed by myself, it could not possibly have closed before Saturday forenoon, and might have been extended much longer.
3. He has stated that he affirmed three sessions, whereas he affirmed but two.
4. He agreed to affirm for four sessions or more, but closed the discussion upon his own responsibility, with the second.
5. He pleaded that a previous engagement necessitated him to “cut short” the discussion, which, (though not according very well with the statement that the time was “filled up”), if true, implies that he knowingly entered into a definite agreement, which, if lived up to, would prevent him from meeting that engagement.
6. He made a second challenge to meet us at any time and place we might select, with Aug. 5-20 only excepted, closing the challenge by saying, “Now let them fix time and place, and see who is afraid to debate”; but when the challenge was accepted, and the accepted time not interfered with, Oct. 2 being selected, then he does not know that he can meet me at the time specified.
7. When the time came for the second discussion, he was over 400 miles away from the place appointed for it.
8. He has allowed new and unmentioned engagements to prevent him from fulfilling previously made and definitely stated ones.
9. Some of his engagements, however, appear to be merely those of convenience, which he has to throw in to avoid meeting an opponent, defending the Sunday, and fulfilling definite and express agreements.
Eld. Lucas has been considered a representative man among his people here in the West, traveling from place to place, and the editor of a professedly Christian paper. Until he shall clear up his past record, we shall feel it our duty to consider him and those who may seek to justify him in his course as unworthy of further notice as sincere Christians.
As to the truth of my statements in regard to the discussion at Abingdon, the following will testify:—
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN.
We, the undersigned, hereby state that the debate at Abingdon, Iowa, between Eld. J. H. Morrison and Eld. D. R. Lucas, began Tuesday, March 6, 1888, at 7:30 P. M., and that two sessions were held on each of the following days, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday, making, in all, seven sessions. Eld. Morrison affirmed five sessions on his proposition and Eld. Lucas two on his, although he (Lucas) had agreed to affirm four sessions, and more at the option of either himself or Eld. Morrison.
Eld. Lucas concluded his affirmation with two sessions, stating as his reason, that it was unnecessary for him to affirm longer in order to establish his proposition. When such reason for prematurely closing the discussion was announced Friday morning, Eld. Morrison arose and said that he (Lucas) had proposed to close the discussion without any consultation with him whatever; objected to the manner of any such proceeding, and reminded him of his written contract to affirm four sessions, or longer at the option of either party. Eld. Lucas then urged that he had arranged to meet his wife the following day, and to preach at Albia the next “Lord's day.”
C. F. SEVERNS, B. D. MOWERY, } Moderators.
[With fourteen other signatures.]