BY ELD. L. R. CONRADI.
The noted Lutheran theologian, Olshausen, speaking of the rich man and Lazarus, remarks in his commentary on Luke 16, and with perfect right: “The expression, immortality of the soul, or the modern immortality doctrine of the soul, are alike unknown to the Bible.” It matters not how emphatically the Holy Scriptures speak of the resurrection through Christ as the true and only hope of the believer for any further life, nor how often they speak of the day of the resurrection as the day of reward, nor how much stress they lay on the judgment, nor how often they designate death as a sleep, and the resurrection as the awakening, nor how clearly they express themselves concerning the intermediate state,—it appears still that fables are more pleasing to the human ear than the living word of truth.
There is probably no part of the Holy Scriptures oftener brought forward as proof that man not only is conscious after death, but also that he then receives his reward or punishment, than the illustration of the rich man and Lazarus which Jesus gives in Luke 16:19-31. The word of God says in Eccl. 9:5: “The dead know not anything;” and still here are Abraham, Lazarus, and the rich man,—three dead persons,—represented as talking, and conscious. The one is comforted, the other tormented. Should the word of God contradict itself? This cannot be possible; but “what is truth?”
A PARABLE.
The first question which may be asked, is whether Luke 16:19-31 is a parable or an actual event. Already, in chapter 15, we find three parables; namely, those of the lost sheep, the piece of silver, and the prodigal son; and the 16th chapter begins with the parable of the unjust steward, and that of the rich man and Lazarus seems to conclude this sermon of parables. It does not exactly state that this is a parable; neither is it specified that the two preceding ones are. But all three begin in the same manner: “A certain rich man had two sons;” “There was a certain rich man, which had a steward;” “There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen.”
Nearly all the church Fathers readily admitted it to be a parable. This opinion was so fixed in the minds of some writers of note, that we find it expressly stated in their manuscripts; it is thus in Beza’s most ancient copy, and in another manuscript of his, it reads, by way of preface, “He said also another parable.” Standard works also, as the Oxford Teacher’s Bible, Smith’s Bible Dictionary, Herzog’s Encyclopedia, M’Clintock and Strong’s Cyclopedia, the commentaries of Lange, Olshausen, the Comprehensive Commentary, Bengel’s Gnomon, Tischendorf’s Greek Testament, Delitzsch, Wiener, and many other critics and commentators acknowledge it as a parable.
But as everybody seems to acknowledge this fact, we next inquire, What do we understand by a parable? Webster defines “parable” as follows: “A fable or allegorical relation or representation of something real in life or nature, from which a moral is drawn for instruction.” M’Clintock and Strong’s Cyclopedia gives the following, as the general sense of the word “parable” in the New Testament: “A fictitious narrative, under which is veiled some important truth.” The noted German Bible dictionary of P. Zeller, Calw edition, says under “parable:” “Besides the real parables, which clothe the intended truth in an event from another field, Jesus has given other fictitious, instructive narratives, which by a single example make a duty intuitive, or place the opinions and actions in the right light. To this class belong the story of the good Samaritan, that of the rich fool, of the rich man and Lazarus, and also of the Pharisee and the publican. Luke 12; 16; 18. Yet these narratives also bear in a broader sense the name ‘parables.’ Luke 12: 16; 18: 9.”
All these definitions plainly show that the subject under consideration is not a real event, but a “fictitious narrative.” A noted theologian justly remarks: “For those who look upon this narrative as an actual occurrence, this must stand as an irrefutable proof for the purgatory of the Catholics.” The evil consequences of such explanations are already seen on every hand, as many professed Protestant theologians incline again more and more to the doctrine of the purgatory.
THE DEVIL NOT YET IN THE LAKE OF FIRE.
According to the word of God, neither the Devil, nor his angels, nor wicked men are in torment; they will first be thrown into the gehenna, or lake of fire, after the judgment of the great day. We do not punish persons before they are judged. The fallen angels and the world will be judged by the saints, according to 1 Cor. 6:2, 3; but this is not done until the end of the world, when all the saints are together, and the number of the ungodly is full; namely, during the thousand years. Rev. 20:4. The judgment, therefore, is future, and God has appointed a certain day for it. Acts 17:31; 24:25.
The Devil, with his angels, is not now in the lake of fire; but according to Eph. 2:2, he rules as prince of the power of the air; and according to Eph. 6:12, we have to wrestle “against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places,” or, as others give it more correctly, in “heavenly places,” referring to the material heavens. Therefore, we have to look for the evil angels outside of the real heavens, and above the earth, in the surrounding stratum of air.
Dr. A. Clarke says, in his commentary on Eph. 6:12: “The spiritual wickednesses are supposed to be the angels which kept not their first estate; who fell from the heavenly places, but are ever longing after and striving to regain them; and which have their station in the region of the air.”
“Perhaps,” says Mr. Wesley, “the principalities and powers remain mostly in the citadel of their kingdom of darkness; but there are other spirits which range abroad.”
M’Clintock and Strong’s Cyclopedia confirms this. Under art. “Devil” it says in reference to him and his angels: “Yet they rule in the kingdom of darkness (Eph. 6:12; comp. Col. 1:13; roving about in the atmosphere, Eph. 2:2).”
Dr. A. Sulzberger, a noted German Methodist, who wrote a standard work on doctrinal theology, remarks: “According to the most and the greatest orthodox commentators, the permanent residence of the evil spirits is now, in the proper sense, neither the heavens nor the hell, but the atmosphere surrounding the earth.”—Christliche Glaubenslehre, part 2, section 97.
And after a closer examination of the text in 2 Peter 2:4, we see that it agrees perfectly with this view, although at first it appears to contradict it. From the words, “reserved unto the judgment,” it is evident that this passage cannot refer to the actual place of punishment or the real hell fire, but to a place of confinement unto the judgment. But the original, as we also see from our Revised Version, solves every doubt; for we do not find here the Greek word gehenna, as in Matt. 5:22, 29, and in James 3:6, but another; namely, tartarus. This word can be found nowhere else in the Bible. The old Grecians used this term to designate a place full of darkness and cold, and Grotius, while he appeals to Plutarch, refers it to the air. According to Bloomfield, tartarus is an intensive reduplication of the very old word tar, which in the earliest dialect signified dark. Many eminent critics have supposed that the apostle used this term to denote the aerial regions that surround the earth. Bengel, Lange, Däcksel, etc., call this a place of detention, but the place of torment is future. Bengel says in his “Gnomon,” concerning the chains: “The darkness itself holds the captives, and is for them a chain.” Therefore, according to the word of God, we have the icy hemisphere which surrounds our material universe, as the present abode of the Devil and his angels, instead of the lake ofp. 34 fire and brimstone, illuminated by glaring flames, and situated somewhere under the earth.
The angels, cast there at the time of their fall from heaven, to be reserved until the judgment, could also visit the earth. Lange and Bengel both remark: “This detention of the evil angels is only a provisional one, and the servants of hell can still tarry on the earth (Luke 8:31; Eph. 2:2; Acts 5:3; 13:10), and, like captives of war, are often permitted to go outside of the place of their confinement.” Thus in Genesis 3, we find Satan already in paradise. But this serpent who so slyly crept into the garden at the time God set man as ruler over the earth, has become the “prince of this world.” He could show to Jesus all the kingdoms of the whole earth, and say: “All this power will I give thee, and the glory of them: for that is delivered unto me: and to whomsoever I will, I give it.” Luke 4:6. The evil spirits are now “rulers” of the world, and mankind, deluded by them, their servants and slaves. The “Devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour.” 1 Peter 5:8.
After all that has been said, the Devil and the evil spirits can neither be in the lake of fire, nor in torment. That this is so, we learn from their own mouths, in Matt. 8:29: “Art thou come hither to torment us before the time?” While Jesus was on the earth, it was not yet time to torment them; but in our day the words in Rev. 12:12 are fully applicable: “Woe to the inhabitants of the earth and of the sea! for the Devil is come down unto you, having great wrath, because he knoweth that he hath but a short time.” Instead of being bound with chains somewhere in the earth, there to be tormented, we find him, with his angels, here on the earth, as John also confirms in Rev. 12:9, when he says: “And the great dragon was cast out: . . . he was cast out into the earth, and his angels were cast out with him.” Just at the time of the second coming of Christ, he will be bound a thousand years, and finally, after he has been loosed for a little season, “to go out to deceive the nations, which are in the four quarters of the earth,” the well-merited destruction in the lake of fire overtakes him and his companions. Revelation 20. In view of these plain statements, we can call the fables concerning Satan and the various representations of his torment, only another of the many misconceptions in reference to the father of lies.
(To be continued.)