In the Christian Statesman of Jan. 3 is printed the speech made by Senator Henry W. Blair, of Sunday-bill fame, on the occasion of the referring of his proposed Constitutional Amendment, “respecting establishments of religion and free public schools,” to the Committee on Education and Labor, of which he is himself the chairman. The most obnoxious portion of this proposed amendment is section 2, which provides that “each State in this Union shall establish and maintain a system of free public schools adequate for the education of all the children living therein, between the ages of six and eighteen years, inclusive, in the common branches of knowledge, and in virtue, morality, and the principles of the Christian religion.” In that portion of his speech which referred to this section, Mr. Blair said:—
In regard to the general principles of the Christian religion, no one but a bigot would think of having introduced into the public schools instruction in favor of any form of sectarianism; but a knowledge of the Christian religion, even if there be no enforcement of those truths upon the conviction and belief of the child, instruction in those principles, a statement or explanation of what they are, exactly as instruction is given in the principles of arithmetic and geography and any of the common branches of science, is exceedingly desirable and important for every citizen of this country to possess, whether he applies the principle in his personal conduct or not, because they are the warp and woof, the very fabric, of society, of the surroundings in which he lives, the basis of our customs and laws and of the conduct of life.
It seems from this, that Mr. Blair supposes it is possible to give instruction in the “principles of the Christian religion,” “exactly as instruction is given in the principles of arithmetic and geography and any of the common branches of science.” But this cannot be done, for the simple reason that there is no general agreement as to what the “principles of the Christian religion” are. A theological congress will first have to be called to decide this question; and even after this has been done, there will be nothing which will guarantee to any one, beyond possibility of doubt, that their decision is correct. There is a difference between an investigation of the truths of science and those of religion, which must be taken into account; namely, that while in the former case the result is never affected by individual preferences or prejudice, in the latter case it almost always is; and therefore one could not have the same confidence in the results arrived at in a theological congress that he would have in one which considered subjects of a scientific nature, especially such simple scientific subjects as those mentioned in the proposed amendment. Many are the published text-books treating upon arithmetic, geography, and other branches of science, yet one does not contradict another. But how different with works treating upon questions of religion! Not only is there here the widest difference of belief, but the conflict rages as fiercely around the fundamental principles of the Christian faith as in any other part of the field. We venture the assertion that the ablest theologian in our land could not at the present moment define the principles of the Christian religion so clearly and exactly as to be certain that no other theologian, representing a denomination of equal importance with his own, would offer a dissent from his views. Certainly Mr. Blair himself, who by his own confession is not a church man, would not be qualified to define what those principles are which his amendment so prominently concerns.
But whatever these “principles” might turn out to be, when summoned from their present obscurity by some Ecumenical council of American theologians, it seems evident that something more is meant by the language under consideration than the instruction of the youth in the principles of virtue and morality; and the fact that such instruction is desired by a large majority of the denominations of Christendom would not render it unsectarian in its character, any more than it would be, should all these denominations afterward unite into one body, and thus constitute themselves one of the sects of Christendom in whose interests it would be unlawful to legislate. In view of the professedly earnest desire for Christian union which finds expression at the present time from all denominations, it would seem that there ought to be considerable hesitation on the part of somebody before allowing the nation to pass laws which would place a premium upon the divided state of things which now prevails to the great detriment of the best interests of the church. L. A. S.