AdventAI

CRIME AND ITS PUNISHMENT.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 3., January 15, 1889

WHATEVER may be the merits of the new plan adopted in the Empire State, of substituting the electric shock for hanging, in the execution of the death penalty, there is little question that it will have no special virtue as a deterrent from crime, if indeed its effect is not rather of an opposite character. Hardly had the new year arrived, when there were two murders in the streets of New York City, the perpetrators of which will, if convicted, pay the penalty according to the new plan. That the law when it inflicted hanging for murder, seemed to have little effect upon the perpetration of this crime, seems to be due rather to the infrequency with which it was carried into effect, then to any impotency in the method of punishment prescribed. It is worthy of note that simultaneously with the establishment of this system in New York, there will go into effect a law totally abolishing the death penalty in the kingdom of Italy; and while other kingdoms have not yet formally taken this step, in several of them the death penalty by law has been practically abandoned for some time. Thus in Belgium there has been no execution since 1863. In Prussia, from 1870 to 1880, while judgment of death was pronounced upon 538 criminals, but one—Hodel, the would-be assassin of the late Emperor William—was actually executed. Of 21 death sentences recently pronounced in Sweden, but 4 have been carried into effect. In France, of 130 death penalties pronounced in 1880, 65 were executed, and of 100 death penalties pronounced in 1884, only 15 were carried out. In Austria the percentage of 16 in 1869 declined to 3 in 1884. Portugal, Holland, Roumania, and sixteen of the Swiss cantons have also totally abolished the death penalty, and Russia is taking steps to abolish it for crimes below the degree of treason.

The alarming prevalence of crimes of all descriptions and degrees of atrocity seems to forbid accounting for this relaxing of the terrors of the law on the supposition that society in general is becoming more humane and averse to human suffering. It is to be feared that there exists only the relation of cause and effect between such a relaxation and the frequency with which the unwritten law of public sentiment against the perpetration of a heinous crime is now executed by Judge Lynch.

L. A. S.