Progressive Sanctification

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 21, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 8.

Read the full edition

Progressive Sanctification.

BY ELD. D. T. BOURDEAU.

A Reply to Criticisms.

The subject of this article is a reply to criticisms on articles against instantaneous sanctification which appeared in Nos. 22 and 23 of vol. 54 of the REVIEW. As will be seen, the object of the criticisms to be considered is not only to demolish the doctrines of progressive sanctification, but also to establish that of instantaneous sanctification. The reader will be left to judge whether this twofold object has been accomplished.
I will number the points of criticism for the sake of convenience.
1. “You define sanctification to be freedom from sin. You define sin to be the transgression of the law. Therefore sanctification is freedom from the transgression of the law. Question 1: Which precept of the law do your ministers transgress? I wish to know, that when they come around preaching the observance of the fourth commandment, we can also preach to them the observance of the one they transgress. It seems to me that you fall under the condemnation of Paul. You who teach that others should obey the law, do you obey?”
Answer. a. I did not thus define sanctification, but defined it, “A cleansing from sin, not only in the record of our own lives, but also in our natures and practices; the setting apart of the body and mind, in practice, from sin to holiness. It is a moral repair of the soul in practical tests to which it is subjected, and can be recognized only in such a use of the soul and its powers as is in accordance with the word of God. And this cannot be the work of a moment.”
b. The passage which was doubtless construed by our friend as our definition of sanctification reads, “The end of sanctification being exemption from sin in the practice of holiness,” etc. Quite a difference between the end of sanctification and the work by which that end, or final object, is reached. But
c. It would not be fatal to our theory to even adopt the definition falsely attributed to me, as the term sin, though comprehensive, applies to each transgression of God’s law; and we are exempt or free from sin to the degree that we overcome it by the grace of God.
d. We strive to advance in the observance of all the precepts of God’s holy law. But
e. Were we to offset one transgression against another, we certainly would not go by the right rule to advance in sanctification. We should sin willfully, and it would be in vain to apply the sacrifice of Christ to our sins; for it would not take them away, and we would remain in our sins, unsanctified.
2. “Your first argument against instantaneous sanctification is that the truth is progressive. Question 2: Was it not progressive in Paul’s day? If it was, and its being progressive is proof that sanctification is progressive, it follows that Paul, and in fact all Christians, died without being sanctified, or died in their sins; for they were not sanctified, according to the argument, and therefore are lost, as it is impossible for anything sinful to enter Heaven. But shall we not continue to advance in the knowledge of God to all eternity, and if so never get sanctified?”
Ans. My argument was that sanctifying, Bible truth being progressive in its manifestation, sanctification must be a progressive work. I did not speak of the truth and knowledge of God in general; hence the odium of our friend’s strained conclusions, drawn from a premise of his own creation, falls upon his own head. Truth was progressive in Paul’s day, but he so advanced in its increasing light that he could invite his brethren to follow him (1 Cor. 4:16), and thus he did not die in his sins, and was not lost. If he had been indifferent to increasing light, as most of his people were in his day, he would, like them, have died in his sins—unsanctified. This devoted servant of Christ did not, after years of progressive advancement, feel above saying, “Not as though I had already attained, either were already perfect.” Phil. 3:12–14. “Let us,” said he to his brethren, “cleanse ourselves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the fear of God.” 2 Cor. 7:1. “Let us go on to perfection.” Heb. 6:2.
3. “The second argument is based upon the fact that all of the blessings of God are granted upon conditions, refers to repentance, etc., as conditions of justification, and states that it takes time to repent and be baptized. If this argument is worth anything, it also proves that justification as well as sanctification is progressive. According to your teachings, justification consists in writing pardon in one book and the name in the other. Question 3: Does it take years to write a person’s name in the Lamb’s book of life, and to write pardon in the book of remembrance?”
Ans. a. In these remarks my real argument is left out. The argument referred to is drawn from conversion as follows: “All who believe the Bible, must admit that there is a mighty cleansing from sin in conversion. . . . Sanctification must therefore embrace conversion. Indeed, conversion, or the first and thorough start in conversion, is the beginning of sanctification. This being the case, sanctification cannot be an instantaneous work. In conversion, as well as in sanctification, there are certain conditions to be complied with, such as repentance, faith, baptism, prayer, etc., which it takes more than a moment to perform. The mind must be enlightened on the nature of sin and the means of pardon and justification, the proud will must submit to God, the bitter pangs of repentance must be experienced, and faith must be exercised in Christ, who died as our substitute and arose for our justification, and now pleads in behalf of the penitent believer the merits of his precious, atoning blood. As these and other steps are taken, the work of conversion and sanctification progresses. It then continues through the work of subduing the remains of sin in the soul, which were perhaps unobserved in the beginning of sanctification, and in forming a holy, symmetrical character, the foundation of which was laid in the first and thorough start in conversion.”
Why should our friend refuse to grapple with the real argument, and make so partial and incorrect a statement?
b. As justification, or the imputing of Christ’s righteousness to the repenting believer, accompanies pardon, we need it not only when we first repent and believe, but whenever we need pardon. We need it all through the purifying process of sanctification; for while we are being cleansed from sin, we need pardon and Christ’s imputed righteousness.
c. Let it be shown that we make the writing of pardon in one book and the name in the other identical with justification. That would be about as consistent as instantaneous sanctification.
d. Admitting that it does not take long to write a person’s name in the book of life and pardon in the book of remembrance, what Bible proof have we that entire sanctification is effected while these acts are being performed? If this were the case, it would be very improper for Paul to exhort Christians to perfect holiness, or sanctification (French translation), also for him to pray that Christians may be wholly sanctified (1 Thess. 5:23); and it would be very improper for the most pious characters mentioned in the Bible to seek for a greater nearness to God, to speak of being changed from glory to glory in the image of Christ, etc. Christ prayed for the sanctification of those whose names were written in Heaven (John 17:17; Luke 10:20); and to the church of Sardis he says, “He that overcometh, the same shall be clothed in white raiment; and I will not blot out his name out of the book of life.” Rev. 3:5.
4. “You make the statement that if a person was to die after being justified, he would be saved without being sanctified. Question 4: Would he go to Heaven with his sins? or is there a moral change at the resurrection?”
Ans. I make no such statement. This is what I say, “The precious blood of Christ also cleanses those walking in the way of sanctification from those sins of ignorance that they have had no opportunity to see and directly repent of, and should they die without a knowledge of these sins, the righteousness of Christ would be imputed to them, and they would be accounted holy, Christ being unto them sanctification as well as justification, with reference to those sins as well as with reference to those of which they have repented [having had a knowledge of them]. But the blood of Christ never cleanses from known sins that are not repented of and turned away from, so that persons dying in those sins cannot expect to be classed by the Lord among the pure and holy to share with them in the reward of the righteous.”
Therefore men are not saved without being sanctified, neither do they go to Heaven with their sins, nor is it necessary for Christians to undergo a moral change at the resurrection.
5. “How much sin must a person commit every day, in order that he can use the Lord’s prayer?”
Ans. We do not teach that men are obliged to sin to use the Lord’s prayer, but that the wording of that prayer shows that the Saviour designed it for those who, while trying to overcome, would sometimes need to be forgiven.
6. “Question 6: Can we keep the law? If so, can we not be sanctified? Or has God given us a law that we cannot keep? and if so, will he punish us for transgressing it?”
Ans. By the grace of God we can keep the law of God and be sanctified, so that there is no necessity of our being punished for transgressing a law that we cannot keep. But the heart of man is naturally perverse, and his mental and physical habits are a barrier against his walking in the path of obedience; therefore, though the grace of God is sufficient, we are slow to improve upon it by carrying out our convictions. Hence if we do not fully give way to hardness of heart, God, through love, afflicts us. He suffers long, knowing our frame and the difficulties we encounter; he waits for us to submit to him and accept his proffered help, for he cannot sanctify and save men against their wills and independently of their actions. The carnal heart being opposed to God and righteousness, is averse to self-examination in the light of God’s comprehensive rule of right, and is not anxious, or even willing, to yield to its claims. But by submission to God, and earnest endeavors by the grace of God to perform every known duty, seeking to know and do the whole will of God, we may come off conquerors in ascending the hill of holiness.
7. “Question 7: If it should take ten or fifteen years for a person to get clear of sin, would it not be instantaneous sanctification when he did get clear?”
Ans. The work that it would take ten or fifteen years to accomplish could not be called an instantaneous work,—the work of a moment.
Such is the nature of criticisms against progressive sanctification.
It is claimed that if growing in grace (2 Peter 3:18) means progressive sanctification, then Christ was a sinner, for he grew in grace. This reminds us of the mode of reasoning that mixes up the two laws to do away with the moral law. It is written, “Jesus increased in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and man.” Luke 2:52. In this case sin is not implied, but approbation. But not so of the grace by which we are sanctified and saved. To grow in that grace is to improve upon the favor that gives us victory over sin and enables us to advance in sanctification.
Again, it is claimed that if we apply 2 Peter 1:5, etc., to progressive sanctification, we must conclude that a person should not have any brotherly kindness, or love, till he has all the rest of the virtues mentioned in that passage. Here the objector overlooks the fact that Peter was writing to those who had the same faith that he possessed. Verse 1. He was addressing a general epistle to all Christians. Therefore those to whom he writes had made a start in all the Christian virtues, and they were to add to what they already possessed,—were to advance in holiness.
It is said that now is the time to prepare for Christ’s coming, and that we should not put off the work of preparation, etc. This we believe. But who are they that put off this work of preparation? Those who believe that the work of sanctification is progressive and is not finished, and who work earnestly by God’s grace to overcome and progress? or those who claim that the work of sanctification is instantaneous and perhaps accomplished, and see no special necessity for earnest effort to do what remains to be done?
Criticisms whose object is the overthrow of a theory, must, to be pronounced sound and logical, demolish the great principles and reasons on which that theory is based. Is this true of the criticisms we have examined? What grand reason or principle on which rests the doctrine of progressive sanctification has been shown to be unsound?
Before the doctrine we advocate is pronounced unsound and unscriptural, let the mighty pillars on which it rests be made to crumble under the tremendous weight of Scripture and sound logic. Let it be shown that sanctifying truth is not progressive in its manifestation, and that consequently sanctification is not progressive. Let it be shown that conversion is not a part of sanctification, and that the duties embraced in conversion may be performed in one moment. Let it be demonstrated that man does not co-operate with God in sanctification, or that if he does, the part he is called upon to act may by the grace of God be performed in one moment. Let our opponents prove that those who boast of perfect love and complete sanctification, have so advanced in the cultivation of the Christian virtues, in one moment, that they have no further occasion to overcome the contrary vices. Let all purifying trials be simmered down to one moment. Let it be shown that the sanctifying Spirit acts its entire part in the sanctification of men in one moment. Let the reasons we have presented, showing that instantaneous sanctification is a dangerous doctrine, be proved unsound, and let it be shown that the scores of scriptures, not simply one, two, or three, quoted to prove progressive sanctification have been misapplied. And lastly, let those who boast of complete and instantaneous sanctification prove that as the result of one moment’s effort, God working through them and for them, they are able to stand before the twenty-five tests of sanctification contained in the first article that has been criticised, and say, “I am clear.” Till this is done, let no one boast of instantaneous sanctification and entire exemption from sin.