The following, by W. A. Robinson, published in the Christian Advocate of Feb. 9, 1882, forcibly illustrates the Scripture injunction, “Keep thy heart with all diligence; for out of it are the issues of life:”—
Your discriminating editorial of the 12th ult. on Guiteau revived the memory of a case given me some weeks ago by a leading lawyer and prominent Judge. It is an illustration of your theory, that at the inception of this crime, “by turning away from it, he could have cast it out and resisted its fascination; but by voluntarily dwelling upon it, it assumed proportions of great magnitude.” Said the Judge, “It is exceedingly dangerous for a man to dwell upon the thought of any crime; for by brooding over it he is in danger of being impelled to its commission. To show how true this is, I will give you the facts in a case I was connected with a few years ago in this State.
“An express company was robbed of $14,500 in money; the package was taken from the office. Suspicion finally fastened upon a young man who was in the company’s employ; he was of an excellent family, and his life up to this time had been irreproachable. I was a personal friend of his father’s, and he sent for me to manage his defense. Knowing him and his family as I did, I firmly believed him to be innocent, and, with this conviction, labored for his acquittal. The evidence against him was purely circumstantial, and the testimonials to his uprightness of character were so clear and voluminous, that on their strength he was acquitted. A few weeks after the trial I was surprised to see him come into my office; he had with him a small valise, and asked to see me privately. We stepped into my consultation room, and as I closed the door he tossed the valise onto the table, and said to me, ‘There is that money.’ ‘What money?’ I said. ‘Why, that money which I took from the express company.’ I was astounded. ‘Why,’ I said, ‘surely you are not guilty.’ ‘Yes, I am,’ said he, ‘and I want you to take the money.’ I said to him, ‘Get right out of my office; I’ll have nothing to do with you.’ In great excitement he drew a revolver, and said, ‘If you do not take the money, I’ll put an end to my life right here.’ I thought it best to learn the whole story, and then do the best thing which suggested itself. I said to him, ‘Sit down and tell me how you were ever led to such a crime. You were in no need of money; why did you take it?’ He answered, ‘No; I was comfortably situated, had a good home, and all my wants were supplied; but one day when in the office the thought just occurred to me how easy it would be for me to take a package of money. I dismissed the thought with scarcely a minute’s consideration of it. In the afternoon I thought of it again, and for a week it came to me off and on until finally the morning I took the money it occurred to me again with great force, and in fifteen minutes afterward I had done the deed. As soon as it was done, and I found it couldn’t be undone without detection, I was strongly prompted by my conscience to confess it and restore the money. But I couldn’t endure the shame it would bring to myself and family; but my mental distress since the trial has become so great that I cannot be quiet any longer, and now if you can give me any advice which will help me, I want it.’ I finally told him I would take the money and restore it to the express company, which I did, with the understanding that the knowledge of the transaction was to be restricted to them, and he was not to be exposed. I then advised him, as he was a young man and was thoroughly penitent, and had evinced it by restitution, to go West and begin an honorable life anew. To this he at length agreed, and I bade him good-by. About three months afterward my door-bell rang violently at midnight. On answering it, behold, my ‘express robber’ was again before me. Said he, ‘Judge, it’s all over; I’m going home to confess my crime, and suffer its penalty. I stand before the community as an innocent man, when I know I am guilty, and I can have no peace of mind until I confess it.’ I could advise him no further. He openly confessed his crime and was sent to the Penitentiary.”
I have given the substance of the Judge’s narrative, which was given to illustrate the declaration, that it is exceedingly dangerous for any one to give entertainment to the thought of committing a crime. He who knows the secret springs of all evil has said, “The thought of foolishness is sin.”