AdventAI

THE LESSON FROM GUITEAU'S CAREER.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 8., February 21, 1882

The friends of the religious amendment movement show a singular facility in drawing arguments in support of their theory from almost every public occurrence. Even the assassination of President Garfield is made to furnish an argument in favor of the ‘proposed amendment. A. M. Milligan, in the Christian Statesman of Dec. 8, takes the position that Guiteau’s “inspiration” was not insanity, but his religion; and that he had “just as good a right to believe himself commissioned of God as had Mohammed or Joseph Smith.”

The reasoning that follows we condense thus: The Constitution plainly states that “Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion” or preventing the free exercise thereof; the District of Columbia is governed by laws enacted by Congress; hence in the District of Columbia any law punishing Guiteau for the free exercise of his religion in the assassination of President Garfield would be unconstitutional!

Mr. Milligan says:—

“Until the Constitution defines what it means by religion, and distinguishes one religion from another, no law enacted by Congress restraining freedom in, or punishing for, the free exercise of that which a person considers his religion, can be, in the strict sense of the word, constitutional. It is manifest that Guiteau joined the Oneida Community as an act of religion, and practiced their peculiarities as religious services. In the same spirit, impelled by the same evil influences, he shot the President, ‘believing that he did God service.’ Now I believe that Guiteau is sane, and cannot be justified or acquitted on the plea of insanity. I believe, moreover, that he understood the nature of his act, and is amenable as a responsible agent to the penalty which the violation of law imposes, but I believe that under a strict construction of the Constitution of the United States he cannot be punished. The law that would punish his act would ‘prevent the free exercise of his religion.’ This is really his plea, and to this moment he justifies his act as a religious obligation which he owed to God and his country. He disowns the plea of insanity, and refuses to be counted a fool.

“I do not justify the Constitution nor the deed committed by the assassin; but if the doctrine of the Constitution be correct, his act cannot be condemned. No government has a right to authorize a false religion or to guarantee to its subjects the right to dishonor God or violate his law under the name of religion. Government has no right to punish a man for his belief, but it has a right, and it is its duty, to restrain his acts whenever they violate either the first or the second table of the moral law of God. Until this government defines in its Constitution what is religion, in the understanding of this nation, the polygamy and the blood atonement of the Mormons, the licentiousness of the Oneida Community, and every other wild extravagance, even to the solemn murder of the best of Presidents, will be practiced in its sacred name. Guiteau richly deserves to die, but the Constitution which educated him to believe that he might murder the President under the delusion that it was an act of religion which could not be punished, needs to be amended.”

This is a revelation. We had never supposed the Constitution of the United States to be a refuge and a defense for polygamy and every other wild extravagance, even to the murder of the chief magistrate of the nation. Senator Edmonds of Vermont should have consulted Mr. Milligan before presenting to Congress his sweeping bill against polygamy; for if there is religious freedom in our land, and, according to the Constitution, men have the right to worship God according to the dictates of their consciences, then the polygamous Mormon must not be disturbed. But those who framed the religious-freedom clause of the Constitution never dreamed of the iniquity they were abetting. To them, the standard of religion was the old-fashioned Bible, and they would never have thought of throwing its sacred mantle around an assassin or a bigamist.