Crime and Drunkenness

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 7, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 10.

Read the full edition

Crime and Drunkenness.

It has frequently been asserted with great positiveness by temperance advocates that fully three-fourths of all crimes are caused by drunkenness, which assertion has been denied with equal positiveness by persons opposed to the temperance cause; and owing to a lack of absolute and certain knowledge as to the facts, people in general have come to accept this statement as only an opinion, and not by any means as a fact.
The Cincinnati Gazette having reiterated this assertion in a recent article, one of its subscribers, in a note to the editor, implicatively questions the truth of the statement by asking for the numerical proof. Being thus placed in a position where equivocation would be a square back-down, the editor dispatched an assistant to overhaul the record of the Cincinnati Police Court, and by taking the total number of criminals arrested during the past year, and obtaining from the judges under whom the cases were tried—and who of course would be most competent to decide the question—their opinions, derived from their own observation and the statements of the criminals themselves, to judge of the proportion of crimes actually caused by drunkenness. In order that these opinions might be obtained free from any concerted agreement on the part of the judges, the total number of cases for the last three months of 1881, with the names of the offenders, were obtained, and each judge was asked, separate and apart from the others, to make a thorough and minute investigation as to the facts, and each of these gentlemen signified his willingness to do so.
After a very complete and thorough examination on the part of the judges, the reporter, and the clerk of the police court, each working separately, and independent of the others, the results were obtained as we now present them to the reader.
The number of crimes committed for which arrests were made were as follows: Drunks, 521; disorderlies, 482; assaults and batteries, 460; vagrants, 255; larcenies, 295; malicious destruction of property, 57; carrying concealed weapons, 65; and miscellaneous, 241, making a total of 2,376; and the estimates of the judges, which wonderfully correspond in the aggregate, show of these 2,376 crimes, 1,938, 81 per cent of the whole, which were attributable to drunkenness.
The evidence thus obtained in a systematic and very ingenious manner, seems to be of a character calculated to substantiate this heretofore questionable assertion and to win public confidence; and we thus present it to our temperance friends.—Iowa State Register.